Q: Sporadically overheating

asked by on July 04, 2017

My car overheats at the most random of times. Used to be very frequent but I changed the thermostat and burped the cooling system. Now it may be once every week/week and a half. I changed the thermostat twice, mechanics thought it may be faulty. They are now thinking it's the head gasket. We used a sealant and it drove fine for 2 weeks and the temp gauge started jumping up and down and then stayed up (the next morning was fine again). I really don't want to believe it's the head gasket. I looked up head gasket symptoms and they don't seem to fit, except the overheating. Oil and coolant levels are fine. I have a new water pump, radiator, thermostat, and fan. Also, what does a compression test do? I was told to do that to see if it is the head gasket. Thank you for your help in advance!

My car has 171000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi There, It sounds like you may possibly have a blown head gasket, but performing a compression test will certainly help to narrow this down. A compression test will indocate how much compression (PSI) is present in each cylinder. If any of the cylinders are lower than normal or if one of them is drastically out of line with the others, this may indicate you have a blown head gasket. A blown head gasket may cause a number of different symptoms. A head gasket that fails between cylinders will generally cause a misfire and potentially compression leaks from one cylinder into another. Low compression will eventually result in a rough idling engine. When the head gasket fails between a cylinder and the coolant port, coolant may leak into the cylinder causing it to be burnt with the fuel charge in the combustion chamber. This often results in misfires on startup, especially after the engine is run, turned off and restarted and in some cases may result in the engine not maintaining enough cylinder compression to even run or start. This type of failure may not always show with a compression test. I would recommend having an expert from YourMechanic come to your location to properly diagnose the symptoms you describe.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

2007 hyundai tucson . oil light came on first then car started to slow down . it caught back up the started to slow down again. I pulled over and now the car won't start. I used starter fluid, nothing. I pulled a spark plug but am getting no spark

My Dodge truck overheated and turned off on me while I was driving and now it won't start

Failure to re-start after overheating is typically due to component damage. That could be a damaged crankshaft position sensor, stuck valves, and so forth. The overheating doesn't change the diagnostic, although to rule out mechanical causes, you could check cylinder...

Chrysler 300c is misfiring and won't stay running but no lights are on

It is possible that you could have an issue with fuel delivery to the engine. It is also possible that you have a check engine light and the check engine light itself is burned out. I would recommend having your...

Does the 2008 Kia Optima have an ABS system? Does anything need to be pressed when changing the wheel hub/bearing assembly?

Hi Laura. Thanks for writing in today. In regards to whether your 2008 Kia Optima has ABS, that depends on what model you have. ABS is an optional upgrade that is available in multiple trim levels. The best way to...

I have a 2008 Chevy Cobalt and will be replacing both CV Axle Shafts. Do I have to get an alignment after?

In short no you do not as long as the lower ball joint is taken loose and not the strut bolts. If you loosen the strut bolts then you will need an alignment.

1998 mercedes benz c280 transmission fluid leak from top

Hi there. Unfortunately, we are not able to receive pictures or video to pinpoint damage or identify parts for vehicles through this platform. The best way to identify this item is to search online for a detailed schematic of your...

Engine oil light comes on and then goes out when driving

Hi There, The engine oil light is driven by the oil pressure in the motor at any given time. When you first start the vehicle up, this light comes on as it does a system check and momentarily detects engine...

Oil pressure sensor....need changed or just dirty

You may still want to have the system checked in person for a possible bad sensor or connection to the sensor. After washing, you may have washed away some corrosion on the connector to the sensor. If you have a...

Related articles

A Buyer's Guide to the 2012 Honda Crosstour
There There could be a number of reasons an SUV isn’t right for you: the price, the size, their mpg, etc. However, there could also be a number of reasons you’d really like to have some extra space. If that’s...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Doctor Who Makes House Calls
If If you are a doctor who makes house calls, reliability is likely to be at the forefront of your mind when it comes to choosing a used car. You also expect a certain level of comfort. We have...
2012 Honda Accord vs. 2012 Honda Civic: Which One Should I Buy?
The Honda Civic was the best-selling compact car as well as the third-best-selling car overall in 2012. With its unique blend of reliability, affordability and refinement, the Civic is a gold standard for transportation in general. While the Accord is...