Q: Whining during acceleration with high RPMs, in lower gears and overdrive

asked by on May 24, 2016

I have a high-mileage vehicle with around 200,000 miles on it. When I try to accelerate, the car starts making a whining sound and RPMs get higher than they should. The whining sound is noticeable in lower gears as well as in overdrive. But, when in drive, it runs normally. I took it to a mechanic and I was told that I should get the transmission rebuilt and that the issues are due to the planetary gearset. I don't know what to do as this is a car with so many miles on it. Do you have any suggestions? Also, would it damage the car if I didn't use the overdrive but only drive?

Car is making a noise Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

I agree with the mechanic that checked it. It needs to have the transmission overhauled. I cannot make the decision if you should get it done or not, since it is a very expensive repair and may exceed the value of the car. If you want to have this issue verified in person, consider YourMechanic, as a certified technician can come to your car’s location and diagnose your vehicle’s transmission noise before you make any major commitments.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

How many miles can I drive on empty?

Every vehicle is a little different when it comes to how many miles you can drive when your low fuel indicator first comes on. The fuel gauge is an estimate of how much fuel you have in your fuel tank....

P0306 code misfire

Hello there, many common faults will cause a cylinder 6 misfire in your 2001 Chevrolet Impala. The most common faults are the spark plugs, plug wires, fuel injectors, vacuum leak, fuel pump, or low cylinder compression. A qualified Technician such...

So that ground issue would cause it to keep burning computers and if the mechanic wasn't compitant he wouldn't think to fix the sh

High resistance grounds or "poor connections" are different than a dead short. To know whether or not a specific short circuit, in wiring or a device, could potentially damage the PCM, it is necessary to know exactly where in the...

Gas leaking

Hi there. Considering the age of the vehicle, it may be equipped with a metal gas tank. Have an experienced technician inspect the vehicle for leaks and replace any components that show rust or corrosion.

overheating quickly, busted hose from coolant tank and will not hold antifreeze.

Hi. The usual cause of a hose to split like that is the hose being old and the rubber of the hose not holding the pressure of the coolant system causing it to split or buster. This hose is either...

Trouble starting in the morning.

Trouble starting in the morning could be a sign of worn secondary ignition components; spark plugs, wires, cap and rotor. As for the shaking and jolting the first thing I would suspect would be motor/trans mounts that have torn and...

Whining sound during acceleration and fourth gear not working on a '92 Ranger

Since you've said it doesn't do the fourth gear but can do other gears, the bearings in the transmission are worn out. You might change the fluid in the transmission and put in heavier weight, maybe full-synthetic gearbox oil, and...

can the neutral safety switch be bypassed on my car??

The neutral safety switch is built into the transmission selector switch, and the power from the ignition switch goes straight through the switch when you are in park and neutral to the starter motor solenoid. There is no good reason...

Transmission slipping at third gear

There are a couple of possible issues. Looking at Ford's technical service bulletins, possible issues range from water intrusion in a sensor to a possible warped separator plate between the valve body and transmission case to possible internal wear in...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Chevrolet Silverado Hybrid
If If you’re looking for a half-ton pickup truck that also gets great gas mileage, look no further than the 2012 Chevrolet Silverado Hybrid. While it has the towing and carrying capacity you’d look for in any regular truck, it...
5 Signs Your Car Isn't Shifting Correctly
Improper shifting is a sign of car transmission problems. The solution might be simple or complex, but get it inspected to avoid expensive repairs.
The Best Used Cars to Buy for Senior Citizens
Everyone Everyone needs a way to get around. You need to get groceries, get to doctors’ appointments, visit with family and more. However, senior citizens have very different needs when it comes to buying a used car than other demographics....