Q: Rattling noise upon starting and then louder rattling at idle if load is placed on engine such as A/C

asked by on October 11, 2016

My problem started as a rattle at idle when my A/C was on. Sometimes I get the rattle simply with fan on at idle or even just a bit with fan off, especially at a low-speed turn. There is also a rattling noise at start-up. These problems come and go to some extent, but have gotten worse - one step forward, two steps back. The noise at idle with the A/C on now is very loud - obviously I don't run it at idle.

I replaced the idler pulley and belt tensioner assembly - no help.

I am thinking perhaps the power steering or A/C pulley or the crank pulley or damper. More serious would be torque converter or flywheel itself, which I probably wouldn't do due to expense. I have had issues with power steering which I fix by occasionally draining fluid and adding the conditioner, which corrects the problem for perhaps 5000 miles.

Any ideas?.

My car has 222000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi there. Given your mileage and your maintenance of the idler pulley, your problem is likely worn/weak hydraulic lifters (or other valve train wear) or the timing gear set. Starting the engine briefly (less than 30 seconds) without the serpentine belt attached, will eliminate noises from all accessories if the problem is with one of them. I would recommend having the engine inspected in person by a professional so that the rattling noise can be diagnosed and properly corrected.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car won't crank
Hello. There are many reasons why a car wont turn over. A bad starter, a bad connection at the battery or starter, low battery voltage, bad starter relay are just a few. Because of the limited amount of information and...
Engine oil leak
Engine oil can leak out from many seals in the engine of your Nissan Maxima. You can consider engine oil as the blood of the engine and it will need the proper amount inside at all times in order to...
Need tips on maintenance for my car that has passed the 80,000 mile mark
There are quite a few service items such as air filter, spark plugs. Also, various fluids such as engine coolant and brake fluid. Idle and valve adjustments are maintenance items as well. Honda has a full maintenance schedule for these...
Engine stumbles at low speeds - 2007 Dodge Sprinter 3500
It may be at a particular throttle angle and the EGR valve is getting carbon into the valve causing the erratic idle. You may need to have the engine decarbonized. If you hold the engine in neutral and REV it...
Car cranks over but won't start - 2004 Nissan Sentra
If the fuel pump is not "whirring" momentarily when you turn the key "on", either the pump is not receiving power or it's non-functional. You might try probing the fuel pump harness for 12 volts at moment key is turned...
Car moves in 1st gear and reverse but won't move in drive
Hello, first thing to check of course is fluid level. If the fluid level is low, any number of weird symptoms can occur. Your symptoms sound like the valve body may be sticking from a bit of grit or leaking...
Gas pump stops every few seconds while re-fueling. It takes a very long time to fill up the tank.
As you may know, the charcoal canister is what absorbs and stores the fumes in the tank. If the charcoal canister is not working correctly, the fumes will still be present while refueling and cause the gas pump to kick...
I have a Mercedes Benz C230 and am seeing an indicator on the dash board that "A check in 5500 miles". Pls what does this mean?
The service reminder system is telling you how far you have until the next scheduled maintenance. The "A" service is an oil and filter change along with a few routine checks and the "B" service is the A service plus...
Transmission problem?
This may indicate a failing speed sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/transmission-speed-sensor-replacement). The transmission speed sensor is a magnetic sensor that provides information related to the speed of the input and output shafts in the transmission, allowing the transmission to shift smoothly. The sensor...

Related articles

Does Running My AC in the Summer Keep My Engine Cooler?
When When you engage your air conditioning in your car, it is usually summertime and hot outside. Air conditioning serves to remove heat from the inside of your vehicle by circulating a refrigerant through the evaporator core in your dashboard,...
What Is the Purpose of Engine Gaskets?
Engine gaskets work as seals to maintain pressure, hold fluids, and prevent debris from entering the engine. Gaskets are vital for engine performance.
How to Replace a Water Pump Pulley
The serpentine belt or drive belt drives an engine’s water pump pulley, which rotates the water pump. A bad pulley leads to a failure of this system.