Q: Hard to shift gears in traffic jam

asked by on December 17, 2017

I have a manual transmission car. When I'm stuck in traffic, it starts to get harder to shift gears until it becomes impossible, it is stuck in the gear I am(any gear or neutral). It seems to happen when I use the clutch a lot. First they changed the clutch, it did not help. Then the whole gearbox was changed, still not good. Then I got the clutch cable changed which solved it for 2 weeks, then it started again plus I have a new symptom: the engine shakes when idling. I'm desperate now, it seems noone knows whats wrong...

Clutch is not working Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

The clutch and transmission on your vehicle are fairly straightforward systems. If virtually all of it has been replaced and yet it still doesn’t work, that is frankly a guarantee that the cause of the problem is faulty, inept, careless installation including the possibility that used parts were installed which then failed just like the ones replaced. A principal threshold issue is: were you given an understandable and credible diagnostic result? If the clutch was initially deemed faulty, exactly what was wrong with the clutch system? If there was never a diagnostic, and no explanation of WHY the work was done, essentially all that was done was just based on guesses. Although the mechanism on your car is not complicated at all (it really is incredibly simple), if the repair instructions (all of them; from the Factory Shop Manual) are not carefully and thoroughly adhered to, and if all parts are not installed with precision, you can have a result just like the one you are experiencing. If you want, we can take it from the top and DIAGNOSE the exact problem and then repair only that which is necessary and relevant to restoring proper function. If you desire that, please schedule an inspection via YourMechanic’s clutch/transmission diagnostic service page and the responding certified mechanic will get this resolved without any further nonsense. As far as the rough running of the engine, there are obvious possibilities, ranging from uneven compression due to sticking valves, faulty spark plugs and clogged injectors, to somewhat less obvious issues like intake manifold leaks. The mechanic who resolves the clutch issue can deal with the engine issue as well and will likely use a real time scanner to see exactly what the present engine operating parameters are; the diagnostic proceeds from there. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic because we want you to make the most of your repair dollars and help you to get the best possible results.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What’s the best way to access the TCM on a BMW X5 with the E70 setup? I’m hoping to avoid dropping the tranny.

I'm about to purchase a 2018 Kia Sorento with AWD. Does the AWD work in reverse?

All Wheel Drive (AWD) works in any gear the vehicle is in. There are two types of all-wheel drive: mechanical and electronic. The most common way of creating a capable, mechanical AWD system is by using three differentials. A differential...

Can a $2,500 car drive 30 plus hours and over 2,000 miles?

Hi there. That's very difficult to answer. The cost of a vehicle is not as important as the mechanical condition of the vehicle. If all systems are properly lubricated, the coolant system works correctly, all belts and hoses are tight...

I have a p0410 code yet my air pump does operate however the flow doesn't seem to be very strong?

There is probably a filter in the pump and yes the filter could block flow. However, before you consider a plugged filter, inspect the check valves; they will commonly get plugged up or stuck. The pump flow is minimal and...

Why did my 'E' brake and battery light came on at same time?

The battery light will come on when the event that the battery is no longer being charged. The 'E' brake (parking brake) light comes on when the fluid is low in the master cylinder or there is a pressure difference...

Electronic throttle control not working

This may be a sign of a failing throttle position sensor. This sensor is usually located on the butterfly spindle or shaft so that it can directly monitor the position of the throttle. It relays the position of the throttle...

After part replacements, spark plugs do not work - 1996 Lexus LX450

If you have a Check Engine Light on, first check for those codes to determine what engine management thinks is going on. If no trouble code, check the ignition fuse behind the driver side kick panel (carpeted panel at foot...

Possible broken front axle

Hello. A common giveaway of a bad tie rod or CV axle is grease leaking from the CV boot or the tie rod boots. Though, either component could be bad and a leak may not be present. It is best...

Mazda not starting.

If your engine is cranking over at a normal speed but not starting, your battery would likely not be the cause of the no start condition. If your car is not cranking at all, then yes, a battery with low...

Related articles

Top 10 Best-Selling Cars of 2016
Ford F-series pickup trucks, Toyota Camry, and Honda Civic are some of the best-selling cars of 2016 and all deliver on reliability and efficiency.
How to Buy a Toyota Prius
The Toyota Prius is one of the most popular hybrid models on the automotive market, and it comes with an array of perks. A Prius is more environmentally friendly than your average fuel-guzzling car, leaving less of an ecological footprint....
2012 Toyota Corolla vs. 2012 Honda Civic: Which One Should I Buy?
Compact cars are the unsung heroes, slightly larger than a subcompact, but not quite big enough to be classified as a mid-size sedan. These vehicles have a small wheelbase of no longer than 109 inches with between 100 and 109...