Q: Hi Ben, there was no leakage before I went for an oil change. The service center replace a nut at the oil pan and its leaking oil

asked by on December 30, 2016

As above. Was wondering if I should go ahead and do the repairs myself

My car has 126000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Change Oil and Filter $92.33 - $165.78 Get a Quote
Oil/Fluid Leak Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

If you went to a service center, in all probability the work that they performed is covered under a warranty of some sort. Additionally, if you paid by credit card, for sure you are covered if you have encountered a problem that was caused by the service center (you would simply maintain documentation and dispute the charge with the credit card company).

If the oil pan drain plug was replaced at the service center, and if that plug is the source of the leak, either the drain plug is "loose" or the gasketing (if used) is not sealing well. If, to repair this, they have to remove the drain plug to either repair the threads, or add a gasket to the drain plug, all the engine oil will have to be drained out. It is not recommended to return that oil to the engine. To get a sense of "who" you are dealing with, in the event that this is a drain plug issue, ask them what value they set the torque wrench to to tighten the drain plug. It will vary from car model to car model but in your case, according to the instructions, it is probably around 18 ft. lbs. (216 in. lbs.). Upon asking that, if they look at you like they never heard of a torque wrench, or it is obvious to you that they do not use such a tool, run for the exits (figuratively, get it repaired there because it will be no additional cost to you but do not deal with amateurs). You can get an oil change less expensively through YourMechanic and the drain plug will actually be tightened to the right amount using the right tool.

With regard to your very specific question as to whether you should repair it yourself, you could attempt it but you might have a circumstance where the drain plug hole has to be re-threaded, or a thread insert placed. Or, it could just be a missing gasket. Also, you have the issue of who pays for the new oil. Assuming they don’t do further damage, the cheapest option is to have them fix it and they assume these costs. If you desire that a professional look at it, simply request a leak inspection. If you have further concerns, by all means please follow-up and we will be glad to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

I have a 2014 isuzu nqr 5.2 engine

Humming sound when accelerating

i have a 90cc adly atv and it is having problems starting and staying running. what can i do to fix it?

The ignition and fuel systems will have to be diagnosed. Make sure you are not using old (stored) gasoline. Old gasoline alone can account for hard starting and poor operation and, as well, will cause continuing problems due to the...

Fromt left collision, curtain airbag didn't deploy. Should it have? I broke the window with my head.

Hi there. First and foremost, I'm glad you're able to send this question to YourMechanic.com - as an impact like you've described can be fatal in some cases. In regards to the side-air bag, the way in which they deploy...

When try to give my car a lot of gas at once it bogs down and wont trys to shift

Hi There, It sounds like you may have a fuel starvation problem due to a lack of sufficient fuel pressure. This can happen when the pump itself is not working properly or when the fuel pressure regulator is not maintaining...

Steering rack problem 2005 Audi A5

Hi there - yes, the "D" unit is an updated steering rack ("F" updated models are already available, so the updates continue). However, remember that this is electrically power-assisted, and there is a software component to the equation. If you...

Engine knock and low engine power

Hi there: The problem with trying to diagnose a ticking issue remotely is the fact that it could be multiple; yet completely different mechanical systems that are causing this issue; ranging from the timing chain being loose, to fuel system...

Tail lights and dash light don't work on a '94 Chevy 1500

It really depends on where you live and what the going rate is. I'm in a big city here at Houston and the dealer's charge around $120-140 per hour of labor. That might help you get an idea if you...

Lights come on, but car doesn't start

Hi. Even though the lights may be on in your car, this still does not signify there is enough power to start the car. The battery very well be on the brink of complete failure. I would recommend a certified...

Related articles

How Serious Is It When a Hose Is Leaking?
A leaking hose in your car could indicate different problems. Some leaking hoses are more serious than others, but all should be checked and repaired.
How Long Does a Vacuum Hose(s) Last?
Most Most car owners fail to realize just how important air flow is to the running of their vehicle. Nearly every system on your car requires air flow in order to function properly. The negative air flow, or vacuum, that...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Need to Haul a Motocross Bike
Of Of course you would love to be able to ride your motocross bike everywhere, but the reality is, at some point you're going to need to transport it. A cargo van of almost any make or model would be...