Q: Brake Pad or Caliper Issue?

asked by on November 08, 2016

Got new brake pads at 39K miles, which seemed premature as I don't tow a trailer or anything. They were at 3mm. Mechanic asked me if I drag my foot on the brake and I do not. He thought 39K seemed too soon as well to show that much wear.

Well, with new pads and 5K miles later, right front wheel is black - covered in brake dust. Left front wheel is normal color - same as back wheels. I think maybe I have a right front brake caliper dragging and that is a) what caused my premature brake wear the first time and b) what is now causing one wheel to be black with dust. Also seems like my MPG is not as good.

Is there a fix for this OR do I just need new calipers? If this is even the correct solution, I am guessing at that.

Thank You.

My car has 45000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Brake safety Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

It is normal for the front brakes to last about 35k to 40k miles before needing to be replaced. When the brake pads were replaced it should of been noted if the right pads were worn down to 3mm and the left side pads were not. If the pads were wearing even on both sides, then there is not a problem with the brakes most likely. It is normal for the wheels to get covered with brake dust and should be cleaned off at every car wash. If you suspect the brakes are having a problem causing excessive wear or loss of fuel mileage, then have a brake inspection done to check to see if the brakes are wearing normal and not binding. If one of the calipers were binding then you may notice a pull to one side or the other.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I access the glove box?
The glove box is located in front of the front passenger seat, and offers a storage space for important items. It is a great place to store your vehicle information, such as your registration and insurance. To open the glove...
Car overheats
Overheating is a fairly common issue with many vehicles. The most common cause of an engine to overheat would be a coolant leak. If a leak exists, the engine will not have enough coolant to keep the temperature within specification....
when i turn my steering wheel to the right--even slightly--my engine stops. why
Hi there, thanks for writing in. I have never experienced this exact issue before. First we should address the vacuum leak, which could cause the car to stall while idling, as well as being a potential cause of the oxygen...
Vehicle runs roughly, shudders and rattles, vacuum leak
Thanks for writing in about your 2000 Chrysler Cirrus. When the coils were removed to replace the spark plugs, they should have been inspected for oil getting on them from a leaking valve cover. The leaking valve cover may leak...
Hi, how can I dismantling the oil sump? do you have a picture or service manual of this car? Thanks!
Unfortunately, I will not be able to post a picture of this repair. The service manual recommends pulling the engine to perform the repair. YourMechanic does not do this kind of service on your vehicle. I suggest purchasing a service...
How can I tell what amp my alternator is?
Hey there. You should have a stamp on the alternator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-buy-a-good-quality-alternator) with a part number and amperage. The part number that starts with F3UZ is the 130 amp, and the F1TZ is the 95 amp. You can use either one....
Car has trouble shifting between gears
As you know, automatic transmissions use pressurized hydraulic fluid to change gears. Every time a gear change is required, the car's computer activates a transmission solenoid, which directs transmission fluid into the valve body to engage the correct gear. When...
My car is showing code P1445
Hi Emily. This is one of the common codes associated with the secondary air injection system on that particular Toyota engine. One of the valves may have failed or has contamination inside. The secondary air injection system is an emission...
I have a 2007 GMC sierra classic. What can be the problem if I have no pressure on the brakes
Hi Jessica. Thanks for contacting us today. One of the most overlooked components that can cause a brake pedal issues like you've described is the proportioning valve. This component is located under the hood and is responsible for adjusting the...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re an Interior Designer
As As an interior designer, you need to transport a great many different items, including fabric, paint and wallpaper samples and sometimes even furniture items. You probably don’t handle overly large loads very often, and when you have to, you’ll...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Love Camping
Do Do you love camping, getting back to nature and enjoying life in the great outdoors? If you do, then you know that getting there can be half the fun, and it’s even better if you have a great ride....
How Do I Know If I Need New Brake Pads?
Car brakes squeak when the pads are worn and need to be replaced. Replace your car brake pads every 35,000 miles to maintain safe braking performance.