Q: Do I need a new transmission?

asked by on February 10, 2017

The car jerks several times after putting it into drive and won't move even though I'm pressing the accelerator. It will jerk and accelerate after a few seconds and usually no more jerks/stalls. If it is cold, it takes longer for the car to recover from the stall. There is also a reddish brown fluid beneath the car.

My car has 114000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The leak might be transmission fluid. If the transmission has been leaking for a while, the fluid level could have fallen low enough to cause engagement and shift difficulties. Therefore, you should first check the fluid level. If low, add fluid while being VERY careful not to overfill the transmission as overfilling is as bad as underfilling. If the difficulty then resolves itself, request a transmission fluid leak diagnostic in order to get the leak identified and repaired.


If the problem you are having is not due to a low fluid level, or is not resolved by adding fluid to the required level, please note that depending on the fault, transmissions are often repairable in the field, on or off the car. The cost of the repair will depend on exactly what has gone wrong with the transmission and so the best thing to do is get the issue properly diagnosed so that you can make an informed decision about how to proceed. As noted, some transmission faults arise because the the fluid level is too low, there could be a plugged filter, faulty shift solenoids or other frankly mundane and easily (on the car) repairable faults. If you desire that the problem with the transmission be diagnosed by a certified Mechanic, dispatched by YourMechanic right to your location, please request a transmission shift diagnostic and the responding certified mechanic will get this resolved for you. If you have further questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you, particularly if you just need more information to make wise, informed decision.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

The engine light just started blinking and it would jerk once I've accelerated to 20 mph.

Based upon the symptoms you are describing, it sounds like you may have a faulty camshaft position sensor. The camshaft position sensor is a magnetic sensor that monitors camshaft speed to regulate ignition timing and fuel injection timing. It gathers...

Can't find crank shaft sensor 2011 dodge caravan crew 3.6 flex fuel

You sound like you are describing two possible problems. Sometimes the engine will not turn over and other times it turns but will not start up and run. If you have to sometimes put it in neutral to get it...

Coolant leak on car

Hi. The water pump and radiator are common leaks on your van. Your cooling system will need to be inspected to find what part is leaking. It’s ok to add water to the system temporarily until the leak is repaired,...

Reduced engine power, possible vent valve solenoid malfunction.

Hi there. Typically the issue you're describing could be related to the EVAP vent solenoid, but I wouldn't rule out the EVAP canister purge solenoid. When this component is damaged, it can cause similar symptoms you're experiencing with your 2005...

Flapping sounds at average speed, steering wheel shakes

This type of situation is caused by a rotational imbalance or load variation on the tires. My recommendation would be to have the tire road force balanced and matched for least vibration. This type of balance will put the...

I have a wobble on the pulley and an oil leak, is it going to need a main bearing?

Hi there. The two symptoms you're describing (the front oil leak and the crankshaft pulley wobble) are two of the best indicators that a professional mechanic should use to diagnose that the issue is the pulley or the seal behind...

What could be the likely problem of an "check advtrac" light staying on in my 05 Ford explorer ( 4wd )

Advancetrac is your vehicle's traction control system. Your vehicle is equipped with wheel speed sensors at each of the four wheels which monitor wheel speed while relaying this information simultaneously to the ABS and traction control system which are controlled...

I'm experiencing a steady drain of coolant. I'm not noticing any overheating, and keep topping up the level

Is there a large wet spot under the vehicle after it has been used? A puddle under certain areas of the vehicle may shed a little light on where to look for the leak. A technician can top off the...

No acceleration

If this started happening right after being jumped then there may be an electrical problem. If the battery cables were hooked up backwards at any point then it may have blown a fuse. A mechanic would usually start by checking...

Related articles

How Long Does an AC Accumulator Last?
Your Your vehicle’s air conditioning system is a complex system of components, each of which plays an important role. However, not all the components will continue to work properly if they come into contact with moisture, and that is where...
How Long Does a Transfer Case Output Shaft Seal Last?
The The transfer case output shaft seal is located on the transfer case of vehicles with four-wheel drive. This transfer case allows you to switch between two-wheel drive, neutral, to, low four-wheel, and drive four-wheel drive. The case consists of...
How to Use Engine Block Sealer to Repair a Head Gasket Leak
Head gasket leaks occur when engines overheat and can be costly to repair. Engine block sealer can be a quick and easy alternative for minor cases.