Q: '05 subaru forester automatic jolts when shifting to 2nd gear

asked by on February 26, 2018

Car sometimes jolts quite hard when shifting from 1st to 2nd gear. This only happens when the car has been sitting for several days and is more likely to happen when it is cold outside. Once or twice on extremely cold days it struggled to get into 3rd, but MUCH less pronounced. Yesterday, after the car had not been driven for 1 week, it failed to shift up into 2nd gear at all and chugged hard while stopped at red light (as though it was about to stall). The check engine light came on and off a few times (I managed to crawl back to parking space in 1st gear). Warmed car up this morning for 5 minutes and reversed back and forth twice before driving it to mechanic with no problems - shifted smoothly, accelerated normally. Mechanic had no problems during road test, says fluid levels/quality are good, no problems indicated on computer readout. What could be going on?

My car has 77000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Many newer automatic transmissions have temperature-sensors in them that, on a stone-cold start, restrict normal shift to only the lower (or non-overdrive gears) until the engine coolant and transmission fluid reach a certain level which in many engines, is around 140 degrees. At that point, engineers generally consider an engine or transmission fully warm for fluid-circulation and engine-stress purposes (this is usually at the lower end of the normal range on an analog temperature-gauge, or when the blue cold-engine light goes off). In some cases, this temperature sensor may fail resulting in delayed shifting or erratic shifting. I would suggest having a professional from YourMechanic come to your location to diagnose and inspect your vehicle.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

When front axle cv shaft is repaired does it come with cv boot

There are a couple basic scenarios when it comes to CV axle repair or replacement. If you have a torn boot on the vehicle, and it has not been torn for long and thus the CV joint is not yet...

What is normal idle for a 2005 Ford focus?

Hi There, Generally, the warm up high idle will last for less than a minute or so depending on the outside ambient temperature, however once the temperature sensor reaches the normal operating temperature (usually between 190-200 degrees F). This will...

Water pump is leaking, do I need to replace the timing belt, too? The car also has a misfire on cylinder 3.

Hi there. If the engine has too many miles on a timing belt, then a timing belt is suggested for replacement. The misfire for cylinder 3 could be caused by a spark plug failure, fuel injector failure, or a problem...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Just Had a Baby
Having Having a baby will completely change your life. Your activities and hobbies will change. Your sleeping patterns will change. Chances are good that you’ll also be looking for a change in vehicles. You need to ensure that your car...
Ten Sports Cars That Double as Good Daily Drivers
The best daily driver is a car that's reliable, usable, and still fun to drive. Popular daily sports cars include the BMW M3, Subaru WRX, and VW GTI.
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Live in a Tropical Climate
If If you live in a tropical climate, most of your vehicle purchasing concerns will be essentially the same as if you lived anywhere else – you want a car that looks good, offers decent gas mileage, and suits the...