Q: Replacement engine running rough.

asked by on January 08, 2016

I had my engine replaced with a used engine. It sounds like there are marbles in the engine, and it has been running rough and stalling while I am driving. I think the engine bolts might be missing as well.

Car is making a noise Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

An engine that sounds like marbles running in a dryer is a classic description of pinging or pre-detonation, this is a sign of major engine malfunction. This in addition to the rough idle and stalling makes me wonder the quality of the used engine before it was installed. Concerning the missing engine bolts, are there clean metal bolt holes where the bolts might have used to been? This could be the sign of careless installation and may shine some light onto what is going on inside your current engine. I would suggest having a certified mechanic diagnose the problem and document everything (pictures) you might need it to prove your case later down the road. Used engines are always a gamble if you can’t verify where it came from, next time try to get a time/mileage warranty in writing to help safeguard yourself from this happening.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Radiator cap needs replacing.
If you have a white residue building up just below the cap and you have to add coolant frequently, this could be the issue. The cooling system and cap need to be pressure tested to ensure the system is not...
My car want start and when it do it shut down and want start until 30 minute or so. Now it want do nothing
When a car turns and won't start, it is called a "crank no start". When this occurs, the first thing you need to do is see what is missing. All internal combustion motors need spark, fuel, injector pulse and camshaft...
Car won't start
You will need to have the computer tested to see if your computer is storing a possible code, and then the code will give more information about finding the problem. You can then monitor the data to see if the...
rough idle, heavy missing, fault codes P0301 and P0456. lack of power, where do i start to diagnose this?
Hi there. From the description you have provided, for the P0301 rough idle and heavy misfire and P0456 evaporative small leak detected, the problems are unrelated. The P0301 is a #1 cylinder misfire code. It could be, a spark plug...
Changing tailight/brake light double filament bulb on 08 sienna. Bulb is stuck in socket. Bad. Can't pull it out. Any ideas?
If the bulbs are stuck in the sockets then the sockets most likely got overheated from the bulbs and deformed the socket. You will need to replace the sockets and the bulbs.
Car is sputtering, miss firing,and dying if I get pass 40mph before I could do 60 before it sputtered
Hi There, You may want to check the power to the ignition coils to be sure that the ignition control module is powering each of the coils properly. I would also suggest checking to be sure the crank sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/crankshaft-position-sensor-replacement)...
what sends signal to a TPS sensor
Hello, thank you for writing in. The throttle position sensor does not take inputs from anything, but instead it acts as an input to the ECU (the main computer). The ECU then uses it for engine performance. The sensor's resistance...
Something is grinding when I stop
It is possible that your dust shield behind the rotor is coming in contact with the rotor sometimes. I would recommend to use a small screwdriver and try to pry the dust shield away from the rotor anywhere that it...
We have a 2007 Honda CRV - new battery installed. While driving seeing sporadic light surge on Dash. Thoughts?
If you just had battery replaced due to it going dead then you may have a charging system problem if light is coming on. Have the charging system checked to see if you need an alternator or have another problem....

Related articles

How Long Do Engine Motor Mounts Last?
Car motor mounts secure the engine to the chassis to absorb vibrations and keep the engine in place. Motor mounts last a long time, but they can fail.
How Long Does a Thermostat Last?
No No matter what kind of car or truck you drive, it has a thermostat in it. This thermostat is responsible for monitoring and regulating the coolant temperature in your vehicle's engine. If you were to look at the thermostat...
How to Clean an Idle Air Control Valve
Maintenance of an idle air control valve includes cleaning it from time to time to ensure it lasts long. It keeps your car idle level at normal.