Q: Stripped lug nut/unable to change tire

asked by on June 25, 2017

I had a blow out on my back right passenger side tire. I had my insurance send out a repair man to come fix the tire. The man worked on it for about 20 mins, then said he was unable to change the tire because one of my lug nuts was stripped. Prior to this blowout, all of my lug nuts were fine. So the repairman states that I have to have it towed. So he ends up towing it 65 miles to my house and I pay $250. The next day, I take it to the shop and they are unable to get it off because of the same issue. Again, had two other repairmen look at the car and they use automatic lug removers, still no luck. I contacted my insurance to file a damage claim on the repairman who damaged the lug nut, but they said they can't send a rental to me until they follow up on the company they sent to me which is bs. Questions: how can I get this one lug nut off so I can change this tire?? Is there something I can buy from autozone or Walmart that can act as a grip to take this thing off?? Please help me.

My car has 210529 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Tighten Wheel Lug Nuts $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

Hello, thank you for writing in. Locking lug nuts would cause every wheel to require a special socket in order to remove the tire. These are often aftermarket, but if you have a set on the car, this may have been the cause of that particular lug nut becoming damaged. With that being said, if you simply have a damaged lug nut, there are a few tricks you can do in order to remove the wheel. One would include welding on a socket in order to be able to grip the lug nut. Not many technicians are equipped or willing to do this however, particularly when insurance is involved. A second includes tapping a socket onto the lug nut with a hammer in order to jam it onto the nut. This WILL damage the wheel, the nut, and your socket. It can also break the socket, and under pressure that metal shrapnel will fly into the air which is incredibly hazardous. Again, this is why most technicians are not willing to do it. Double check that you are not dealing with a locking lug nut (possibly by making sure you can remove another one of the tires with a normal socket), and then proceed to find a technician who is confident they can remove it. To have one of our technicians assess the issue, contact our service department.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Hi I wanted to ask since my car has been shutting off every time I use it and and when I turn it on the VDC off is light on? I thought it can be the cam sensor but I want to make sure if it’s that

I received a P0700 and P0750 code which required me to change the transmission Solenoid Pack. I put a new one in

You should have replaced the filter and fluid when replacing the solenoid pack. If you did then you may have internal issues with the transmission that require the transmission to be overhauled due to internal seals leaking on the clutch...

My car makes a loud knocking noise when I accelerate put four quarts of oil knocking now comes and goes

Claimed by Kevin Gainer

Loss of power with flashing engine light

What you are describing sounds like a dirty or faulty mass air flow sensor. The mass air flow sensor monitors air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected into the motor. This sensor relays vital information...

when i start my rav4(1997) the rpm goes high for about 5 min althought that wasnt occur before a period of time ,, what might be t

Hello, thank you for writing in. There are several causes for high idle after starting. The first thing to consider (although it has its limits), is that the engine does need more fuel when cold. This is why all cars...

Misfire in Cylinder 3

Engine misfires can be caused by many different problems and are generally caused by either a spark or fuel issue or in some cases, a combination of both. Spark related problems generally will result from things like ignition coils, crankshaft...

Not getting heat when idling

Of course the system has too be coming up to operating temperature in order to get good heat. If it isn't, you will need to replace the thermostat. But if the thermostat is good and the engine is coming up...

Towing alarms stays on

This vehicle should come equipped with the button to turn off the towing alarm. The owners manual will show where the button is located in picture form. With the alarm staying on, this may indicate a wiring issue or that...

buying for 22,000.00

That is a very tough question to answer without being able to see the vehicle first hand. That is a lot of miles, but if it was mostly highway miles, that isn't so bad. If it was a lot of...

Related articles

How Do I Take Care of My New Tires?
You’ve You’ve equipped your car with a brand new set of tires, replacing the old set of worn out rubber. They were noisy, and every time you had to brake hard, you were losing traction. Now you’ve spent your hard-earned...
All About All-Season Tires
Depending Depending on the climate you live in, season changes can be slight or they can be extreme. Some areas of the United States have very temperate climates with a rainy season and a hot season. Others have a short,...
Is It Safe to Drive With a Bubble in Your Tire?
If you see a bubble in your car tire it's a problem. A tire with a bulge in the tread or sidewall is not safe to drive on and must be replaced.