Q: Black coolant - no oil

asked by on June 07, 2016

I drained the coolant in my car and replaced it with distilled water and some coolant flush. I went for a drive then drained that coolant again, it looked fine. still kind of pink/ red. I filled the cooling system back with distilled water and went for a drive again, came back and let the car cool. I drained that water and it came out black. There was no oil in it(I made sure that there wasn't) and it was just cloudy. The reason I know it isn't oil is because I put that water in a container for recycling and let it sit overnight, it has not separated and there is no sludge on the top. I filled the car back up with coolant to be safe and I have yet to see what color it is now. Do you have any Idea why it came out black? I also installed an aluminum water temperature adapter so maybe that has caused some rust. could it be that the distilled water has reacted with the hoses or aluminum in the car? In the manual, it says to not use water alone... Maybe that's why.

Cooling System Flush $201.32 - $237.92 Get a Quote

Hello. Black or cloudy coolant can be caused by excessive rust or corrosion, or contamination in the cooling system. If the cooling system hasn’t been flushed or serviced for a long time, it may take a few cycles of flushing to get all of the contaminants out. Black coolant can also be caused by worn hoses that have decomposed and have now begun to break apart and contaminate the cooling system. I would examine the condition of all the cooling hoses, removing them if possible, to also examine the internal condition of the hoses. If you need assistance, a certified mobile mechanic from YourMechanic can visit your home or office to inspect the problem and flush your cooling system.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car overheating.
The starter and alternator are not related to your engines cooling system in any way. The overheating starting after these repair might be a coincidence, unless something was disconnected or damaged during the repair. Sometimes we as technicians disconnect or...
Driver's side window fell
Greetings! I did not get your vehicle's engine size, but this concern plagues many vehicles. It seems the mechanical connection between the window glass and window regulator may have failed. In many cases, the mechanical connection can be repaired. More...
What size connecting rod bearing bearing do I need for a 2004 Toyota matrix xr 1.8L front wheel drive
You should look at the back of the original bearing for the size and part number. If you go to the dealer with your VIN number (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-decode-a-vin-vehicle-identification-number-by-jason-unrau) and engine number you should get the correct one. Unless your engine is...
valve tick on driver's side - 1971 Dodge Charger
Hello. This is very normal for nearly every car. When your car's engine is cold and has been sitting for a while, the oil that is brought to the top of the motor when the engine is running will slowly...
There's a lot of smoke coming from my exhaust pipe when I push on the gas or going fast
Hi there. Normally, when smoke blows from the exhaust while you're under acceleration it is due to worn out or damaged piston rings. If this happens while you're driving down the road under normal throttle, it could be caused by...
My car shows trouble codes P0133 and P0420
Hi there: It appears as if you've got a lot of miscommunication going on with your mechanic. Here are a few basics. First, anytime an error code is triggered, such as the P0133 OBD-II code (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0133-obd-ii-trouble-code-o2-sensor-circuit-slow-response-bank-1-sensor-1-by-blake-griffin) the issue needs to...
No reverse in transmission 1997 Chevrolet Express Van 1500
Hello - I believe you have a failure in the reverse input clutch (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/does-an-automatic-transmission-have-a-clutch) in the transmission. This could be caused by several components in this clutch, all of which will require removal and disassembly of the transmission to repair....
Fuel EVAP line that runs under car is kinked how do I know if it is leaking? Also can I drive it like that if it's not leaking?
Hi there. In most cases, an EVAP leak will create an OBD-II trouble code, which is the best way to detect an EVAP leak. By having a professional mobile mechanic complete a check engine light inspection (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/check-engine-light-is-on-inspection), they will be...
My car takes a 195 55 r15 but i currently bought 195 65 r15 what well be the affects and well it pass a safety inspection with big
The 195 65 R15 size has a 7% greater diameter than the stock tires. A consequence is your speedometer (which was calibrated to the OEM specified tire) reading will be inaccurate. For example, if your speedometer reads 65 miles per...

Related articles

5 Essential Things to Know About Gasoline
You You already know how much we depend on gasoline in the US. Even though there has been an increase in electric and diesel cars, gasoline is still the most used fuel in the US. However, there are a few...
How to Buy Good Quality Brake Pads
Brake Brake pads sound cushy - however they’re anything but soft and snuggly. These components attach to the brake calipers in order to stop the discs (also known as rotors). The calipers squeeze the pads against the discs, which are...
What Does the Cruise Control Warning Light Mean?
When the cruise control light in your car is orange, it is either determining the speed to maintain, or there is a fault in an electrical component.