Q: I'm considering buying another car and it's going to be an automatic. Is it worth it? I've never had one.

asked by on May 04, 2016

I'm considering buying another car and it's going to be an automatic. Is it worth it? I've never had one.

It depends. I personally like to drive the standard because you have more control, you get a tiny bit better gas mileage, and you can drive faster. It’s a better driving experience. You’ve got to think about how far people are when you shift gears. You keep more active.

When you are on an automatic, you could be on a sofa and playing around like you play a game on a Nintendo. So, it’s more fun experience as far as I’m concerned. But, a lot of people get automatic because they get tired of shifting while driving in traffic all the time. They don’t want to mess around with it.

If you are going to get an automatic, do a little research. Make sure you buy a car from a company that makes good automatic transmission that doesn’t have problems. Like Toyotas, they rarely have automatic transmission problems. Take a company like Subaru, they have nothing but automatic transmission problems for the last 15-20 years. So, if you are buying a Subaru, I would definitely get a standard transmission and not an automatic. To be sure that you get a car in great condition, I recommend that you also do a pre-purchase inspection on your car so that you can feel better about your purchase.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Transmission lost all fluid I refilled it and now you step on gas and car wont go. 2003 Saturn Vue

Hello - if the vehicle was driven any distance with low fluid, major damage could have occurred. If the transmission now has a proper, clean fluid level, and won't move in any gear, there is likely serious damage. I would...

2011 ford escape gear shift wont more from park to drive from time to time.

Hi there. The interlock solenoid in the shifter housing is not working and is causing the shifter to stay locked in the park position. This solenoid works with the brake switch. Check the brake switch and see if there is...

High RPM, cannot shift gears on 1998 Lincoln Mark VIII

Hello. We will be happy to assist you with your 1996 Lincoln Mark VIII. I suggest to have the vehicles computer scanned and trouble codes retrieved by a technician. Being that the Check Engine Light comes on when the problem...

Transmission makes high pitched whistle intermediatly

Hi there. The whistling noise from the transmission could be either a thrust bearing failing or a clutch pack is slipping under certain conditions. First check the fluid to the transmission and make sure that its full and red in...

2012 Nissan Maxima- Code P1778- Drive speed at 60 the RPM shows 4

The code P1778 is due to a problem with the step motor actuators inside the CVT transmission not moving the pulleys to a higher gear position and this is why your engine is revving too high. you will need to...

CEL slow higher rpms

Hello there, thank you for asking about your 2013 BMW 135i. The very first thing I would do is have the vehicle scanned for trouble codes, as sputtering and a Check Engine Light can be caused by a wide variety...

2006 Mercedes-Benz E350 won't shift into high gear

This vehicle is equipped with an electronically controlled transmission. When the vehicle will not shift into high gear it is in a safe mode to prevent damage until the issue is resolved. A qualified technician, like one from YourMechanic, will...

Automatic transmission not shifting properly.

The computer on these cars are prone to interference if the owner has put on an aftermarket code scanner to the ALDL connector to scan the computer. Some owners use these to monitor system functions or for other reasons. These...

Transmission goes into reverse but not drive.

This is likely a sign of low transmission fluid. I would recommend checking the fluid first to see if this does not fix your issue. If this does not solve the problem, this may be a faulty transmission control solenoid....

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Shift Interlock Solenoid
The shift interlock solenoid needs to be replaced if the vehicle cannot shift out of park and the battery is not dead.
How Long Does a Transmission Position Sensor (Switch) Last?
All All automatic transmission vehicles have a safety switch in place that only allows them to start if they are in park or neutral gars. The transmission position sensor, also called the transmission position switch, ensures the vehicle is in...
How an Automatic Transmission Works
An An automatic transmission allows a vehicle engine to operate within a narrow speed range, just like a manual transmission does. As the engine achieves higher degrees of torque (torque is the rotational power of the engine), the gears in...