Q: How often do you replace a catalytic converter?

asked by on January 09, 2017

Replaced factory original cat with aftermarket part at 180000.. Car failed emissions in California after 10 000 miles (just over 2year warranty) and was replaced with another cat and was 1 point away from failing after another 10000 miles. Mechanic recommends replacing it again. Is this what I can expect because the car is so old?

My car has 200000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Check Engine Light is on Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

This would all depend on the quality of the catalytic converter and whether or not the engine is running rich. If the catalytic converter installed was not of OEM quality, this can be part of the reason that it did not last. It is also possible that the engine is running rich. This means that excess fuel is being delivered to the engine. If this is the case, the catalytic converters can foul out much faster than normal. If this is the case, I would recommend having your vehicle inspected for a rich running condition.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Crankshaft bearing replacement cost 2008 BMW M3

Hello - unfortunately, this is not a service YourMechanic offers at this time. Thanks for thinking of us though!

Top gets stuck open

Hello. Most of the time this occurs when the lift motor is failing. This is the most common failure on this top. When it cannot lift it any further, then it is failing internally. I usually do an amperage draw...

My car needs service..but I don't know where to start. My brake light is on..but i just did the brakes 2months ago and my engine l

You should have the computer and ABS systems scanned for codes to get an idea of the problem you may be having and then a repair can be made. If you want a mechanic like one from YourMechanic to come...

My abs and traction lights on and wont shift into gears

It is possible that your transmission can be malfunctioning. I would recommend having your transmission inspected by a qualified transmission specialist to determine the exact cause of this issue. If your transmission is stuck in the lower gears, this can...

I need the name of the part that connects my driveshaft to my transfer case.

Hi there, thanks for your question. The part your are looking for is called the slip joint yolk. Best of luck!

Car burning a lot of oil

Hello. Your vehicle is equipped with an oil level sensor and an oil pressure sensor. The light will come one from either sensor. If the engine is making a rattling noise, then I would worry about problems such as: the...

Average price to replace outer door skin?

In order to get the door skin replaced you will need to look into different body shops to get quotes. Be aware of low ball quotes. If you get the door skin replaced you will also need to have it...

Car has rough idle and ticks.

If the engine has low compression on one cylinder it is usually an indication of a damaged valve seat or possibly a bad head gasket. If it is also accompanied by a ticking noise then there may be an issue...

Radio interior lights IOD

Since the problems go away when the radio harness is unplugged, this sounds like a bad ground, or loose power supply connection related to that installation. The Ignition Off Draw fuse is on the main fuse block. Your Owner's Manual...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW X6
The The X6 is a study in identity crises. While the sleek fastback styling and cozy interior suggest a sporty coupe, the hatchback and SUV platform speak to a weak attempt at imitating a wagon (without the roomy passenger capacity)....
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Live in a Windy Area
If If you live in a windy area, one of the most important things you’re going to be looking for in a used vehicle is the ability to remain stable on the road on even the most blustery days. That...
How to Use a BMW With Comfort Access Technology
The The BMW comfort access technology was introduced in 2002 as a keyless remote system that uses sensors to detect where the owner is in proximity to the vehicle within 1.5 meters (about 5 feet), allowing him or her to...