Q: How Can I Tell If My Car Isn't Shifting Correctly?

asked by on December 01, 2015

How can I tell if my car isn't shifting correctly?

Car is hard to shift Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote
Car is stalling Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

The automatic transmission in most vehicles are designed to shift the gears for us rather than use a manual transmission and a clutch with a stick shift to change gears. If you have driven a manual transmission before then you know the challenge of starting off smoothly and knowing when to release the clutch to keep the engine from stalling and have a smooth take-off. When a manual transmission car is moving, you have to change each gear going up and down. There is full control of how and when to shift the car and if we make a mistake then the car jerks or cannot accelerate fast enough.

Now we have automatic transmissions to do most of the gear changes for us. There are specialized transmissions out there that give us some control over the shifting of the forward gears, but for the most part the automatic transmission shifting is done by the transmission control systems. Every vehicle is designed to have a powertrain that can propel the vehicle in the best and most efficient way possible with the most comfortable drive possible.

If you start the vehicle and put the transmission in reverse only to notice the transmission takes longer to engage or the gear engages harshly, the car is not shifting correctly. Another indication of a problem is if you are driving down the road and the transmission has a harsh upshift or downshift. Your engine might also start to get bogged down and stall when you come to a stop.

These are some of the signs you may have when you start to have transmission troubles with shifting. If you feel something is not right then most likely there is a problem and you should not delay getting it looked at. Sometimes getting a problem fixed early can keep a larger problem from happening.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Large EVAC leak.

Hello. If the gas cap is verified to be good, the most common culprits are the purge valve and charcoal canister. If you would need help having this checked, a certified technician from YourMechanic can come to your car's location...

Car loud with exhaust leak

If you removed the catalytic converter, then that may be the cause of your noise, since it works like a muffler to slow the exhaust down, and lower noise levels. The exhaust leak would need to be located to see...

The car doesn't shift into first gear while it works fine in reverse

The problem could be that the internal transmission pump is weak, or the transmission clutch seals are leaking. It sounds like the transmission will need an overhaul. I recommend having a transmission mechanic test the pressures and diagnose the...

Sequential shifting

Sequential shift mode allows you to choose when the transmission shifts, instead of the transmission control module (TCM) is making the choice for you. It's very easy to use, and there is no clutch pedal involved. First, choose the 'S'...

When engine warms up and goes in reverse, it shuts off

Hello there. This is a bit of a rare issue on the 1990 Chevrolet K2500. There are a few possible causes that come to mind with the issues going into reverse. The most common would be a shift solenoid, torque...

Engine turns off when the first gear is shifted

Hello. The most common cause of the car dying once it is put into gear is the transmission torque converter or the fluid level of the transmission. If there are leaks present from the transmission, I would suspect the fluid...

Truck will move in reverse but when in drive it will move a couple of inches and then stop moving

Hello there, many common faults will cause your 1999 Ford F-150 to not move when placed in gear. When transmission issues occur the first step is to check the quality and level of the transmission fluid. If the transmission fluid...

I'm trying to figure out if it's my transmission or axle (or both)

Hello. Typically an axle will not cause this unless it completely broke. If that occurred, you would have had an extremely loud noise followed with a grinding and knocking noise every time you tried moving the vehicle. It sounds like...

Replacing timing belt on a 2001 Ford Escape

Yes it is and you should change it right away, because mileage is mileage and time is time. That baby is 15 years old. They tell you that you are supposed to change the belts and they are only good...

Related articles

How Long Does Clutch Fluid Last?
The The usual answer to this is, forever. Of course, as is the case with many hard and fast answers, there are always exceptions. The reason that your car clutch fluid should last forever is that it’s a closed system....
How to Find the Source of an Oil Leak
Oil Oil leaks are a very common problem that affects many car owners. Virtually all modern engines use some sort of oiling lubrication system, and a compromise in the sealing of this system will result in an oil leak. Whether...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Universal Joint (U-Joint)
Common signs of a faulty u-joint include a squeaking noise, clunking sound when shifting, vibrations in the car, and transmission fluid leaking.