Q: Opinion on cylinder deactivation

asked by on April 13, 2016

What's your opinion on cylinder deactivation?

Cylinder deactivation on those cars, let’s say a V8 engine, sometimes runs on 4 cylinders and sometimes runs on 6 or 8. It determines this through computer activation.

The old systems are absolute garbage. GM had one on Cadillac, and it was a piece of garbage. It fell apart and they run like junk. The new ones are completely different designs. They are all computer controlled and some of them work quite well so you get maximum power with the maximum gas mileage when you are just touring around at a steady speed.

But, they are very complex systems and when they break they cost a small fortune to fix. My advice is, if you want a good gas mileage, get a 4-cylinder car or a diesel. If you want power, get a V8 or the turbo charged car. But, don’t think you are going to get a giant past V8 that’s going to get a really good gas mileage with those type of systems. Because, I guarantee it, they’ll all end up having problems, breaking down when they are older. They are so complicated.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Noise coming from tires
Hi there. Diagnosing this issue would require a mechanic to take your vehicle on a test drive and determining what noise is coming from your vehicle. This issue maybe related to your tires being out of balance. A qualified mechanic...
Brake lights not turning off
Your brake light switch located under your brake pedal could be stuck or even electrically short to power, forcing your brake lights to stay on. Also, your brake lights themselves could be short to power as well which forces them...
Possible electrical issue in a 2004 Honda Pilot
It appears that you are having multiple and intermittent issues with your Honda Pilot. Following the dealer's recommendations of replacing the gear shifter cable will likely only solve one of your concerns. The issues you describe with your alarm may...
Car turned off completely during highway driving
In order for an engine to continue running, it must have three things. These things are compression, fuel, and ignition. If one of those three things goes away, the engine will no longer run. I would recommend checking your alternator...
When looking at the Truck Engine my fan spins to the left which way would I turn the bolt to loosen it on a fan clutch
Always loosen the fan in the same direction it turns. You may need to have the holder and large wrench. You may need to shock the fan to the left while holding the fan pulley. I usually leave the belt...
ABS, Trac Off, and Airbag light on after battery change.
You may have damaged the systems when last you disconnected and connected the positive cable to the fuse block and without using the battery ground. I would recommend disconnecting just the battery ground, and then leaving it off for ten...
Overheating - 1996 Saturn
Hey there. You will need to not drive the vehicle if it is overheating since you may do engine damage if you overheated it. Have the system pressure tested and leak detected to see if the water pump (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/water-pump-replacement) is...
Flickering dashboard lights, total light outage that comes right back on. Burning smell in car.
You may want to find a local repair shop that specializes in electrical issues. While I can't say if you actually had a fuel pump issue, I doubt the fuel pump is related to the lighting issue and burning smell....
Code P0451
P0451 (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0451-obd-ii-trouble-code-evaporative-emission-control-system-pressure-sensor-range-performance-by-valerie-johnston) will set if the PCM (powertrain control module) detects an incorrect, erratic, or otherwise improper voltage signal from the evaporative emission control system pressure sensor. The underlying cause is usually due to a defect in, or damage to,...

Related articles

How to Buy a Good Quality Gasket
There There are a wide variety of gasket types on a typical vehicle, from head gaskets which are installed between the cylinder head and the engine block to engine gaskets which seal out harmful elements and keep the engine safe...
How to Buy a Good Quality Cylinder Head
The The cylinder head is one of the single most critical parts of your car’s mechanics, and one part that can trigger the most engine damage if it becomes compromised. The cylinder head, along with the head gasket, sits on...
How to Replace a Cylinder Head Coolant Temperature Sensor
Signs of coolant temperature sensor failures include sluggish acceleration, hard starting, and a Check Engine or Service Engine Soon Light.