Q: Car has power reduction and grinding noise

asked by on September 08, 2016

My car has been shifting rough and I went to the dealership and reported this. I was told that this was normal. I trusted the mechanic and so I went ahead and used my car. A few months later while I was driving in a parking lot, the transmission failed, the engine shut off while the car was moving and I was jerked to a stop abruptly. I went to the dealership and they explained to me that the problem was due to computer errors controlling the transmission. Then three months after that, my car looses a good bit of its power, develops a grinding noise, and the check engine light came on. Fortunately I was only a few blocks from the dealership and managed to get there in my car. There were a number of faults, according to the technicians and they reported these to VW of America to get advice on how to proceed. They eventually decided that part of the transmission called the mechatronics unit needed replacing, but they had no idea of when one would be available. They told me gave the car back to me and told me to drive it until the parts arrived. Really??!! They told me that it was just a noise. I responded with repeating to them about the serious power reduction that had occurred and the previous problem just a few months ago when my car had complete failure of the engine and the transmission. They denied that these two problems could be related. After my complaining to them, they said I could rent a car and I kept complaining until they gave me a loaner. I am thinking that they are using a tactic of which I have read, on how to get around lemon law liability. I am concerned that the real problem isn’t being considered by them. Please give me your assessment of all of this and any advice that you can give.

Grinding sound from transmission Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

Hello. From the symptoms you are describing it would appear that the vehicle may be experiencing some sort of mechanical issue with the engine or transmission. The issues may or may not be related, however that should not be an issue if the vehicle is under factory warranty. I would recommend having the vehicle diagnosed for grinding sounds from the transmission by a certified technician from YourMechanic, just to verify the issue. I would also verify with the dealership that they are in fact actively looking for, or in the process of ordering the component you need. If the vehicle is still under factory warranty the dealership should be able to help you without much question, and may put themselves at risk of legal issues if they refuse to. If you do decide to continue driving the vehicle, I would also verify with the dealership that they understand that they are at liable if any other issues occur, due to the fact that they told you it was safe to continue driving the vehicle.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Check [engine](/topics-engine-chevy/) light on... codes p2076 , p0420,p0128

I have a 2000 Dodge Durango my ac compressor went out. Now there is light white smoke coming out the tailpipe. Is it due to the ac

If the refrigerant in the A/C system leaks, that refrigerant can't get into the exhaust system. White smoke in the exhaust is typically due to engine coolant leaking into the combustion chambers and such a leak could be due to...

Downsizing for winter tires

Even though the rims are different sizes the two tires are very close in size for height and width and will not cause any issues using them. You do not need to have an alignment since this is for the...

AC is not blowing cold and a plastic-like smell when AC is on.

There are different possibilities that could contribute to the plastic smell. The smell could be caused by a coolant leak, an electrical issue, the A/C compressor overheating, or simply an outside smell. Sometimes, plastic bags tend to get stuck...

My truck struggles to start and stay running

This sounds like a fuel pump that is weak to start the vehicle and then stops pumping after ten minutes when it heats up. Have the fuel pressure checked to see if it is holding pressure and keeps pressure when...

Won't start

Hello, thanks for writing in. From what you describe it would appear that your vehicle is experiencing some sort of engine performance or electrical issue. If the warning lights are on then I would scan the computer for trouble codes...

Spark plug blew out

Spark plugs blowing out are not uncommon for that specific year and engine of the vehicle. When a spark plug blows out, usually the threads need to be repaired, or replaced, and a new spark plug installed. This job may...

Car won't start after removing sysLOCATE device

The SysLocate GPS system was designed to track the location and the speed of the vehicle it was installed in. If the device's power supply was being pulled from the wrong power source or if it wasn't uninstalled correctly, this...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Ford Fiesta
This This subcompact vehicle is available as a 4-door sedan as well as a 5-door hatchback. The prices for the vehicle are very low, even for the models that are decked out with all of the optional features. Those who...
2012 Ford Fusion vs. 2012 Toyota Camry: Which Should I Buy?
While most people believe that domestic sedans just cannot compete with the Honda Accord and the Toyota Camry, the industry leaders, that is not necessarily true. Yes, there are some metrics where the Camry just excels, however the Ford Fusion...