Q: Can failure of a transfer case cause damage to a differential?

asked by on November 28, 2016

This vehicle is AWD. The car broke down today and had to be towed to the dealer. They found that both the transfer case is bad AND that the rear differential axle seal has failed (there are no spots whatsoever in my driveway or garage). Because of recurrent problems with the transfer case in these cars, Mazda extended the warranty for transfer case repairs to 90,000 mi., so I'm protected there. But it will cost $2700 to repair/replace the differential. My question: Is it a coincidence that these problems occurred simultaneously, or could the failing transfer case have damaged the differential?

My car has 62000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi there. Based on the mileage of your vehicle, its possible that the seal could have gone out on its own. A dynamic seal (seal on a shaft) will last for up to 80,000 miles on normal conditions, however, this depends on the engine load and where the vehicle is driven. Dirt and contamination can cause the seal to prematurely fail and causing the oil to leak out of the differential. First check the differential oil level. If there is no oil, then the seal was leaking and leaked out all of the oil. If the level is full or slightly low but within range, then the differential could have failed from either overloading the gears or causing an over-speeding condition and then an instant stop (usually when off-road). Its possible for the transfer case to fail and make the differential have a jolt to break a gear, but its more common to have the oil leak out or the gears to over-spin. If you need further assistance with replacing a damaged differential, then seek out a professional, such as one from Your Mechanic, to help you.

Hello. There may be instances where the transfer case can cause issues with the rear end, as the two are connected via a driveshaft. If the transfer case fails in manner that causes a sudden impact or jolt to the drive train, it is very possible that the differential or rear end could sustain damage, as it is mechanically connected directly to it. In most cases this sort of issue would cause a problem with the ring gear or pinion, not so much with the seal. Usually a problem a the seal will result in a noticeable leak, which can result in damage to the differential, but only if the differential fluid runs low. In most cases an axle seal is simple to replace, however that can vary across makes and models. I would consult the shop and have them specify to you what the specific issues are, and explain to you why the differential needs to be replaced.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How Does the Hazard Switch Operate?
The hazard switch (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/4-essential-things-to-know-about-hazard-lights), (also known as the "emergency flashers",) is a vital part of your vehicle's safety system. The switch is typically located within easy access to the driver and has a red triangle located on the switch. The...
Fuel pump not installed correctly, gas smell.
I would have the car checked out by a technician. There could be a number of things that would cause a fuel leak. If you notice it leaking when you fill it up it could be the EVAP canister and...
Hesitation in second and third gear
I would recommend taking this to the dealership. There is a Technical Service Bulletin for the early Saab transmissions stating that there is a software update that can resolve this issue. I would have this issue taken care of sooner...
Traction Light on
It sounds like there is a serious problem in the traction control system. Fault codes need to read out to see what the Electronic Brake Control Module (EBCM) sees. For the traction control system to work properly, it needs to...
Oil not getting to the engine
Hello. If oil is entering the combustion chamber it will coat the spark plug and cause a misfire. Oil can do this if there is a failure in a valve stem seal or if there is a piston ring failure....
Car suffering a loss in power
If the issue seems to be in time with the crank pulley, then it may be a timing issue. This engine tends to have a history of misfire issues, typically from bad coils. I typically start by scanning the computer...
I have a broken water pump and now the car wont start without a jump. What could that be?
Hello. From what you describe I would say that your vehicle is experiencing 2 separate issues. A broken water pump (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/water-pump-replacement) is a serious problem, that can cause overheating and serious engine damage, but will rarely ever affect the vehicle's...
How to reset odometer
The mileage on an odometer can only be set by a state certified repair facility. You will need to have proof of the existing mileage. The repair facility would need to see the proof before they can adjust the mileage...
Will the idler pulley keep my car from cranking . 1999 Mercury Mystique
Hi - a failing idler pulley (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-idler-pulley) can certainly keep your alternator from charging properly, resulting in a dead battery, which would prevent the engine from starting of course. The idler pulley bearing may have been failing, or possibly a...

Related articles

What Are the Risks of Switching to Synthetic Oil in Older Cars?
Older cars usually have to use conventional motor oil instead of synthetic motor oil. Switching to synthetic can cause engine leaks or engine damage.
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Personal Assistant
As As a personal assistant, you have a lot of demands placed on your time. Often it’s important that you be able to get around town quickly, running a ton of errands, picking things up here, dropping them off there,...
How Long Does a Differential Output Seal Last?
The The differential is located either in the front or rear of your vehicle, depending on what make and model you drive and whether it is or front- or rear-wheel drive. When you turn your vehicle, the wheels need to...