Q: At red light, engine revved high and lurched forward

asked by on July 07, 2016

My new 2016 car is having transmission trouble. When I stopped at a light, my car wouldn’t engage in Drive. The engine revved very high and was lurching forward, kind of like hiccups. Fortunately there were no cars in front or behind my car. If there had been, there would have been an accident and I would have been hit on both ends. Even though it finally did engage, I don’t feel safe driving it. Before I take my car to the dealership, can you please give me your advice and a diagnosis. Thank you.

Hi. That’s a scary situation you were in. I’m glad you didn’t get into an accident. Okay, it seems like the new CX5’s have been having transmission issues for the past couple years now. Some of the new transmissions have been known to give out quickly, not even a thousand miles into being driven. Many CX5 owners have had similar occurrences and had it replaced under warranty because they all were new CX5’s. It is likely that the transmission is faulty.

The only other things that I’ve seen in my experience which will cause that drivability concern is that something was spilled on the gear shift which contaminated the shift circuit. I doubt this is your case but make sure that there’s nothing spilt around the shifter.

This is a serious concern, I’d suggest having the vehicle looked at in person by a certified mechanic who can diagnose the rough driving symptoms you’ve experienced in order to get this fixed.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Noticed rubbing noise from transmission after replacing bearings and lug studs.

Hello. This is tough to diagnose without hearing the sound specifically, as the transmission should not be rubbing on any other components in the vehicle. I would recommend checking the driveline components to be sure there are no loose or...

Car abruptly stops in traffic, but engine still on - 2016 Subaru WRX

Hello. There may be a problem in your drivetrain causing such a hard stop. If your brakes were serviced recently, check to see if a fastener may have come loose and is causing the caliper to press against the wheel...

Toyota Corolla vs. Scion IM

On that one, it's a toss-up. Toyota makes Scions. That was an experiment they had--"let's call these little cars Scions." They shut down Scion and now they are going to call all of them Toyotas. They are both good cars....

Related articles

What Is the Difference Between a Diesel and a Gasoline Engine?
Gasoline and diesel engines use similar components but ignite fuel differently. Gasoline engines use spark plugs, while diesels rely on compression.
What Does an Engine Inspection Entail?
An engine inspection is the first step in diagnosing engine problems. A pre-purchase engine inspection helps you know if a used car is a good deal.
How Engine Timing Works
Your Your car engine consists of a number of rapidly moving parts, including a crankshaft, camshaft, pistons, engine valves, rods and pulleys. As the piston moves up and down, the valves move correspondingly, in and out. The crankshaft spins, and...