Q: I got a code for my EVAP (P1457)

asked by on November 14, 2016

This code is meant for my EVAP. I recently replaced my purge valve, charcoal canister, and the solenoid and all my hoses are crackless, and also my plug that attaches to it is clean and intact. I can't seem to find the problem, there's supposably a small leak somewhere. One of myfriends, says it's my PCV valve. Is this possible? What do you think is the best possible thing to do. If it isn't that one part.

My car has 151000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Check Engine Light is on Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

First, it is not the PCV. (positive crankcase ventilation) The PCV is there to relieve pressure and gases from the crankcase. The evaporative system keeps the fuel in the fuel tank from evaporating into the atmosphere. They are two separate systems.

This particular code simply states there is a problem with the evaporative emissions system. It doesn’t really point to any one thing wrong, such as a leak. Since this code is so generic, a total system test will need to be run. This can only be done with a shop level scanner and a technician with the experience to understand the results. Evaporative system tests will activate all the valves and solenoids in the system in a fashion that will reveal what to look for. It could be a leak, a solenoid that is not working or a sensor that is reading incorrectly. There are pressure sensors on the fuel tank that are used by the system to check for leaks. This is done by using the vacuum in the engine to put the fuel tank into low pressure. If the tank does not hold this low pressure condition, a code will be set. This is a simplified version of the test. If the sensor is showing an incorrect value, the system will assume there is something wrong.

If it is a leak that needs to be chased, the most common place for leaks in an evaporative system, are the seals that seal the hose connections. When these seal dry, they contract and begin to leak. The best way to look for any leak in an evap system is through the use of a smoke machine. Unfortunately, smoke machines are expensive. It creates pressure in the evap system and injects smoke into it as well. Smoke will escape out any leak in the system.

Because of the tools involved and the complicated nature of evaporative emissions systems, I recommend the following inspection to help you out. Check engine light is on inspection

Good luck!

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I turn on the fog lights?
The fog lights can improve visibility in adverse driving conditions, namely rain and fog. To turn on the fog lights, rotate the fog light switch to the on position (the fog light switch is located next to the light switch,...
Alignment off on 2004 GMC Envoy
Hello. Sometimes hitting a curb or running over a pothole can cause the alignment to go out in a car. Also, if you have a worn suspension it will cause the alignment to go out as well. If this is...
Fail safe Mode engaged with the engine shaking. Possible over revving of the engine
Your vehicle is in limp mode to prevent engine damage from the overheating. I suggest you let the motor cool for a while before trying to drive it again, if at all. I also suggest having a certified technician, like...
timing control valve
First, there are many different reasons you might get a timing over advanced code. The problem could be anything from a stretched timing chain (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/timing-chain-replacement) to a failed actuator. The timing control solenoid valve is turned on and off by...
Does not idle well.
You may have a dirty or failing idle air control valve. The idle air control valve reads the air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected into the engine at low speeds and at idle. Since...
Vibration Under Acceleration
You may be dead on about the CV joint, the car certainly does have enough miles on it for the joint to be bad. CV's will respond to the torque load as well as changing direction, so your analysis is...
I have no cabin heat, just blows out cold air. The engine doesn’t overheat and it seems like fluid is coming out of the radiator c
If coolant has to be added more than once per year, there is a leak. To find the leak that exists in your case, and get the required repair estimated, please request an engine cooling system leak diagnostic (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/coolant-is-leaking-inspection) and...
is it too late to get undercoating for a week old 2017 Toyota Prius
No it is never too late to get the car undercoated unless your car is already rusted out. You may need to have the under car washed of any dirt or salts that may have got on the undercarriage.
The sleeve that goes on the harmonic balancer that the belt goes on popped off and the belt slipped can the sleeve be reused?
The short answer is no. The harmonic balancer is manufactured in three pieces: The hub, a rubber sleeve, and the outer sleeve. They are held together with adhesive and the reason your's fell apart is because the rubber has gotten...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Fit EV
The The 2012 Honda Fit EV is lots of fun to drive and offers a smooth ride to passengers. It is Honda’s first pure electric car, and it offers a range of 70 to 123 miles between charges. The Fit...
The Best Used Cars to Buy for Teenagers
If If you’ve decided that you’re ready to purchase a used car for your teenager, then you’re probably pretty picky about what you’re looking for. Likely affordability, safety, and fuel economy are high on the list. With that said we’ve...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Need a Lot of Trunk Space
Many Many people focus more on interior room than cargo carrying capacity. That’s natural if you have a large family or regularly carpool, but what about drivers who need to carry a lot of stuff most of the time and...