Q: how do you know if you need to replace rotors

asked by on March 31, 2017

I don"t seem to be having any problems braking. just replacing pads for the first time. my mechanic just said I needed to replace them.

My car has 62000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Brake Pads Replacement $125.62 - $449.32 Get a Quote

When brake pads are replaced, the brake rotors MUST either be re-surfaced on a brake lathe OR the brake rotors must be discarded and new rotors installed. If the old rotors are NOT worn below the legal minimum thickness, and are not otherwise damaged (scored or warped), the least cost option is to re-surface the rotors on a brake lathe. Most aftermarket rotors are junk made in China. If you buy new rotors because the old ones cannot be re-surfaced, I strongly recommend you install ONLY the OEM rotors from the dealer or rotors from a reputable name brand such as AC Delco. The reason that rotors can never be re-used as is, no matter how they appear to the eye and no matter what your present braking experience is, is because a variation in thickness in the rotor that exceeds just .001 inches WILL be felt as pedal pulsation and vibration. In comparison, a human hair is FOUR TIMES that value (a hair is .004 inches thick). In other words, the brake rotor must be perfect and I can guarantee that if the rotor is used, it is far from adequate for re-use (without re-surfacing at minimum) with brand new brake pads. In addition, once the rotor is re-installed on the wheel hub, the total installed rotor run out must NOT exceed .002 inches. Ask your mechanic to use a dial indicator to confirm that and if run out exceeds .002 inches the rotor must be re-indexed, shimmed or replaced (or the cause of the run-out found and repaired). Certified mechanics from YourMechanic install new pads and rotors on a mobile basis thus saving you a lot of money. If you desire that service please request brake service - new pads and rotors and the responding certified mechanic will get this taken care of for you. If you have any further questions at all regarding this service, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Bolt on 06 Elantra control arm no longer attached

The repair will depend on whether the arm detached and as a consequence got damaged. Also, detachment of the arm if the vehicle is moving can potentially damage other parts such as the mounting boss(es) on the frame that the...

What can cause the smart key to not work?

There are a few things that will keep the smart key from operating properly: 1. Another smart key is near the vehicle. 2. A mobile transmitter, such as a cell phone, is too close to the smart key. 3. A...

Car vibrates when braking on a hill.

The front brake rotors on this car is common to get warped causing the vibration you feel. When you are going down the hill it is putting more stress on the brakes and will tend to heat the rotors more....

What does it mean if the Brake System indicator comes on in the dash?

The Brake light on the dash of your car is designed to come on as a warning and as a reminder in different situations. Here’s what you need to know: The light will turn on if the parking brake...

Noise when braking at low speed

Hello. I am not sure of your description of the sound, but I think you are describing a brake rotor runout causing the brake pads to gyrate and make a noise at low speeds and light braking it is most...

replaced brake shoes in the back (they are drums,) but now they dont work...

Hello there, thank you for asking about your 2001 Ford Escape. You may have put in a spring incorrectly or did not adjust them tight enough before putting on the drum. If you think there is a missing spring then...

Squeaking noise when braking. Pads still very good.

The majority of modern cars on the road have certain wear marks in the brake pads that will make a squeaking noise when they reach a specific material thickness. When the pads wear down to a specific mark, they will...

Should I change my rotors?

If your rotors do not have a good clean smooth surface for the new pads to ride on then the pads will not be able to seat properly. This can lead to vehicle pull to one side or lack of...

After part replacements, spark plugs do not work - 1996 Lexus LX450

If you have a Check Engine Light on, first check for those codes to determine what engine management thinks is going on. If no trouble code, check the ignition fuse behind the driver side kick panel (carpeted panel at foot...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Hyundai Genesis
The The 2012 Hyundai Genesis is a midsize luxury sedan that is both powerful and well equipped with lots of standard features. It has an elegant look with the choice between V6 or two V8 engines. This four door sedan...
How Long Do Brake Rotors Last?
Brake rotors, sometimes called discs, are an important component of the braking system on any vehicle. The brake rotors are the part of...
Why Do Brake Rotors Warp?
Brake rotors are the large metal discs visible behind the wheels of a car. These spin along with the wheels so...