Q: I have a 1998 Caddy DeVille, has original muffler and catalytic converter. had to be tweaked to pass CA smog, replace both?

asked by on May 23, 2017

I own a 1998 Caddy Deville, it still has original muffler and catalytic converter. It had to be "tweaked" to pass CA Smog last year. Should I replace muffler and converter? Thanks, Pete

My car has 214000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Catalytic Converter Replacement $291.63 - $3214.07 Get a Quote

Hey Pete, thanks for writing in. The replacements have more to do with what is actually wrong with the vehicle. If they have been modified illegally, then the answer is an automatic yes. Not only does it cause issues with the legalities behind California exhaust standards, but the changes may cause issues with the way the vehicle operates. The catalytic converter does most of the work when it comes to emission standards, and it will need to be focused on first. The muffler does more for sound regulation, but there are laws regarding them as well. Again, start by replacing the catalytic converter first. Replace the muffler if it is damaged, rusted out, or illegal. If you need help making the repairs and getting the car to pass SMOG testing, contact our service department to schedule an appointment.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

Car won't start with new battery after sitting a year

Hello. If the vehicle only starts with the jumper wire method, then it is likely its an issue with the ignition switch itself. It's possible that the switch itself is bad or the key has a become bad. Try starting...

Car got hot and lost all spark,it turns over but thats it.

There may be a couple of possibilities at play here. The overheating issue may be related to a faulty thermostat, coolant temp sensor relay or potentially a blown head gasket. This can cause the car to run rough or not...

How do I bypass the heater core?

There are two hoses that go to the heater core on the firewall, these two hoses would need to be hooked together. This is the only way to bypass the heater. If you need some assistance with this, consider enlisting...

My 2005 Kia Sorento doesn't have the power to go down the road. It will start and run, but it won't go faster than 35 mph.

Check to see if any vacuum lines were disconnected when your engine was serviced. A vacuum leak can cause the engine to have a loss of power under a load. If all of the vacuum lines are good, then the...

Do u think if I install leveling kit on my trundra just the front 2 inches I'll mess up my truck?? I just don't like the way they

Your truck ride height is set from the factory and any modifications could jeopardize your vehicle warranty. Lets look at some pros and cons if you alter the front end ride height. Pros: The truck will look more level...

Muffler hanging from bottom of vehicle.

I recommend having a qualified mechanic, like one from YourMechanic, replace your severed exhaust pipe. The exhaust may have also damaged the manifolds of the engine and caused wiring damage to the exhaust sensors. The exhaust systems on these vehicles...

What does it mean when you hit your brakes your car tried to sway

Swaying, or pulling, as you describe it means that braking forces from left to right are unequal and/or there are faults in the vehicle suspension. Brake force can be unequal from side to side due to worn or warped rotors,...

My air vents smell like coolant when I just run the air. In the morning I turned it on and a little bit of smoke came out with the

Hi Chris. Thanks for contacting us today. Usually, when you smell coolant from the vents, it's caused by a coolant leak near the heater core. It could be the core itself, a coolant hose or a hose connection that has...

I have a 99 Cadillac deville that keeps over heating.I've replaced the water pump and thermostat its still running hot

The most common causes of overheating include low coolant level (including that due to leaks), a faulty thermostat, a plugged radiator, a faulty radiator pressure cap, collapsed hoses, non functioning cooling fans, and a faulty water pump or drive belt....

Related articles

How Long Does an Exhaust Clamp Last?
When When examining your vehicle's exhaust system, it's normal to find that each of the pipes involved have been welded together. However, sometimes you may find that an exhaust clamp has been used, which is even more common when an...
What Metal Is the Exhaust System Made From?
Exhaust Exhaust systems must be made from metal to provide the required durability and resistance to heating, cooling and exposure to the elements. However, there are many different types of metals (and grades of individual metals). There are also differences...
Does Changing the Exhaust System Void a Manufacturer Warranty?
Stock exhaust systems are designed to provide good operation in the widest possible range of driving conditions. That means there...