Q: Car has power reduction and grinding noise

asked by on September 08, 2016

My car has been shifting rough and I went to the dealership and reported this. I was told that this was normal. I trusted the mechanic and so I went ahead and used my car. A few months later while I was driving in a parking lot, the transmission failed, the engine shut off while the car was moving and I was jerked to a stop abruptly. I went to the dealership and they explained to me that the problem was due to computer errors controlling the transmission. Then three months after that, my car looses a good bit of its power, develops a grinding noise, and the check engine light came on. Fortunately I was only a few blocks from the dealership and managed to get there in my car. There were a number of faults, according to the technicians and they reported these to VW of America to get advice on how to proceed. They eventually decided that part of the transmission called the mechatronics unit needed replacing, but they had no idea of when one would be available. They told me gave the car back to me and told me to drive it until the parts arrived. Really??!! They told me that it was just a noise. I responded with repeating to them about the serious power reduction that had occurred and the previous problem just a few months ago when my car had complete failure of the engine and the transmission. They denied that these two problems could be related. After my complaining to them, they said I could rent a car and I kept complaining until they gave me a loaner. I am thinking that they are using a tactic of which I have read, on how to get around lemon law liability. I am concerned that the real problem isn’t being considered by them. Please give me your assessment of all of this and any advice that you can give.

Hello. From the symptoms you are describing it would appear that the vehicle may be experiencing some sort of mechanical issue with the engine or transmission. The issues may or may not be related, however that should not be an issue if the vehicle is under factory warranty. I would recommend having the vehicle diagnosed for grinding sounds from the transmission by a certified technician from YourMechanic, just to verify the issue. I would also verify with the dealership that they are in fact actively looking for, or in the process of ordering the component you need. If the vehicle is still under factory warranty the dealership should be able to help you without much question, and may put themselves at risk of legal issues if they refuse to. If you do decide to continue driving the vehicle, I would also verify with the dealership that they understand that they are at liable if any other issues occur, due to the fact that they told you it was safe to continue driving the vehicle.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

How do I adjust the steering wheel of a 2012 Honda CR-V?

Adjusting the steering wheel is an important thing to do. Having the steering wheel adjusted to the optimal position for you will increase your ability to drive safely, and also increase your comfort. It’s very easy to adjust the steering...

How do I check the level of the brake and clutch fluid?

Both your brakes and your clutch (if you have a stick shift) are hydraulic, and require fluid in order to operate. Checking the level of fluid in both reservoirs is important – low fluid can lead to component damage or...

Accelerating after 4th/5th gear, RPMs up, but no faster

Yes, your clutch is slipping and needs to be replaced. As for the high quality fuel, top tier gasoline does have additives designed to keep your engine and fuel system clean. Will you ever notice a difference while driving?...

Related articles

The Top 5 Selling Cars in Florida in 2012
Florida Florida offers great weather year round, and the fact that snow and ice never factor into the equation means drivers don’t have to focus on the overall vehicle handling as they do in other states. The best selling cars...
How to Replace a Vent Oil Separator
A car engine has a vent oil separator that fails when vapors clog the separator, smoke emits from the exhaust, or the Check Engine Light illuminates.
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Personal Trainer
As As a personal trainer, you either operate out of a gym, or you go to your clients. Either way, you probably don’t have to haul any more gear than what fits into your gym bag, so your main focus...