Q: Water pump is leaking, do I need to replace the timing belt, too? The car also has a misfire on cylinder 3.

asked by on October 27, 2016

I brought my car in to the shop for a valve cover gasket replacement (my dad was gonna replace my wires and found a bigger problem), and today they called saying it's leaking a little oil, but my car is "known for that"... And my water pump is leaking and when they replace that instead, they need to do the timing belt, too. This is going to cost $900. I'm really wondering if I should bother. The issue I was having was the engine misfiring every time I stepped on the gas and the code I got was misfire in cylinder number 3.

My car has 235000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Timing Belt Replacement $318.59 - $1516.66 Get a Quote
Spark Plugs Replacement $113.11 - $716.47 Get a Quote
Fuel Injector Replacement $400.56 - $3968.30 Get a Quote
Engine is misfiring Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hi there. If the engine has too many miles on a timing belt, then a timing belt is suggested for replacement. The misfire for cylinder 3 could be caused by a spark plug failure, fuel injector failure, or a problem with the cylinder.

First, check for the fuel injector. Start the engine and disconnect the harness to the fuel injector for cylinder 3. If the engine sounds different, then the fuel injector was working. If the engine has no difference in sound, then the injector was not working and needs to be checked.

Next, check the spark plug for a solid blue / orange spark. If the spark is weak, the plugs and wires need to be replaced as a set.

To check the cylinder if it is getting hot enough to burn fuel, put a compression tester on cylinder 3 and crank the engine over. There should be more than 130 psi.

If you need further assistance confirming the misfire diagnosis, then a certified technician from YourMechanic, can come to your car’s location for a second opinion on the car.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the rear window and side view mirror defroster?
The rear window and side view mirror defroster will provide extra visibility through the rear window and the side view mirrors when they become foggy. To turn the defroster on, press the Defroster button, which is located on the middle...
Service Stabilitrak light came on
The only way to see what the problem is to scan the computers on your car. Stabilitrak is tied in with the ABS system and provides braking to specific wheels when the vehicle is losing control. This system can reduce...
Starter parts
Hello. You will need all of the bolts for the intake manifold, intake manifold gaskets, and starter bolts. The bolts must be replaced because they are made from aluminum, and are designed for one-time use. Gaskets should always be replaced...
Carburetor needs tuning
The fuel accelerator pump is most likely bad and not pumping extra fuel during acceleration. The carburetor needs to be replaced (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/carburetor-replacement) or overhauled if you can find a mechanic with the experience to overhaul carburetors. I recommend having a...
Knocking sound when idling or stopped 1993 Chevrolet Lumina APV
Hello - the rhythmic knocking (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/what-does-it-mean-when-an-engine-knocks) you hear could be something driven by the serpentine belt (i.e. AC compressor) or the belt itself. It is also possible that this an internal noise - like the timing chain (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-long-does-a-timing-chain-last), which is...
We are replacing rhe water pump and the special tool is not working it just keeps slipping the water pump is very rusty need help
The replacement of the water pump on your vehicle is more complex than the average vehicle and does require a special GM tool (J 38816-A Water Pump Remover & Installer), therefore if you desire you can request that a certified...
Ripped cv boot
Driving with an axle boot that is torn will cause the internal lubricating grease to get washed out of the joint and dirt to get into the joint. If you have to make a trip it should be able to...
05 ford explorer cranks wont start have spark fuel pump is workin what else cld it be??
Hello, thank you for writing in. There are several other tests that you will want to run on the vehicle, or have tested. To start, although you do hear the fuel pump running, the fuel filter or a line may...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy for Towing Light Loads
Towing Towing is tricky business and depending on the weight you’re dealing with, it really determines what vehicle is best for you. If it’s light loads you’re looking at towing, we’ve put together a list of the top five cars...
How Long Does an Oil Filter Housing Gasket Last?
Oil Oil is one of the most important parts of any engine due to the lubrication that it can provide. The internal parts of the engine need a lot of lubrication in order to stay working as they are supposed...
The 5 Safest Used Cars You Can Buy For Under $20,000
The Subaru Legacy, Honda Accord, Ford Fusion, Chevy Volt, and the Volvo XC60 are five of the overall safest used cars you can buy for under $20,000.