Q: Check Engine light comes on, mechanic replaced o2 sensor but light still comes on.

asked by on December 19, 2016

Check engine light comes on, mechanic ran diagnostic and said it needs o2 sensor replaced. He replaced it but light still comes on. Mechanic ran diagnostic again and said it still is showing bad o2 sensor but since he replaced it the problem must be a catalytic converter that is plugging up and should be replaced. Since replacing a converter is costly I want to make sure this is the problem. My question; could this be something else or does the converter need to be replaced? Second question, is it okay to run the vehicle if the converter is the problem?

My car has 122000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi there:

If the mechanic completed the O2 sensor replacement, reset the codes and the error code was triggered again, it is possible that the catalytic converter is damaged and needs to be replaced. However, it’s also very common for the electrical harnesses that power these sensors to become frayed, damaged or faulty; which can also trigger the check engine light. It’s not advisable to drive a vehicle with a damaged catalytic converter for extended periods of time, as it can cause damage to internal engine components.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car not driving straight.
If your wheel is not straight you could have a broken control arm or something else may be broken in the suspension. I would have the car checked out by a technician who can better determine the cause (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/brakes-steering-and-suspension-inspection).
Low idle and stalling
Hi there. This is a problem that comes up often on this engine. It is typically caused by a failing idle control valve or a dirty throttle body. If the throttle body is dirty then that will typically cause the...
Bolt problem
It is common for this to occur on this engine. It is typically due to corrosion caused by electrolysis. Once this occurs the bolt almost fuses itself to the metal around it. In some cases, using a penetrating lubricant can...
Opinion on cylinder deactivation
Cylinder deactivation on those cars, let's say a V8 engine, sometimes runs on 4 cylinders and sometimes runs on 6 or 8. It determines this through computer activation. The old systems are absolute garbage. GM had one on Cadillac, and...
I have a 2004 honda accord and my front door speakers don't work but everything else does how do I fix?
The first thing to check is to see if the radio has a fader function and front speakers are turned off. If set okay then you will need to try a known good speaker to see if signal is getting...
2001 Isuzu Rodeo Transmission is jumping high but doesn't pick up speed right away. What could be wrong?
Hi there. Generally speaking, when this type of problem occurs, its caused by one of two transmission issues. Either the torque converter is starting to fail or you have an inner leak or obstruction of transmission fluid, caused either by...
loud banging and clunking noise from rear driverside wheel consistently and worsens with turns. can feel the this through the seat
The noise could be suspension, wheel bearing, or axle/differential related if you have all wheel drive. All of those possibilities have to be examined to pinpoint the origin of the noise. If you request a vehicle noise diagnostic (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-is-making-a-noise-inspection), the...
Does my 2009 volkswagen jetta Wolfsburg edition 2.0t have a digital speedometer ?
The best way to determine if your vehicle has a digital speedometer is to check in the owner's manual. The owner's manual will tell you how to operate all functions of the vehicle as long as they are equipped with...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Dodge Durango
The The 2012 Dodge Durango is a more fuel efficient SUV yet still provides all of the room and power you need. The Durango can tow up to 7,400 pounds making it perfect for family outings and carrying lots of...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Dodge Journey
The The 2012 Dodge Journey is easy to drive, and it’s not so large that you will have a difficult time parking it. It’s an attractive vehicle that has the power you need whether you are hauling a full carpool,...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Farmer
If If you're a farmer, you know that what you need isn’t a used car – it’s a used pickup truck. How else are you going to haul around hay, implements, garden produce, fertilizer, and all the other things you...