Q: stiff gear change

asked by on June 30, 2016

I recently bought an audi a3 fsi. soon after I epc warning light remained on and at times had trouble starting. after diagnostics, sensors and connectors replaced the problem was dirty oil. the system was cleaned and oil replaced. I now have the problem of when the engine is cold it is difficult to get into first gear and reverse goes in with a big clunk. the other gears are also stiff. when the engine is warm the problem is not as bad but it is not the ease and smoothness as before. could this be associated with the recent work carried out?

My car has 126000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Hey there. One of the problems associated with buying a used car is having accurate data on how the previous owner maintained the vehicle. When you mentioned that after diagnostics were completed, that the technician discovered that dirty oil was the problem it seems pretty evident that routine service and maintenance may have been an issue with the previous owner. It definitely raised a red flag with me.

However, what typically doesn’t show up on a diagnostic check is what damage the dirty oil may have caused to the engine/transmission or other components inside including gaskets, o-rings, or gears. Oil works best when it has reached an operating temperature, which is most likely why you’re having problems shifting when the car is cold and why when you shift into reverse initially you hear that "BIG CLUNK"; and when the car heats up, it becomes smoother.

The one thing that dirty oil does a good job of however, is masking mechanical problems inside the engine and transmission case of a manual transmission. It’s quite possible that changing the oil simply brought to life the damage that had been done previously because of wear and tear and lack of proper maintenance. Having 126,000 miles on your manual transmission is about when you’re due for a transmission inspection.

Let us know if the problem smooths out over the next week or so. If not, a good road test and diagnostic check by a qualified mechanic can give you a good starting point for fixing your shifting issue. Thanks for writing into us today! I hope your problems go away sooner rather than later.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Check Engine Light is on - 2003 Honda Accord

Hello. If the issues appeared when using the AC and defroster, then they are likely related to that system. In most cases, the AC / Heater does not use vacuum lines as a part of it's operation, so a vacuum...

Cannot shift from Park : have to use override-trick of pulling on shift lever while turning key.

The shift lock actuator is actuated when you push on the brakes. If the brake lights do not work then it will not release the shift lock. Check the brake lights to make sure they work properly. If they do...

Coolant circulation issues Impala LS 3.8L.

Hi Adrian. Thanks for contacting us today. Typically, when a water pump goes bad, it's the inner seals that fail, which leads to bearing failure and overall water pump failure. This will produce a slow leak of coolant. This video...

Related articles

Can I Use Synthetic Motor Oil in My Brand New Car?
Changing oil on time will help protect your engine from damage. Synthetic motor oil will likely work, and may actually be required, in your new car.
A Guide to Motor Oil Additives
Motor oil contains various additives to make it perform better. Conventional and synthetic oils both contain additives which help prevent engine wear.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Differential Gasket
If you find traces of oil on the underside of the differential, puddles of fluid, or whining sounds, you may need to replace the differential gasket.