Q: Charging issue, New alternator/battery

asked by on October 14, 2017

Replaced the alternator in May on my Nissan Altima 3.5 V6 2008 because of battery and brake light turning on and off, car was working fine for a while then battery and brake light would intermittently turn on and off again. Got a yourmechanic to come diagnose and was told the battery needed replacement, got it replaced but after a week had the same issue come back. Got another diagnosis and was told alternator had a bad diode, got a replacement alternator from auto zone( remanufactured) but after 2 weeks car stalled and eventually died on me while driving, got another diagnosis and alternator not charging the battery after a few minutes, fuses were checked and was all good according to the mechanic. Now going to need to replace the alternator once again for the 3rd time in six months. What are the odds of getting two bad alternators in a row? Would like to know whether something else is causing the alternator to stop charging ? Any help or advice would be great. Thank you.

My car has 125000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi Christian. Thanks for contacting us tonight. An alternator is a mechanical system. Failure of an alternator is typically due to one of three sources. Either the internal components of the alternator fail (which is common sooner in refurbished alternators or aftermarket replacement components), the ground connection to the alternator is poor, the charging cables are damaged, frayed or poorly installed. In most cases, the alternator will fail when the efficient flow of electricity is compromised. Although it’s likely the most expensive option, the best way to resolve these issues is by replacing the alternator along with all charging cables that allow the system to work correctly.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Ran out of oil and engine knocked, is it broken?
Hello! Thank you for writing in with this question. First off, stop trying to crank the engine. It may have seized up and by continuing to crank it you will likely damage the internal engine components and make it a...
What does it mean if the Brake System Light comes on in the dash?
Of all the safety systems built into your car, the brakes are the most important. While the Brake System indicator should come on during startup, it should go out after a few seconds. If it does not, or if it...
How do you pair a cell phone with the HandsFreeLink system?
In order to make use of the convenience and enhance safety offered by the HandsFreeLink® (HFL) system in your car, you’ll need to first pair your phone. Thankfully, doing so is relatively straightforward. Here’s how to do it: Make sure...
Crunching / cracking sound when turning sharp right at low speeds
The noise is most likely an outer axle joint (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-axle-cv-shaft-assembly). The joint that makes the noise when turning right will be the right or passenger side axle (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/axle-cv-shaft-assembly-replacement). If it was turning left and the noise happens then the noise...
Yellow triangle and yellow brake light illuminating on dashboard
Hi, thanks for writing in. I recommend checking the brake fluid level and the brake fluid level sensor. These are more "logical", given recent service. Replacing the ABS is an expensive proposition. I would get an ABS reader on it...
Could the Traction Control System (TCS) lock your wheels?
Hi there. Your vehicle is designed to haul lots of weight and a trailer behind it. The noise could be from the traction control system (TCS) activating when in a turn. If a wheel speed sensor is not functioning correctly,...
Truck won't start in morning. 2nd day now. Battery seems good.
Since the symptoms changed when you touched the battery terminal, it leads me to believe you may have a poor connection and the main battery terminals. If they are badly corroded or have any small cracks, the terminal may be...
voltage warning light still coming on 30-45 seconds after car starts.
Nothing should be replaced until you have in hand a definitive diagnostic pinpointing the faulty segment of the car's electrical system. There may be too much voltage drop in the charging circuit, as well as elsewhere, but start with the...
Fuel burns and car jumps when stopped
Whatever is causing your car to run rough is probably also causing it to drink gas. Look under the hood for any vacuum lines that may be off or in bad condition. It's surprising how many problems you can solve...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Nissan Rogue
While While the Honda CR-V and the Toyota RAV4 generally get the most attention in the crossover utility vehicle (CUV) class, buyers should take a look at the 2012 Nissan Rogue. The second-smallest model in Nissan’s line of SUVs and...
A Buyer's Guide to the 2012 Nissan Titan
With With the 2012 Titan, Nissan continues its march into domestic territory. This model lives up to its name, but it’s also quite impressive inside as well. Even if you are in the market and wouldn’t normally consider a truck,...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Nissan Murano
The The 2012 Nissan Murano is a sleek crossover SUV that has all the modern amenities. It has ample interior space with a luxurious feel, and a driver oriented suspension. If you need a vehicle that can hold passengers and...