Q: How often do you replace a catalytic converter?

asked by on January 09, 2017

Replaced factory original cat with aftermarket part at 180000.. Car failed emissions in California after 10 000 miles (just over 2year warranty) and was replaced with another cat and was 1 point away from failing after another 10000 miles. Mechanic recommends replacing it again. Is this what I can expect because the car is so old?

My car has 200000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Check Engine Light is on Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

This would all depend on the quality of the catalytic converter and whether or not the engine is running rich. If the catalytic converter installed was not of OEM quality, this can be part of the reason that it did not last. It is also possible that the engine is running rich. This means that excess fuel is being delivered to the engine. If this is the case, the catalytic converters can foul out much faster than normal. If this is the case, I would recommend having your vehicle inspected for a rich running condition.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What does the Service StabiliTrak message mean?

The Service StabiliTrak message can appear in the driver information center (DIC). When the DIC displays this alert, the StabiliTrak system is not properly working, and needs to be serviced. When the StabiliTrak issue is resolved, the alert will go...

Truck not starting after replacing starter

Hi, is the check engine light on? Sometimes a no start will throw a diagnostic code which will help in solving the issue. Certain sensors, such as the crankshaft position sensor, are needed to run the engine and if the...

2004 Saturn Vue...Right Front brake hanging up, replaced caliper and master cylinder and still hanging up.

High brake effort can be caused by a restriction in the system. What can happen with the brake system is the brake hoses attached to caliper degrade internally causing a restriction. The hose will collapse under pressure.

Speed control broken. 2005 Buick Terraza

You may be having a problem with the throttle control actuator assembly not getting a signal from the ECM, or the actuator module is defective. The cruise control test with the dealer scanner can monitor all the inputs and outputs...

My car is sputtering but it's not a blown gasket what else could it be

Hi, thanks for writing in. This could be many different possibilities ranging from fuel delivery issues to possibly a blown head gasket. Without further detail of the symptoms, this may be tough to diagnose without physically inspecting or taking the...

Oily thick coolant

Hi there. This is a sure sign of a blown head gasket. This can happen when the car overheats causing the cylinder head gasket to fail. When this happens, this will allow oil to leak into the engine coolant passages...

Radiator fan is not turning on

Once the relay and fuse have been checked and are working, the next thing to check is the controller for the fans that determines which fans operate and at what speed. There are several inputs to this controller: coolant temperature,...

Check engine light on flashing traction light on

The traction control system monitors the steering stability of the vehicle and engages when loss of traction has been detected. This is done by the use of electronic sensors that communicate with the Power Train Control Module (PCM) regarding steering...

My '65 F-100 lurches only when driven slowly.

Hi there. The symptoms that you are describing lead to the accelerator pump in the carburetor not pumping correctly at low rpm's and low speeds. Try adjusting the carburetor settings to be 100 rpm's higher and turn in the fuel...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW Z4
BMW’s BMW’s entry in the hardtop roadster segment, the Z4 delivers the ideal combination of performance, looks, and standard comfort features. This two seater is not only classically stylish and heavy on extras that aren’t, well, extra, it’s also the...
5 Essential Things to Know About Luxury Vehicles
There’s There’s something to be said about the looks and offerings of luxury vehicles, but appearances can always be deceiving. If you’re considering buying a luxury car, there are a few things you need to know before you make your...
How to Purchase a Pre-Owned BMW
BMW BMW offers a wide selection of luxury cars. In many circles, owning a BMW is a sign of success. While most balk at the price of a brand new BMC car, pre-owned models provide a viable alternative if you...