Q: Opinion on buying a cheap, high-mileage Mercedes or BMW

asked by on June 08, 2016

Is it worth buying a Mercedes or a BMW that has over 100,000 miles. I've noticed they are very cheap.

Yes, they are very cheap because they are endless money pits when they are that old. Don’t buy them. If you get them from a relative for free, then yes, you may want to take that off their hands. I’ve had a few customers over the years who inherited a Mercedes for nothing and I tell them "you’ve got it for nothing, drive it and I’ll maintain it." And I’m honest and say as soon as I see something big going on on the front end then sell it and get rid of it.

If you are going to need an engine or transmission job done, that is going to cost thousands so get rid of it. But the reason they are so cheap is because they are endless money pits. They are over-engineered. When I was a kid, those Mercedes 300D diesels could go half a million miles. They were pretty much trouble free. Not any more. They are over-engineered junk these days. They aren’t made nearly as well as they were in the past. Most of those in the United States aren’t even made in Germany. So you’re just paying for the name and they aren’t worth it. And if you buy one really cheap or free, go ahead. But don’t put much money because they will bankrupt you.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Brake locking - 1990 BMW 750iL

Your vehicle uses a high-pressure hydraulic brake booster. It's likely that the pressure regulator sensors that provide the braking assistance are not functioning correctly, providing too much "braking assistance". A professional mechanic, like YourMechanic, can assist with diagnosis of your...

car not accelerating properly, only gets half way to the speed

Many different things can cause the car to lack power. Most of these will be seen with a Check Engine Light to indicate there is a fault. The most common issues involved in this scenario are problems with the fuel...

Failed compression test

Hi there. First, a compression test will only check the cylinder for pressure build up during cranking and test the rings. To verify that the valves are really leaking, hook up a leak down tester to the engine and pressurize...

Related articles

What Do the Belts on the Front of an Engine Do?
Car serpentine belts power multiple parts like the power steering pump and air conditioning. A broken engine belt can cause damage to components.
How To Add Air To Your Tires
Checking and adding air pressure to your tires requires finding the proper tire pressure, a good gauge, and an air compressor with a tire chuck.
How to Deal With a Car Battery For Long-Term Storage
If If you store your car for the winter, or for other long periods, it’s important to make sure that your car battery is properly cared for. Long term car storage can wreak havoc on your battery. Isn't it okay...