Q: Rough idle and sputtering off and on

asked by on February 21, 2017

I've had my car for almost a year now. Once in a while I will start it up and out of nowhere it has an extremely rough idle. I can hear a thump-tump... thump-thump... in the engine. The whole car bounces when the thumps and when it's standing in neutral the shift stick is shaking a lot. It stalls often in a low gear moving slowly (parking etc.), the engine is loud, it accelerates very slowly and barely gets up hills. Every time I'm about to take it to the mechanic I will start it up again and it's gone all of a sudden and the car is fine again. Sometimes after it's been sitting overnight, sometimes literally just after it's been sitting for 20min. I have new spark plugs and have had regular oil changes. Thank you for you time.

My car has 200000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Car idle is rough Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Hello, and thank you for writing in. Considering the age and mileage of the vehicle, there could be a number of issues going on. At this point in its life, there are going to be critical components that will need to be replaced, all depending on how the vehicle has been taken care of up until this point. You want to look into the fuel, air, and spark systems. With new spark plugs, consider replacing the fuel filter, and possibly the pump. If it is the original pump, it has worked hard and is likely weak. Also make sure you air filter is new. If the problem continues, consider having your vehicle scanned for diagnostic codes. Even without an engine light, there may be codes that have been recorded by the computer which can shed some light on the situation. For more diagnostic help, contact our service department to schedule an appointment.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Used wrong oil, then installed new radiator 3 days later now car won't move forward when put in drive

Hello, thank you for writing in. Unfortunately you are in a situation where multiple variables are not helping the problem. To start, having the car weighted down does add extra load to the engine and can cause overheating. Secondly the...

Loud rough ride coming from the front of car.

Hey there, thanks for writing in to YourMechanic. There are many things this may be, ranging from front differential problems to an out of balance tire to bad wheel bearings. For an issue like this I would recommend having a...

Car jumps revs then immediatly shuts off

Hi there. After reading your question, it appears that the problem you're experiencing is either caused by a problem with your fuel injection system or an electrical fault, especially since your car is 22 years old and has 134,000 miles....

Radiator hose pops off

The cooling system would need to be opened to see if, when the engine is cranked, the combustion of the engine is pressurizing the cooling system, and blowing off the hose. The head gasket may be blown. I recommend having...

honda accord v6 97 the only arm working is on drivers side.

Claimed by Tim Charlet

2006 Acura TL Has High Idle

Your vehicle uses electronic throttle control to maintain the desired idle speed. In this system, the engine control module (ECM) receives input from various sensors to determine how much the throttle should be open. It then opens and closes the...

Car idling rough

A rough idle indicates that your engine is misfiring. There are many reasons why a car would misfire. It could be a bad ignition coil or spark plug. It could also be a bad control module or wiring issue. If...

Why would Oil Pressure Light come on while braking?

Hello. I don't know how often you check your oil level, but I would certainly check it now. Turbo-charged engines consume a bit more oil during an oil change interval than non-turbo engines, and it's possible your oil level is...

Car shakes while in drive and stops.

Based on your description it sounds to me like your have a bad motor or transmission mount. When one of these mounts go bad, it is no longer able to isolate the vibration of the engine from the body of...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy for Long Commutes
Most Most of us are faced with the prospect of commuting back and forth to work on a daily basis, but some have a much longer drive than others. When it comes time to buy a car, you need to...
How Long Does an Idle Control Valve Last?
Among Among the most important factors in having a smooth running car is a consistent idle speed. Having the incorrect idle speed can lead to a variety of different issues. There are a number of different components that have to...
How Does an Engine Idle High and Low?
A common problem that car owners experience is high or low engine idle. A damaged intake gasket, cold air intake, or PCV valve can cause idle issues.