Q: I have a 1998 Caddy DeVille, has original muffler and catalytic converter. had to be tweaked to pass CA smog, replace both?

asked by on May 23, 2017

I own a 1998 Caddy Deville, it still has original muffler and catalytic converter. It had to be "tweaked" to pass CA Smog last year. Should I replace muffler and converter? Thanks, Pete

My car has 214000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Catalytic Converter Replacement $288.41 - $1959.69 Get a Quote

Hey Pete, thanks for writing in. The replacements have more to do with what is actually wrong with the vehicle. If they have been modified illegally, then the answer is an automatic yes. Not only does it cause issues with the legalities behind California exhaust standards, but the changes may cause issues with the way the vehicle operates. The catalytic converter does most of the work when it comes to emission standards, and it will need to be focused on first. The muffler does more for sound regulation, but there are laws regarding them as well. Again, start by replacing the catalytic converter first. Replace the muffler if it is damaged, rusted out, or illegal. If you need help making the repairs and getting the car to pass SMOG testing, contact our service department to schedule an appointment.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What is the evaporative emissions control system?
Gasoline evaporates, even in the gas tank of your Accord. If those fumes are allowed to escape into the atmosphere, they create hydrocarbons that damage the environment and also contribute to smog/air pollution. To help combat this problem, your car...
Expansion tank leaking
The expansion tank on these vehicles are known to have leaks after years of use. The new replacement tanks hold up better to the coolant heat and pressures they encounter. You will most likely need to get the entire tank...
EGR BPT valve & EGR solenoid valve need replacements
Hello there. When codes go away like this, it generally means that the fault has resolved itself or the Check Engine Light has failed in the cluster. If the code is gone this would indicate that there is not a...
When replacing ball joints can you just replace the ball joints or do you need to just replace the control arm?
Suspension components on modern vehicles are not as heavy as they used to be. Components like control arms can be lighter and thinner. Ball joints are riveted or pressed into control arms. Sometimes bolted/screwed. Since replacing a ball joint will...
The airbag light is on, could it be caused by previous work done on the car?
The SRS (Airbag) light comes on when the controller has sensed a malfunction somewhere in the system. The malfunction may be an open circuit or an incorrect voltage at any of the sensors. When the controller sees the error, it...
Brake pad is vibrating Toyota IST
Hello. This vibration or pulsation in the brakes would require a complete brake inspection in person, but the problem is most likely going to be warped rotors and the pads worn down. The front rotors (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/brake-rotor-disc-replacement) and pads (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/brake-pads-replacement) would...
What causes shaking in 2nd gear when I accelerate
Hi There, It sounds like something may be loose when the reinstallation happened resulting in the vibration (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-is-shaking-or-vibrating-inspection) as the torque of the engine is transferred to the suspension when shifting to second gear. I would suggest having a professional...
My acura tl melted 2 coil pack and they cannot be removed should I replace the heads or replace the motor 2006 Acura TL
Hello. I would first determine why the coils melted whether it was from an overheat or something else. In some cases the cylinder head will need to be replaced. I would get some help from an engine specialist to be...
I replaced my starter and my car won't start. I think I did everything correctly, because it did start once.
Hi Philippe. Thanks for the question today and writing back. If you'd like to request an estimate to have one of our mobile mechanics come to your location and diagnose the root source of this hard starting issue, click this...

Related articles

Can Exhaust Get Into a Car's Interior?
There’s There’s a very simple answer to the question of whether or not exhaust fumes can ever get into a car’s interior – yes they can. This happens more often than you might think, and it’s never a good thing....
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re a Realtor or Real Estate Agent
If If you make your living as a realtor or real estate agent, you may have a number of considerations when it comes to purchasing a used vehicle. The most common considerations are budget, ability to transport people, and comfort....
How to Replace an Exhaust Clamp
An exhaust pipe is supported by exhaust clamps within a vehicle. A bad clamp can lead to exhaust leaks that can turn hazardous if not addressed.