Q: Should I replace my head gasket or just buy a new car?

asked by on August 03, 2017

I need to replace the head gasket on my 2006 Subaru B9 Tribeca - it would cost about $2,400 - It's not an urgent need but I have been made aware that it will need to be done in the next 3,000 miles or so. With the wear & tear on my car it's probably only worth about $3,000 - $3,500. I'd be interested in getting a car that's a bit more reliable and not as expensive to fix. Would it be a better financial decision to fix the head gasket and keep driving the Subaru? Or to trade in the Subaru and just get a new/used car?

My car has 106000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Change Oil and Filter $103.58 - $181.08 Get a Quote
Transmission Fluid Service $140.08 - $502.73 Get a Quote
Rotate Tires Get a Quote

Unfortunately, this is a decision you would need to make on your own. As you know, a blown head gasket can be very expensive to fix no matter the vehicle. This is not specific to a Subaru necessarily. As you may know, on any vehicle, the amount of labor required to change a head gasket is very time consuming and tedious.

As with any car, the life expectancy depends largely on how you maintain the car, the driving conditions it is subjected to, the driving habits of the owner and many other factors. Proper maintenance schedules are a key factor to prolonging the longevity of the vehicle and avoiding unnecessary costly repair bills due to neglecting proper maintenance intervals. Things like oil changes, transmission fluid services, and tire rotations are all basic maintenance items that will drastically prolong the life of the vehicle and prevent premature wearing on parts. I would suggest having a professional from YourMechanic come to your location to take a look at your car and come up with a routine maintenance schedule for your vehicle.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the Uconnect voice training system?
If your Uconnect is having a hard time recognizing what are saying, then you can use the voice training feature. This will help your Uconnect system recognize your voice. You can turn on the voice training system in four different...
Problem with two front doors.
In regards to the door that doesn't close always. The door latch mechanism can be lubricated with a spray lubricant. A dry graphie or white lithium grease are good lubricants to use. These will need to be sprayed on the...
How do I turn on the CD player?
To turn on the CD player, press the CD/AUX button.
Advice on changing the fluid in the differential
Differential fluid on a lot of modern cars has it built in the transmission. For example, for a 2002 Toyota Camry, when you change the transmission fluid you are also changing the differential fluid (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-often-do-i-need-to-replace-my-car-s-differential-fluid). They share the common fluid....
Creaking sound at the rear end, at lower speeds
From what you've described it sounds like a problem with your suspension, there is a couple of things you will need to inspect. Check and lube any of the rubber sway bar and control arm bushings. Inspect the springs that...
my fuel gauge temp oil preassure and battery gauges all stoped working.
When you lose any electric items or accessories, I suggest first checking all your fuses. You can pull the fuse out to check it, but even better is to use a test light to test the fuses with them still...
Radiator fan is not turning on
Once the relay and fuse have been checked and are working, the next thing to check is the controller for the fans that determines which fans operate and at what speed. There are several inputs to this controller: coolant temperature,...
Rear differential won't spin driveshaft, starts to turn then locks up.
Hello there, many common faults will prevent your driveshaft from spinning on your 2003 Mazda. Without knowing which model you have I can only offer general advice. The most common fault would be failing u-joints or worn ring and pinion...
My heater is blowing cold air.
If the engine temperature is not abnormally low, then a stuck open thermostat is not likely to be the cause of inadequate cabin heat. Common causes of no cabin heat include malfunctioning blend door(s) (part of the in-dash ventilation network),...

Related articles

Are Wider Tires Better?
The The size and width of the tires on your vehicle determines how your vehicle will handle in different conditions. There are several factors that go into the decision of which tires to equip your vehicle with (https://www.goodyear.com/en-US/company/partner/yourmechanic?promoCode=YOURMECHANIC&utm_source=null&utm_medium=referral&partnerId=yourmechanic&partnerName=yourmechanic&retaggingLaunchUrl=%2F%2Fassets.adobedtm.com%2Flaunch-EN786b79de5697438cb1f8839bcd30487c.min.js&floodlightEnabled=true&liveChatEnabled=true&siteName=Goodyear+Tires), including: The...
How Far Can You Drive On a Flat Tire?
You’re driving down the interstate and your tire pressure monitor light comes on. You notice the tire pressure slowly dropping....
How Often Does the Suspension System Require Routine Maintenance?
Keeping Keeping a car, truck, or other vehicle running safely and efficiently requires a certain amount of routine maintenance. Most owners know that they’re supposed to get their oil changed periodically, but what about the suspension — what routine maintenance...