Q: I ask a questiion earlier and was very pleased with response from Tim. After reading his answer i was browsing some of the other q

asked by on May 17, 2017

I wanted to comment while also asking if any of your mechanics have ever heard of this. I read where someone was asking about a knock sensor. I read an article and I quote "Believe it or not, some engineer at Toyota thought it was a good idea to disallow the vehehicle from changing into high gear if the knock sensor goes bad" Have you ever came across this situation and how would you know if the sensor is bad or just doing its job by not allowing the vehehicle to go into overdrive?

Hi Chris. I’ve always believed that engineers that design cars, trucks and SUV’s driving on the roads today are pretty smart folks, and contrary to what some might say, there is always a method to their madness. In the case of the knock sensor, if it is not able to diagnose engine issues on the fly, serious engine damage will eventually occur. When it fails, it triggers a limp mode (which is probably what the author of that quote was referencing). This article is actually a great one that talks about whether or not it is safe to drive with a damaged knock sensor that expands on why it’s smart for the vehicle to enter limp mode. In regards to how to tell if the knock sensor is doing it job or if it’s failing, this is where having a professional mechanic completing an OBD-II diagnostic inspection when symptoms occur is the best way to know for certain. Thanks for the reply.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Rattle under car
The vehicle should be inspected for the loose or broken component which many be minor in many cases. The exhaust system uses rubber hangers that crack and break allowing extra movement. The components of the exhaust system are prone to...
Faulty brakes cause unpredictable stopping distance
Hello. Bumpy roads can cause the ABS system to have trouble working correctly. Bumpy roads cause changes in the speed of the wheels which is the main input for the ABS system. If computer is not reading correctly then the...
Car cannot start, engine unresponsive
The hard start issue on your 1994 Toyota Previa could be a variety of possibilities from something as simple as a dirty battery cable (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-cable-replacement) to a faulty starter (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/starter-replacement), starter relay switch (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/starter-relay-replacement), or many other possibilities. Your vehicle...
Hesitation, stalling out
Hello. It sounds like the spark plugs are fouled and the spark plug wires need to be replaced. It is possible that the fuel filter (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-filter-replacement) is clogged up and needs to be replaced as well. Have a certified technician,...
Battery Light came on after jump starting another person's car incorrectly
Hello. Your battery light likely came on as a result of additional draw or amperage from your car's charging system. Keep an eye on your charging gauge, but you should be fine. If you notice that you are having further...
Dark green sludge
Hi, thanks for writing in. Dark green sludge is most likely grease from an outer CV joint boot that has split open on whichever side you are seeing it. If you would like help with the repairs, consider having an...
Engine smells hot on my 2000 Toyota Camry but isn't overheating
Hi there. Not overheating, coolant level okay, and normal operating temperature are all good things. The hot smell may be, engine oil burning. It could be, the valve cover gasket leaking oil (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/valve-cover-gasket-replacement) onto the exhaust manifold. This may account...
No response when pressing on the gas pedal.
Hi There, It sounds like you are describing the symptoms of a failing throttle position sensor. The throttle position sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/throttle-position-sensor-replacement) monitors the throttle position of the throttle plate inside the throttle body in relation to your foot position on...
Signal lights quit working, shifter can't move
Hi. We will be happy to assist you. More than likely the wiring inside of the fuse box specifically the connectors where the fuses were blown have lost contact or melted. This is very common on your make and model of...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re Over Six Feet Tall
While While shorter than average drivers can have a tough time finding the right car, it’s equally hard for taller drivers, perhaps more so. If you’re feeling squished, or have to hunch over the wheel to drive, then you’re not...
How to Buy a Good Quality ABS Control Module
The The ABS (anti-lock brake system) control module, which is also known as an EBM (electronic brake module) or EBCM (electronic brake control module) works almost like an engine control computer. This microprocessor receives input from sensors to prevent wheel...
Symptoms of Bad or Failing Stabilizer Bar Links
Common signs of faulty stabilizer bar links include clunking or rattling noises from the tire area, poor handling, and a loose steering wheel.