Q: Car won't start - 2004 Volkswagen Golf

asked by on September 13, 2016

I just got a brand new battery and alternator put in for my car, and it still won't start. My mechanic let me know that the AC and heat unit was drawing too much energy and to keep it off, and I have been - but the car still won't turn. It sounds like it's trying when you crank it, but no spark/nothing. I was driving it a week ago just fine - with the AC and heat unit off.

Hello. I will help you on this. It’s unclear whether you bought a new battery and a new alternator because those parts were accurately diagnosed as defective. A battery must be load tested, only after it is fully charged, in order to determine if it is defective.

An alternator must also be tested according to specific instructions in the Factory Service Manual (FSM). If these tests were not performed and a mechanic just told you to change out those parts, then you need a new mechanic. In the world of automobile technology, there is no diagnosis that refers to an AC system or a heating system that draws too much energy. The diagnosis the Mechanic gave is a bit imprecise. We can speak of electrical faults in the electrical segment of an A/C system as "drawing too much energy" but typically such will blow a fuse. At any rate, your A/C and heating systems and their energy consumption and the electrical and mechanical load they place in your engine have nothing to do with your no start condition. You may want to have the mechanic explain their findings back to you more specifically or have a second mechanic diagnose the no start for you. The mechanic can then resolve your issue by replacing only those parts that are necessary to get your car running. Given the age of your car, certain "tune-up" parts might be recommended as well such as plug wires, spark plugs, fuel filter and so forth the replacement of which will help you avoid future problems if those parts are past due for replacement.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How should pregnant women use the seat belt?
Anyone riding in or driving the car must be buckled up. Not only is it the law, but it’s the only way to reduce the chance of injury during an accident. Don’t rely on your air bags to protect you....
Car only staying started for five seconds
If the powertrain control module (PCM) does not have proper communication with the Sentry Key Remote Entry Module (SKREEM), the PCM will shut off fuel after two seconds of run time. A full key cycle down sequence must be performed...
Loud grinding noise coming from engine
Hello. If there is a loud noise like that coming from the engine accompanied by a misfire and fuel from the exhaust, then you may have a valve timing problem. It may be a failure in the timing chain. I...
Engine sputtering and "service traction system" control light coming on
The Powertrain Control Module needs to be scanned to see if there are any stored codes. A possible issue could be the mass air sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-mass-airflow-sensor), as this sets up initial injection timing. The air mass meter needs to be...
Car won't start, latching noise
If when turning the key you hear a loud click or latching noise, that may be the starter gear kicking out to contact the engine flywheel in an attempt to start. Test the battery (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/service-battery-cables) while trying to start the...
loss of power. 2003 Mazda 6
Hi there, thanks for writing in. You should check to see if the timing belt (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/timing-belt-replacement) is off or jumped, or your injectors (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-injector-replacement) have some blockage and needs to be cleaned cleaned. Also, make sure you have a clean...
Coolant is not being pulled from the reservoir.
Hello. From what you describe, it appears that your vehicle may be leaking coolant or may perhaps have air in the cooling system. First off, I would carefully inspect the engine bay and undersides of the vehicle for any signs...
Drive shaft replacement
Hello. Replacing a driveshaft usually require replacement of the driveshaft itself and any bearings or couplings that go with it. Most driveshafts will have at least one center support bearing or flex coupler joint that should also be replaced at...
No pressure at clutch pedal
Hello. If you are not getting any pressure to the pedal then it may be possible that there is an issue with the clutch master cylinder. The clutch master cylinder is the component responsible for generating pressure for the clutch...

Related articles

How Long Can I Leave the AC on While My Engine Is Not Running?
You’ve parked your car, and are sitting inside waiting. Maybe you’re early for work and don’t want to head into...
How to Diagnose a Stalling Car
It’s It’s incredibly frustrating to have a car that stalls and it always seems to happen at the worst possible time – like when you’re in middle of a busy intersection with fifty enraged drivers behind you. There are a...
How to Diagnose Your Car's Air Conditioning System
There There is never a good time for your air conditioning in your car to stop working, but it typically seems to happen in the dead heat of summer. If your AC system has either quit working or has stopped...