Q: Hard to shift gears in traffic jam

asked by on December 17, 2017

I have a manual transmission car. When I'm stuck in traffic, it starts to get harder to shift gears until it becomes impossible, it is stuck in the gear I am(any gear or neutral). It seems to happen when I use the clutch a lot. First they changed the clutch, it did not help. Then the whole gearbox was changed, still not good. Then I got the clutch cable changed which solved it for 2 weeks, then it started again plus I have a new symptom: the engine shakes when idling. I'm desperate now, it seems noone knows whats wrong...

Clutch is not working Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

The clutch and transmission on your vehicle are fairly straightforward systems. If virtually all of it has been replaced and yet it still doesn’t work, that is frankly a guarantee that the cause of the problem is faulty, inept, careless installation including the possibility that used parts were installed which then failed just like the ones replaced. A principal threshold issue is: were you given an understandable and credible diagnostic result? If the clutch was initially deemed faulty, exactly what was wrong with the clutch system? If there was never a diagnostic, and no explanation of WHY the work was done, essentially all that was done was just based on guesses. Although the mechanism on your car is not complicated at all (it really is incredibly simple), if the repair instructions (all of them; from the Factory Shop Manual) are not carefully and thoroughly adhered to, and if all parts are not installed with precision, you can have a result just like the one you are experiencing. If you want, we can take it from the top and DIAGNOSE the exact problem and then repair only that which is necessary and relevant to restoring proper function. If you desire that, please schedule an inspection via YourMechanic’s clutch/transmission diagnostic service page and the responding certified mechanic will get this resolved without any further nonsense. As far as the rough running of the engine, there are obvious possibilities, ranging from uneven compression due to sticking valves, faulty spark plugs and clogged injectors, to somewhat less obvious issues like intake manifold leaks. The mechanic who resolves the clutch issue can deal with the engine issue as well and will likely use a real time scanner to see exactly what the present engine operating parameters are; the diagnostic proceeds from there. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic because we want you to make the most of your repair dollars and help you to get the best possible results.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I switch between my cell phone and Uconnect, and vice versa?
If your cell phone is paired to your Uconnect system, you can switch between your phone and the system without losing your phone call. That way, if you’re on your cell phone and get in your car, you can seamlessly...
Car smoking and smelling
If the smoke coming from the tailpipe is white and has a sort of sweet smell, it is coolant getting into the exhaust system, due to one of the engine head gaskets being blown, and leaking coolant into one of...
Car abruptly stops in traffic, but engine still on - 2016 Subaru WRX
Hello. There may be a problem in your drivetrain causing such a hard stop. If your brakes were serviced recently, check to see if a fastener may have come loose and is causing the caliper (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/brake-caliper-replacement) to press against the...
Replacing driver's seat
Hi there, thanks for writing in. You can use the same bucket seat out of any GM truck whether it is a GMC or Chevrolet from the years of late 1989 all of the way up to 1998. This can...
After changing radiator and oil, car stalls when coming to stop. Is the motor damaged?
Hello. Stalling can be caused by many things. If the engine is no longer overheating, then it is unlikely that the stalling is directly related to the radiator repair. A few common causes for stalling when braking are a faulty...
Skyline GTR R33 Engine swap with Chevy 383 small block, will it fit?
With a large enough budget, you can get just about anything in there. You will need more than just an engine to make everything work like the engine control module from the donor vehicle with a wiring harness installed in...
Distributor
The distributor on the 1996 Accord has an integrated Cylinder Position (CYP) Sensor, Crankshaft Position Sensor (CKP) and Top Dead Center (TDC) Sensor. If you have replaced the distributor due to diagnostic trouble code P1382 setting, which involves faults with...
BRAKES KEEP NEEDING BLED
If your vehicle is equipped with anti-lock braking, you have to either bleed the ABS pump and valving (per Factory Service Manual instructions) or use a bi-directional scan tool to remotely actuate the ABS system during brake bleeding. Otherwise, in...
My car jerks when i put it on R/D and also there is a 2 seconds delay when i put it on reverse ( gear takes 2 seconds to engage )
The transmission has electronic controls as does the engine. It's possible there is an electronic issue. A faulty transmission control module can give symptoms like you are experiencing. The brake light switch (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/brake-light-switch-replacement) can also cause issues. On modern cars,...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Toyota Highlander Hybrid
You’re You’re likely already familiar with the much-celebrated Toyota Highlander, but did you know that Toyota has actually offered a hybrid version of everyone’s favorite crossover SUV since 2006? The 2012 Toyota Highlander Hybrid is one of the most exciting...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Farmer
If If you're a farmer, you know that what you need isn’t a used car – it’s a used pickup truck. How else are you going to haul around hay, implements, garden produce, fertilizer, and all the other things you...
How to Turn Off the Reverse Beep in a Prius
The The Toyota Prius is designed to shut off the engine when stopped as an energy-conserving measure. When the accelerator is depressed, it starts to back up, so you can go about your business on the road. When your Prius...