Q: 2001 Acura cl s won't hold any gear except park. Acts like a false neutral. Before this happened it didn't slip out of gear at the

asked by on August 17, 2017

2001 Acura cl type s Worked perfectly and one day it just down shifted bad and wouldn't change gear. Stopped and restarted it and it worked fine again for a few days then did it again. Now my car won't hold any gear besides park and a false neutral in all gears. I've replaced the TC checked and cleaned all solenoids, replaced speed sensors, both pressure switches. Flushed my transmission completely fluid is red now before I replaced and cleaned everything it was a dirty brown. The only other thing I can think of is the neutral safety switch. Can anyone help??? I never slipped gear at all so I don't believe it's mechanical

My car has 196000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi Tyler. If the transmission fluid was a dirty brown when it was replaced, it’s possible that you’ve got an inner seal that is faulty - or the transmission fluid filter is corroded, creating a blockage inside hydraulic lines. I would agree that a neutral safety switch could cause the symptoms you are describing. If you haven’t changed the transmission filter, you might want to start by completing this, replace the neutral safety switch, but also double check all the electrical harnesses and connections to those sensors, as typically those also tend to fail overtime.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How does the front passenger power window switch work?
Your car is equipped with power windows in the front and rear (unless you drive a coupe, in which case you only have front windows anyway). The passenger side power window switch offers the ability to do three things: Roll...
Car overheats when heater not on
There can be a variety of reasons that your Ford Five Hundred is overheating, even after repairs have been made. While it is possible you are experiencing problems with the water pump, you may have a defective new thermostat as...
What should i do the light came on of the electric power steering indicator
Hello there. A few common faults will cause the electronic power steering warning light to be displayed. The most common are the power steering module, steering angle sensor, or wiring harness fault. If you need to have this checked, a...
My Check Engine Light came on - 2011 Hyundai Accent
When the Check Engine Light comes on, it means the engine controller has detected a fault in one of the sensor inputs and that the fault is bad enough to affect the emissions. Most cars have additional warning lights for...
Why would my passenger side drum brake engage when I'm not touching the brake pedal and then release?
Do any warning lights come on when this happens? If you are having an issue with the ABS system (which is kind of unlikely), or an issue with the brake sensors the vehicle will likely set codes (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-read-and-understand-check-engine-light-codes-by-jason-unrau) which can...
Are the miles too high for me to buy this car?
I would recommend checking the Kelly Blue Book Value (http://www.kbb.com/) for your car which is relevant to your particular zip code. This should give you an indication of generally what the car is worth. You will of course want to...
Won't start after putting in new alternator, battery, starter and fuses.
Hi there. Check the battery cables (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/service-battery-cables) and make sure that they are hooked up properly. Look to see if there is an issue with a loose ground on the fuse box. When smoke comes from the battery cables, that...
Is it dangerous to drive with the service advancetrac light on
Hi there. It really depends as to what is causing the light to illuminate that would determine the safety of continual driving. In general, the warning light will illuminate when a system sensor detects a fault within one of the...
White smoke ticking not overheating
If you have white smoke out of the exhaust and are not getting low on coolant then you may have a cylinder that is low on compression or not firing. Have the misfiring cylinder compression checked on that side of...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Acura TSX SportWagon
The The 2012 Acura TSX SportWagon has the perfect combination of utility and performance. The vehicle is pleasant to drive and makes luxury a priority. The TSX SportWagon uses electrically boosted power steering, which provides you with more stability driving...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're On a Budget
If If you’re on a budget and need to purchase a car it can feel as though it’s slim pickings. Thankfully, there are plenty of great options available even to those on a tight budget. Let’s take a look. The...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If Your Kid's On the Soccer Team
If If you are a soccer mom (or dad), you know that you need a lot of space to transport your budding World Cup contenders, along with their gear. From time to time, you can also expect to be bringing...