Q: Clutch issues

asked by on July 13, 2016

Hi Had a lot of issues with chattering when releasing the clutch. In 02/16 it quit on the side of the road. Mechanic advised seal in the slave cylinder had gone & put in a new clutch assembly which incl. new slave cylinder & they resurfaced the flywheel. Upon return we noticed a new issue: often when coming to a stop & shifting into 1st gear, it won't go in. You have to shift into 2nd & then it goes into 1st OK. Not knowing much about this, we figured since it was new, it was just tighter. About 2 mos later we noticed once the engine was warm (hwy driving about 15 mins) the chattering was back & getting worse & worse. Took back to the same mech. who advised the issue was bad engine mounts. 2 other mechanics state that's not the issue. Dealership thinks it's a faulty clutch or has to do with the resurface of the flywheel. The issue is getting worse, so much so that on one trip, after about 2 hrs hwy driving it was so bad it wouldn't engage at all. Eventually did. No leaks. Any ideas?

My car has 130000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Clutch is not working Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

It’s always a challenge when multiple people get involved, as it can get very confusing since you won’t know who is wrong or right. Let’s begin with the shifting into first gear issue. This is most commonly an issue with the hydraulic portion of the system. This includes the clutch master, clutch slave and the clutch pedal. Clutch hydraulics can be very difficult to thoroughly bleed and this is where I would begin addressing the issue of getting into first gear. It will take some patience on the mechanics part. A thorough inspection the clutch system is needed.

As for the chattering, this is most commonly and issue with the clutch to flywheel interface. But chattering can be a result of crankshaft end play. The clutch pressure plate could have issues as well. Again, this will need thorough diagnosing.

Since you noticed an issue as soon as the car was returned to you, it would seem to be the responsibility of the mechanic who replaced the clutch. Unless they are not cooperating with you, I would give them a chance to take a look at it. Keep in mind, it has been sometime since the initial clutch replacement, so there is almost no way for the mechanic to verify if it was something they did or something else that has developed. If you want the car looked at by an independent technician, book one of our technicians to diagnose the clutch issue for you. They will be able to pinpoint the problem and advise you on the correct repair.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

Thumps and grinding noises in differential

It is possible that you could have a faulty wheel bearing. Wheel bearings can often cause grinding noises when the lubrication onside them dries up. I would recommend having your vehicle inspected once more for a rear wheel bearing failure....

Check engine light is off and when I turn on the key the car won't start. Just happened after changing the clutch kit.

Hi there. If the vehicle ran before you performed the job for the clutch exchange, then back track the work you had performed and look for anything that is not plugged in. Most likely, the crankshaft sensor was unplugged and...

Car makes a noise when I accelerate

Some noise from these engines is considered normal, especially on cold start. The noise is often the result of "piston slap" caused by excessive piston to cylinder wall clearance. The noise goes away when the engine warms up and the...

Car vibrating under acceleration

There are many things that can cause a vibration like what you are describing. Rotating parts that are off balance for some reason are usually the issue. Since a car has many rotating parts, it is usually best to seek...

2007 Dodge Grand Caravan hard detonation problems

Take a compression tester and check the compression of each cylinder. This will determine how much pressure will hold in the cylinders. If the pressure is 120 or higher, then the cylinders are okay. If the pressure is lower than...

Car wouldn't go over 50 mph I went over and next thing you know I hear loud knocking from the engine

The knocking is suggestive of a mechanical failure of some sort. I would first measure cylinder compression to get a basic idea of the condition of the engine. If it doesn't test well (too low and/or too much variance) you...

Oil under car

Oil leaks generally will become worse over time. Locations where leaks commonly develop are at the valve cover, oil pan or camshaft and crankshaft seals. The source of the oil leak will need to be located, and then the leak...

Cruise Control feature doesn't work

The cruise control computer requires inputs from many different systems to function properly. The throttle body sensors, fuel injectors, and throttle plate are all contributors to the cruise control computer readings. If a fault is present in any of these...

Temp gauge fluating between halfway and hot but runs at halfway mark on freeway but rises to hot at lights

Hi there. The temperature gauge fluctuating between halfway and hot, at stops, is most likely the radiator cooling fan(s) is inoperative. This could be caused by a blown fan fuse, a faulty cooling fan relay, a faulty cooling fan switch,...

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Clutch Slave Cylinder
If your manual car has abnormal pedal feel, low or contaminated brake fluid, or any visible leaks, you may need to replace the clutch slave cylinder.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Sliding Motor Door Assembly
Common signs include sliding doors not opening, noise coming from the door, and metal-to-metal grinding when opening and closing the door.
Is it Safe to Drive With an Exhaust Leak?
Your vehicle’s exhaust system keeps the car quiet and the exhaust fumes away from the cabin. Furthermore, the system helps...