Q: Transmission problems

asked by on January 17, 2017

I recently took my car into the honda dealer to have them diagnose a leak coming from my power steering reservoir. That part turned out to be a simple fix- replacing one of the return hoses. They did an inspection of the car along and I had them diagnose the transmission with it and told my that my differential was "bad" and that it is wearing out my bearings. They told me that the transmission will probably go out within the next few months and that it needs to be replaced. I havent noticed any problems with the transmission such as leaks or gears slipping. A few days before this I had another shop do an inspection and the only thing they told me about the transmission was that the fluid needed to be replaced. Im just wary of the dealer because the other shop didn't find a problem with the differential but I also didn't have the first shop to a full diagnosis of the transmission. How do you think I should proceed?

My car has 138000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Car is making a noise Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

A diagnostic is only meaningful if there is a specific identification of a part or parts that have failed, are worn out, defective or the like. The bearings in the differential that you refer to are not visible for inspection, even if the axles are removed from the vehicle, which I presume didn’t happen because removal of both axles is involved. Thus, their mention of bearing failure is nothing but a guess. One way to inject some rationality into something like this is "get it in writing". In other words, if a mechanic cares to offer you a diagnostic get the result in writing so that you can then evaluate what is being claimed. You’re dealing with a very technical subject and whatever they "say" is going to be hard to parse and pin down unless it is in writing and you can then, at your leisure, see if it makes any sense. One thing of concern is the relatively low mileage on the vehicle. One-hundred thirty-eight thousand (138,000) miles on a Honda transmission is not a lot and if you are the original owner and the car was not abused, I would not expect the transmission to be worn out. So, the next person who says there’s a problem with the transmission, ask them to write down the specific Diagnostic. If they refuse or even balk at the request, that means there is either nothing wrong with the transmission or they fundamentally lack interest in your problem, of course, in either case your task is to simply find somebody else who can help you. If you are detecting noise from the transmission, do get it investigated. Obviously, a certified mechanic, dispatched by YourMechanic can come right to your location if you request a noise diagnostic and that responding certified mechanic will get this resolved for you. If you have further questions or concerns related to this incident, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

When put in drive, transmission automatically shifts to park

Hello. Since the car is still relatively new, I do not have any information on this problem at moment. If you took it to the dealer, then they are aware of the problem and currently do not have a fix...

Misfire in cylinder one

The cylinder pressure does not tell me anything about any of the other cylinders pressure. Also, was a wet and dry test or a cylinder leakage test done to show what valve is bent or burned. I feel the engine...

Leaking coolant

First of all I'm glad to hear you are just using water. I always advise customers to use just water if they are experiencing a leak and can't get it fixed right away. My question is did the pressure gauge...

Power window does not go up

Hello, there are multiple reasons the window is no longer working. The first thing that you could check is your fuses. if the fuses are good then it could be the window regulator, the window motor, the switch or wiring...

Brake issue..

With the vehicle off, pump the brake pedal until all of the assist has been diminished. This will empty the brake booster. Upon pumping, the pedal should become more and more stiff until it feels like you are almost stepping...

I have a strong burnt metal smell.

Most of the time, bad smells indicate leaks. Oil, coolant, or brake fluid can leak onto hot surfaces and cause some really potent eye burning type smells. But in your case, I'm suspicious of the brakes. If you have a...

What’s the proper way to disconnect the battery

In normal operation, your battery should recharge while the engine is running (the alternator should supply all the power needed). However, if the car has set for some time, it’s possible that the battery may be low. To charge it,...

Is it common to have such play in steering rack?

Hello. It is common to have very little play in the rack, but it should not be much. If there is some noise coming from the rack, then it needs to be replaced. The rack you have was more than...

How do I know which O2 sensor to change when it sets a code for o2 sensor? 2000 Jaguar S-type

Hi - the description for each Check Engine problem code contains the clues : for a given code - P1647 for example - the description is "Bank 2, Sensor 1". This means the first sensor in the exhaust system -...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy For a Graduation Gift
Your Your little bundle of joy has grown up and on the cusp of entering adulthood. Graduating is a milestone, and you want to reward their hard work and show how proud you are. Buying a used car is a...
How Does Traction Control Work?
Traction control is a car safety feature that prevents wheels from spinning on low-grip surfaces. Electric sensors in your car make the system work.
How to Check Your Car’s Differential Fluid
Ever Ever since you got your driver’s license, you’ve been to told to check your engine oil. But what about the fluids underneath your vehicle? If you’ve got a rear-wheel drive, four-wheel drive, or all-wheel drive vehicle, chances are, you...