Q: Knocking and rpm revving high

asked by on August 14, 2016

My radiator fan was not coming on. I had a mechanic look at it and he said that he would re-wire the fan to the fuse box so that it could come on as soon as my car would start. But after he did this my car started revving to 4-5 rpm's and it would gain speed but it would take 10-15 seconds. On top of that when I tried to gain speed the engine started knocking after I would try to gain speed. Now when I start the car the engine would knock immediately and now when I push the gas the knocking becomes louder. When I returned the car to the mechanic he said I blew my engine because there was no oil but the day he rapaired my car he checked my oil and there was oil in the car. Do you think it's because there was no oil? Or could it be how he re-wired my car? Again the noise or revving with the high rpm didn't start until after he re-wired my car.

My car has 140472 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Cooling/Radiator Fan Motor Replacement $120.68 - $1412.28 Get a Quote
Car is slow to accelerate Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Hi there. Unfortunately, without being there to physically inspect the vehicle, it’s hard to pinpoint the precise cause of the engine failure. However, one thing I can say without hesitation is that rewiring your vehicle’s cooling fan was not the correct solution to your radiator fan problem.

Anytime a mechanic assumes that they can bypass an issue by rewiring it or going against the manufacturer’s recommended service manual, they are risking damage to other mechanical components.

My best advice is to contact a different mechanic, perhaps a local ASE certified mechanic, who can inspect the root cause of your radiator fan issue, the unresponsive acceleration, and also any damage that was caused to your engine.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Engine rod knock

Hello and thank you for contacting YourMechanic. The oil to use is a thick 15/40W oil for diesels. This oil is thicker than normal engine oil and can keep an engine from knocking for a little while. If the engine...

water is leaking from a metal pipe thats runs on top of the transmission how do i fix this

You most likely have a leak in the system. I have seen a lot of failures in the heater's hoses and connections for this model. You typically will need to perform a coolant pressure test with the engine cover in...

Gauges have gone dark

Hi there. Since your issue is intermittent this would lead me to believe you are experiencing a bad connection behind your dashboard. A loose connection between your light bulbs and sockets will cause this problem along with a fault in...

On interstate, after 15-20 seconds car loses acceleration

Hello. Thanks for writing in about your 2007 BMW 335xi. It sounds like the thermostat may be sticking. The thermostat needs to be checked and the cooling system needs to be checked to make sure that the coolant is flowing...

Headlight problems

It is common practice to replace both head light bulbs at the same time. The bulbs may have loose or burned connectors that should be inspected and replaced if bad. They would cause the bulb to fail quickly. Once the...

New battery losing power

When the charging system indicator comes on the majority of the cases are caused by a faulty alternator. I suggest having the starting and charging system tested by a technician. When the battery was installed a connection it may not...

What tools are needed to remove the exterior door handle?

Hello. If you have successfully removed the interior door panel, then you are off to a good start. The only tools that should be required to replace the exterior door handle are a set of screwdrivers and a regular socket...

Rear main seal leaking

Hi there. The only way to fix a rear main seal is to remove the transmission, pull out the old seal with a seal puller, and install a new one. It is an extensive procedure and needs to be performed...

Car only starts when pressing the gas pedal

Hi. The computer system that runs your engine has a memory system that requires the battery to keep it alive. If the battery is disconnected for any reason, the computer learns that specific idle, which is no the appropriate one....

Related articles

What Does It Mean When an Engine "Knocks"?
If your engine is making a knocking noise it means there's a problem. The wrong fuel octane, carbon buildup, and bad spark plugs can cause knocking.
How to Determine Compression Ratio
Whether Whether you’re building a new engine and you need the metric, or you’re curious to know how efficient your car uses fuel, you have to be able to calculate the engine’s compression ratio. There are a few equations needed...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Cylinder Head Temperature Sensor
Common signs include long cranking time, engine performance issues, and the Check Engine Light coming on.