Q: Car occasionally won't start. Is it the starter?

asked by on October 25, 2016

Occasionally, my car won't start. There is no cranking or other noises. Also, all lights and radio come on when I turn the key. My car runs after it's jumped. I have a new battery and the car has been tested in that respect. A mechanic today said it was the starter. However, I'm not sure. What do you think? Parts and labor are expensive for my car. Thank you.

Connie cmark@midco.net

My car has 164000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hello. If the alternator is working and the battery is new, as you say, then the mechanic may be right. The starter itself may not be dead so much as it would be that the solenoid is sticking. When that happens there is no click, no nothing one moment, then the next time, it may start as though there was nothing wrong. Since the solenoid switch comes with the starter, it is common practice to replace starter and solenoid together. They can be changed separately, but you don’t really save any money by doing that. If you would like to have this inspected by another technician, or if you would like to move forward with the starter replacement, then consider YourMechanic, as our technicians can perform services at the site of your car.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

I have a creaking/squeaking noise when turning the steering wheel

If an assistant, preferably a mechanic, listens at the relevant suspension and steering components under the vehicle as you turn the steering wheel the sound can undoubtedly be pinpointed. Be sure to check at the top of the spring tower...

knocking from suspension.. already replaced complete strut units (spring/strut

Hello, and thank you for writing in. Replacing the struts was a good starting point. Now you are going to want to inspect the rest of the steering and suspension components (which are very closely related). Turn the steering wheels...

My ignition and steering wheel got locked. After getting it unlocked, it wont start. System is saying start then an error shows.

Hi there. If you're having problems with the steering wheel and ignition cylinder being locked and the vehicle is having issues starting, the problem may be with the ignition lock cylinder. Sometimes the components inside the ignition lock cylinder can...

Related articles

How the Starter Works in Your Car
A A car starter is a powerful electric motor that cranks your engine in order to start your car. The starting system consists of the motor itself, and the attached solenoid. The solenoid is what takes battery power and delivers...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re Shorter Than Average
Vertically Vertically challenged? Hate getting behind the wheel and having to crane your neck to see? There’s nothing wrong with you, but there is something wrong with your car. It might be time to trade it in and take advantage...
The Best Used Cars to Buy for First Time Car Owners
Owning Owning your very first car is an exciting time in a person’s life. Likely you want to put a lot of thought and research into the process to ensure you get something that meets your needs, is fun to...