Q: Is this the alternator or just the battery?

asked by on August 14, 2016

Hi this morning my car was dead and wouldn't start, so eventually I jumped it with a charger and after twenty minutes or so it died , I did this again and same thing. This leads me to think the alternator is bad because it's not recharging the battery but the date on the battery says it original to the car from 2001. So is it possible the battery just can't hold a charge anymore and the alternator is ok? Also if I put a new battery in would I be able to drive 5 miles to my mechanic without it dyeing assuming then that it is the alternator? * I checked the connections and cleaned the small amount of corrosion on the battery also before the first jump *

My car has 115000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Warning Light is on Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote
Battery Replacement $200.97 - $319.07 Get a Quote
Alternator Replacement $149.30 - $1396.98 Get a Quote
Car is not starting Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Since the battery was dead, this could be the cause of a failed alternator that was unable to maintain the battery charge. Try charging the battery first and running the vehicle. If the Charge Warning Light illuminates, there could be a problem with the alternator. In this case I would replace both the battery and alternator at the same time for the best results. If you need assistance wit this, consider YourMechanic, as a certified technician can diagnose your starting issue and replace these components as necessary. Good luck.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

93 Oldsmobile Cutlass supreme won't start.

Hi there. Check the camshaft and crankshaft position sensors and make sure that they are plugged in. If the engine is cranking but not starting then the crankshaft position sensor could have failed. Also, check the mass air flow sensor...

Why would my steering only be stiff when driving but be fine when I'm still or going real slow 2001 Nissan Frontier

The steering system is designed to have a hard steering at high speeds to prevent any rollovers. The Dynamic Stability Control or Traction Control is designed to keep the vehicle from over steering when driven at a higher speed. You...

No fuel pressure in my line. Car won't start. When it did star, it died and now won't start at all.

As you know, this may be a result of a faulty fuel pump. This may also be a result of a failing fuel pressure regulator as well. This is what monitors the fuel pressure in the system and maintains pressure...

honda accord will not start

Hello, thank you for writing in. In these situations always start with the basics. First, when turning the vehicle over to try and start it, a slow cranking speed may indicate you have a weak starter or battery. The starter...

car turns over but wont start

Hi there. Check the fuel pressure regulator on the fuel rail and see if its plugged up. You may have to remove it and clean it. If the regulator is good, then I recommend replacing the spark plugs to ensure...

I have to jump my car repeatedly.everytime I try to start my car no matter how long it was running for.altenator belt still spins.

If your car will not stay running after jump starting then the charging system is not working and may need an alternator and may even also need a new battery. If you need help with this, I recommend having a...

How do I use the headlight aiming control?

If you have a lot of weight in your vehicle, or are traveling up a steep hill, the headlights may be angled too high. This can cause visibility issues for not only you, but also any vehicle in front of...

How Can I Prevent My Car Battery From Dying?

The battery has a limited lifespan of between two and five years. A battery life can be shortened by lack of maintenance, leaving lights on and causing a discharge, charging system problems, or defective cables. A battery is made up...

How much to replace engine for 2001 oldsmobile aurora

Hi there: Replacing an engine is not as easy as it used to be due to the multiple electrical sensors and components that frequently don't align perfectly after the engine swap. In regards to cost of the engine and replacement;...

Related articles

How the Alternator Works in Your Car
Your Your car alternator, at its most basic, is what works along with your battery and the rest of your charging system to keep your car running. When you start your car, you’re running on battery power. Then the battery...
What Is Key-Off Battery Drain?
Many Many things in your car continue to work even after your vehicle is turned off – radio presets, security alarms, emissions computers and clocks are just a few. They continue to draw power from your car battery, and the...
Can a Car Battery Freeze?
Cold temperatures can make it hard to start your car, and extreme cold can freeze a battery. Use a battery heater to make your car reliable in winter.