Q: What Causes Shock Absorbers Or Struts To Leak Or Otherwise Fail?

asked by on November 17, 2015

What causes shock absorbers or struts to leak or otherwise fail?

Shock absorber/strut life depends on how and where the vehicle is driven. Original equipment shock absorbers/struts are carefully matched to the vehicle springs and bushings to provide the best ride comfort and control. As the ball joints, control arm bushings, and other suspension components age, the energy built up in the springs of the vehicle is controlled less by the friction of these joints and bushings, requiring more control from the shock absorbers/struts.

Normal suspension systems are called passive suspension systems. Passive systems have either a firm or a soft ride. Their height varies according to mechanical forces on the suspension and they do not adjust to these changes.

The major purpose of any shock or strut is to control ride and handling. The springs support the weight of the vehicle; the shock absorbers control the actions and reactions of the springs. Various styles of dampers are in production, hydraulic, gas-charged, air-inflatable, magneto-rheological fluid, and electronic-controlled to name a few. For the purpose of this discussion, gas-charged dampers will be covered.

The majority of today’s vehicles use gas-charged shocks/struts. Pressurizing the oil inside the shock/strut helps smooth the ride over rough roads. This pressure helps prevent air pockets from forming in the shock absorber oil as it passes through the small passages in the shock.

Even under normal conditions on a smooth road, shocks can cycle an average of 1,750 times for every mile traveled. This can add up to almost 9 million cycles in 50,000 miles and that is why inspection of suspension components are so important.

When a shock or strut is cycling and exchanging fluid between chambers, it is generating heat. This heat is produced because the unit is changing the movement of the suspension into thermal energy. The solution for managing this excess heat is nitrogen gas. The gas chambers in the shock or strut keep the shock oil under constant pressure, which reduces foaming. If the gas leaks out of the chambers, the unit will “fade” and not perform as intended. Note that the unit will not leak externally. Instead, the nitrogen will form tiny bubbles in the oil. Since nitrogen gas is compressible and is much thinner than the oil, the unit starts to fade and provides much less resistance and ride control.

The valve size is not constant on most shocks and struts. By using metal discs and springs, a valve can change the size of fluid passages depending on the type of rod movement. The discs and springs in the valves can suffer from metal fatigue due to the constant movement of the suspension and fluid, which can lead to wear and handling problems. This type of wear can’t be seen with the naked eye.

The seal between the piston and bore is one area of wear. The seal must prevent fluid from flowing between the two surfaces without creating excessive amounts of friction. If the seal allows too much fluid to pass, it will influence how the valves perform. Poor sealing surfaces will cause the unit to leak. If the pitting or lost chrome plating is large enough, it can damage the seal, which can lead to water and debris getting into the unit and damaging the valves and piston seal.

If the outside of the shock body is damaged in any way due to road debris or collision. If rubber bump stops show signs of contact, a shock could be damaged or the vehicle might have been lowered or raised excessively.

A preliminary shock test with the car on the ground is the bounce test. Push down hard two or three times on the fender at each corner of the vehicle. After the fender is pushed down, it should oscillate only about 1.5 cycles and then settle.

The bounce test only checks the first stage of shock/strut operation. A failure in the second or third stage valves will not be evident from this test. So even if a shock passes the bounce test it still might be defective.

The bounce test or looking for cupped tires only highlights worst case shock/strut damper failures. Evaluating worn shocks/struts is best done by driving the vehicle over variety of roads. Shocks/struts do not often fail at the same rate. Usually one damper has a problem, requiring the replacement of both.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Rear suspension creaking on a '02 Mercedes C180

The problem is that, since it's a Mercedes-Benz, they used to make cars with grease fittings. Now there are no grease fittings, but just rubber bushings and metal pieces. Your Mercedes is 13 years old. As they get older, that...

Overflow tube in the front differential is leaking oil constantly on a 2014 GMC Sierra 1500.

Disconnect the vent tube on the differential and blow through the tube on the differential. If you are unable to blow through it, then the differential is creating too much pressure and pushing out the oil through the tube. I...

Leak caused by corrosion on throttle body terminal

Hello. There are some fairly sensitive electronics inside the throttle position sensor (TPS) housing. They are also not engineered to be easily disassembled for repair either. Unless you are quite experienced at unsoldering and soldering printed circuit board connections, I...

Related articles

When to Replace Front Struts
Know the signs of front struts in need of replacement and when to take your car in to have them fixed.
How to Troubleshoot a Car Pulling to One Side
If your car pulls to the left or leans to one side, check that your tires are all the same size, suspension parts are even, and if springs are bent.
Is it Safe to Drive With an EVAP Leak?
While it is safe to drive with an EVAP system leak, it causes excess car pollution. Fixing the problem is often as simple as tightening the gas cap.