Q: Should I replace my head gasket or just buy a new car?

asked by on August 03, 2017

I need to replace the head gasket on my 2006 Subaru B9 Tribeca - it would cost about $2,400 - It's not an urgent need but I have been made aware that it will need to be done in the next 3,000 miles or so. With the wear & tear on my car it's probably only worth about $3,000 - $3,500. I'd be interested in getting a car that's a bit more reliable and not as expensive to fix. Would it be a better financial decision to fix the head gasket and keep driving the Subaru? Or to trade in the Subaru and just get a new/used car?

My car has 106000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Change Oil and Filter $92.33 - $165.78 Get a Quote
Transmission Fluid Service $125.08 - $496.65 Get a Quote
Rotate Tires Get a Quote

Unfortunately, this is a decision you would need to make on your own. As you know, a blown head gasket can be very expensive to fix no matter the vehicle. This is not specific to a Subaru necessarily. As you may know, on any vehicle, the amount of labor required to change a head gasket is very time consuming and tedious.

As with any car, the life expectancy depends largely on how you maintain the car, the driving conditions it is subjected to, the driving habits of the owner and many other factors. Proper maintenance schedules are a key factor to prolonging the longevity of the vehicle and avoiding unnecessary costly repair bills due to neglecting proper maintenance intervals. Things like oil changes, transmission fluid services, and tire rotations are all basic maintenance items that will drastically prolong the life of the vehicle and prevent premature wearing on parts. I would suggest having a professional from YourMechanic come to your location to take a look at your car and come up with a routine maintenance schedule for your vehicle.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Well my pick up 2017 Nissan [Frontier](/topics-frontier/) Np300 the clucth will not engage

I have a 2003 honda [pilot](/topics-pilot/) and it won't start. I just replaced the [fuel pump](/topics-fuel-pump-honda/) and the starter relay

I am missing parts of my car, it's the part between the front tire and the engine, it looked like a cover of some sort

This is called the inner fender plastic liner and protects from water and dirt from getting into the engine area. You may have to special order a new one from a dealer or if you contact our customer service they...

High idle and poor gas on my 92 Chevy s10 4.3 . How can I fix this?

Hi Dominga. Thanks for submitting your question today. There could be several mechanical problems causing the high idle and excessive fuel consumption. Usually, it is something simple - like a loose vacuum line, dirty or damaged mass air flow sensor...

2001 c240 intermediate crank & stall at idle deceleration. Ecu code p0300 p0341. Changed cam please sensor cleaned maf. No fix.

Hi There, As you know, code P0341 relates to the camshaft position sensor and code P0300 relates to a misfire which is likely a result of the faulty camshaft sensor. It may be possible for the same code to exist...

Service engine light flashes when accelerating and driving rough

This is a common sign of a dirty or failing idle air control valve. The idle air control valve reads the air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected into the engine at low speeds and...

Hard starting and clicking noise

The clicking noise is an indication of either a bad or discharged battery or a bad connection in the starting circuit. There are two circuits in every starting system: the primary circuit that is energized by the key, and the...

problem starting engine

Hello there, thank you for asking about your 2011 BMW X5. This may be a variety of potential issues but most likely related to a fuel delivery problem. Try checking idle air control module which regulates the air flow intake...

Car door opens on its own

Hi. It sounds like you are having problems with you automatic sliding side door. The door has a bundle of wires that run along the bottom. Over time, these wires break and cause electrical issues with your vehicle. Issues range...

Related articles

Is it Safe to Drive With a Flat Tire?
Once Once a tire loses a large amount of air pressure, it causes a flat tire. Overuse, puncture, improper air pressure, or a defect can cause a tire to become flat. Furthermore, driving on underinflated tires can cause damage and...
How Do I Take Care of My New Tires?
You’ve You’ve equipped your car with a brand new set of tires, replacing the old set of worn out rubber. They were noisy, and every time you had to brake hard, you were losing traction. Now you’ve spent your hard-earned...
How Do I Take Care of My New Tires?
You’ve You’ve equipped your car with a brand new set of tires, replacing the old set of worn out rubber. They were noisy, and every time you had to brake hard, you were losing traction. Now you’ve spent your hard-earned...