Skip the auto shop - Our mechanics make house calls

Q: Should I have a massive cooling system replacement done?

asked by on

Engine overheated after never ever ever overheating. Water came out (I believe) of the radiator cap. My bad mechanic (who seems to just not want to work on my truck) said he wouldn't touch it unless I agreed to a 1200 dollar cooling system replacement. Wouldn't explain a specific problem, and the engine was still hot when he gave me the ultimatum. Before I left he put in a new radiator cap. I took the truck to my old mechanic (who I like) and said it had overheated and that the former mechanic wanted to replace the water pump and everything related. He came up with as price of 860, but seemed to focus on a leak in the timing cover gasket. Seems to be a "while we're down there you might as well replace the x and y" etc. I caught a doubling of labor charges on their write up and am sleeping on the decision. Bottom line: I'm a girl. Everyone says it's too big a truck for me. Bottomer line: I love this truck. Any advice? How long can I drive like this? Thanks!

My car has 180000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

To answer your last question first, if the truck is "overheating", you can’t drive it at all, not even to a repair facility. Overheating, if severe enough, has the effect of warping the cylinder heads, block, and manifolds. Even if you don’t warp the heads and block, if you end up with a warped exhaust manifold, you can get an exhaust leak, which is labor intensive to fix due to the amount of disassembly required. Hopefully, no damage was done and you are simply in a circumstance now where you need to identify the component in the cooling system that caused the overheating.

So, basically, you need an intelligent and accurate diagnosis before you can make any decisions about the reasonableness of the dollar estimates you were given. With regard to the first mechanic you mentioned, if he didn’t give you a specific diagnosis based on testing and inspection, that’s not the wisest way to proceed because then you could be paying for unnecessary repairs.

As regards the second mechanic, the visual inspection is part of a diagnostic but is only a small part, so if you go with him, he still has to actually identify the cause of the overheating before a decision is made as to which parts need replacing. Now, in your case, you’ve presented a very intriguing "clue." You mentioned that the overheating is of the "sudden onset" type, that is, you are not reporting that the truck has been consistently overheating. Sudden onset points to faults like a stuck thermostat (not hard to diagnose), failed radiator fan, or large leak.

Not to diminish anything I have stated about the importance of getting an accurate diagnosis (so your cost to repair is kept as low as possible), but there are circumstances where a reasonable case can be made that, given advanced age and mileage, it is prudent to replace a "basket" of parts just as good insurance. So yes, that could still happen as you get into this. But, even in that scenario, you still first need to get the cooling system diagnosed; if the diagnosis reveals that only the thermostat failed, that’s a $10 to $25 part and is a lot different than getting a brand new $1,000 plus cooling system.

I recommend having a certified mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, come to your location to determine exactly why your truck is overheating and suggest the necessary repairs to get your truck back in proper working order.

Was this answer helpful?

Need advice from certified mechanic? Get help now!

Over 1000 mechanics are ready to answer your question.
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details
  1. Home
  2. Questions
  3. Should I have a massive cooling system replacement done?

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Q: no pick up

Hi Chad. Assuming the check engine light is not coming on, leads me to believe the ECM (engine control module)/computer is not recognizing a fault. The overall lack of acceleration and reduced speed, holding a steady accelerator pedal, could be...

Q: My vacuum pump seems to be leaking water

Hi and thanks for contacting YourMechanic. Vacuum pumps are required to have oil in them for lubrication. If the pump is leaking water, then either the oil is the wrong type and is leaking out, or the pump has a...

Q: My car overheated with smoke coming out, I found antifreeze all over the engine and the temperature gauge was high

This can be caused by a number of things such as low coolant levels, a faulty thermostat, or a failing coolant fan switch. As you may know, the coolant fan switch helps to maintain the proper coolant temperature by turning...

Related articles

How Long Does a Distributor O Ring Last?
The distributor is part of the ignition system in your vehicle and its purpose is to route high voltage from the ignition coil to the spark plug. The spark plug then...
P2428 OBD-II Trouble Code: Exhaust Gas Temperature Too High Bank 1
P2428 code definition A P2428 trouble code signifies that the PCM has detected a problem in the exhaust gas temperature sensor circuit in bank 1, which subsequently contains the number one...
How Much Does a Mechanic Make in Vermont?
Automotive technician jobs in Vermont have an average mechanic salary of $37k, with some mechanics earning a salary of $53k.