Q: Hello, I have a 2006 mazdaspeed 6 with 100,000 miles and a "blown third piston" is it worth fixing?

asked by on May 25, 2017

I have a CAI that sucks up water. Drove about 2 hours on the highway in a major storm and my car was bucking like crazy. I never noticed a major loss of power, very minimal. I did notice I was burning oil like crazy, about a quart and a half a week and had white smoke from the tailpipe that smelled odd. Took it to the shop and was told I had a blown 3rd piston. That's all I was told. Estimated a $5,000 fix. Should I get it fixed, swap engines, or just cut my losses?

My car has 100000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

It’s too bad that it failed this early in the game, but I don’t think there’s any future in fixing it. Just remember that an engine is only one of many very expensive parts on a car and once you’ve changed the engine, you will still be spending money on other major repairs as time goes by and the mileage racks up. In a way you can count yourself lucky. Many people go through a series of one or two thousand dollar repairs on an older car before they start to think of moving on. My guess is you haven’t spent any big money on this car yet. Some people like to use the formula comparing repair costs to car payments, and that has some merit, but one thing to keep in mind is that with car payments, at least you know how much it is going to be and when it will come so you can plan for it. Car repairs are not that predictable. If you decide to look at some used cars in the future, schedule a pre-purchase inspection with Your Mechanic. They can send a technician to the location of the car to check it out for you and make sure you’re not about to buy someone else’s problem.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

Brake pads fixed, parking brake, car won't start.

If the parking brake warning light is on and yet the parking brake is disengaged, that typically means that the switch is stuck. If the warning light yo are seeing though relates to the brakes generally, that could mean the...

This vehicles rpm is running at 2500 at 70 mph. The 4x4 & ABS light is on. Is it safe to drive it down the interstate ?

Vehicles are designed to operate with all their systems functioning in certain ways. When warning lights such as "4X4" or "ABS" are lit, there is a fault, or multiple faults in those systems preventing them from operating as they were...

My service charging system battery light is on after replacing my alternator with a brand new one. It is not charging my battery.

Hello, thank you for writing in. Several things may be going on. The installation of the new alternator needs to be verified, focusing on the electrical connections and the drive belt. Make sure the connections are clean, dry, and tight....

battery tested fine, car won't start

One way to diagnose this is to use a voltmeter to check for battery voltage at the starter motor when the key is held in the "start" position. If there is power to the starter motor, and yet it doesn't...

Radio only works through steering wheel controls

It sounds like the radio unit in your vehicle may have partially failed to where the controls no longer work. I would recommend having your radio inspected by a qualified professional. This inspection may involve the removal of the radio...

Engine idling and check engine light on

Carbon build-up on the intake valves is a common issue on the IS250. Lexus recommends to remove the valves and clean them while other manufacturers use anything from an intake cleaning solvent to sandblasting using walnut shells to remove the...

What causes reverse to go out in automatic transmission mini van

If you have all the forward gears and do not have any reverse then you may have an internal reverse band problem or the reverse solenoid is the problem. You will need to have the transmission computer scanned and transmission...

I have a Po171 code on a 2006 trailblazer

The cause behind diagnostic trouble code P0171 is easiest to find by looking at the secondary firing patterns on the Bank one cylinders. That will confirm if the too lean condition, that has caused the code to set, affects all...

I got oil changed n they told me I had metal in oil n two major oil leaks I got the car sept 24 from jd by rider of Greenville bk

Hello. Metal shavings or pieces in the oil pan can be a serious sign of major mechanic failure on the horizon. Did you personally see the metal shavings? Do you trust that this was an honest diagnosis? If so then...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy for Occasional Drivers
Not Not everyone relies on their car on a daily basis. Maybe you aren’t the type that deals with a daily commute, and running from here to there constantly. If that’s the case, you may be looking for a car...
A Buyer's Guide to the 2012 Mazda 2
For For those of you who really just want a car for the sake of transportation—and not towing or for a job where you need to transport tools—you might want to consider the 2012 Mazda 2. This car may not...
Ten Sports Cars That Double as Good Daily Drivers
The best daily driver is a car that's reliable, usable, and still fun to drive. Popular daily sports cars include the BMW M3, Subaru WRX, and VW GTI.