Q: Should I keep using high mileage oil?

asked by on March 23, 2018

I've been running high mileage synth blend at my trusted shop for every oil change since I bought my car two years ago. I change it every 3,000 miles. The engine is still runs well and smooth, no leaks or oil burning. I use the high mileage oil because my car has very high miles even though it's no problem for a Honda. Is it worth it for me to keep using it over the regular conventional oil? I plan on keeping this car for a while until 300k miles.

My car has 246700 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The term "High Mileage" is a marketing term only and thus has no meaning in Tribology, the relevant science one relies on to measure and evaluate the technical appropriateness of engine oils. I am not aware of any published, public domain studies proving a benefit from these "high mileage" oils, that are sold at a premium price, where the principal benefit of relevance to be measured is enhanced engine service lifetime due to the use of "high mileage" oil versus other API certified oils. The paucity of published evidence means it is not likely the claimed advantages of "high mileage" oil are meaningful, if they exist at all. I encourage you to make inquiries of your own including, most relevantly, contacting the Technical Support department at the oil vendor of interest to you and just simply ask for the published evidence (not the marketing vagaries but actual published test results from third party laboratories). If no evidence is supplied, the conclusion will be clear enough: "high mileage" is marketing fluff concocted to sell more costly engine oil to you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Warning lights on brand new car

Talk to the General Manager of the dealership and see if you can just trade it for another vehicle. If the vehicle cannot get fixed within three visits, for the same problem, then you can get the lemon law evoked...

Where is the plug in for the code reader?

Your vehicle's OBD connector is located on the driver's side of the vehicle underneath the dash to the right of the steering column just above the gas pedal.

Air bags deployed after hitting a bump, and getting stuck on front bumper. Can a friend who's been a mechanic fix the problem? How much this is going to cost?

Sent billing question to CS about the cost of replacing airbags that were deployed from the bumper coming off. The bumper was already fixed.

The power door locks don't lock, either by the door switch or the key fob

It sounds like your remote may have lost synchronization. Most door lock systems use a "rolling code" where the digital code for the remote changes each time it is activated.The code for the controller changes along with it so they...

While driving my engine stutters and tries to cut out at 4000 rpm.

Hi there. The engine is cutting out for a high back pressure build up in the exhaust system. The catalytic converter or muffler could be plugged up causing the engine to create too much back pressure and when the engine...

What may cause my transmission to jerk?

These types of rough running issues are very hard to diagnose without taking a look at the vehicle and doing some diagnostic testing. This could be caused by the vehicle needing a tune up, a fuel pressure problem, a vacuum...

All of the dash lights and gauges flash, and then the car dies

Have the main integrated fuse relay box checked for connection issues. The fuse box on these vehicle have been known to cause stalling issues along with other erratic electrical issues. Contact a dealer to see if your vehicle may have...

Honda N WGN 660 5cc japanese frequent limp home mode

Hello, thanks for writing in about your Honda N WGN. A likely possibility related to the misfiring may be that the car's computer may have tried to recalibrate the fuel supply as a result of the faulty throttle control relay...

Is it safe to drive 60 miles with the VSA and abs light engaged?

The VSA (Vehicle Stability Assist) and ABS (Anti-Lock Brake) systems generally controlled by some of the same components which may cause any issues with them to be related, which may explain why both lights are on. The ABS control module...

Related articles

The Top 5 Selling Cars in Arizona in 2012
Depending Depending on where you live in Arizona, the weather is either arid or there may be periods of heavy snow – such as in the mountain areas. The vehicles that have been popular in previous years for the area,...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Honda Ridgeline
The The 2012 Honda Ridgeline is built on the Pilot SUV configuration and welded as a single unit, resulting in a five passenger truck that delivers a decidedly carlike ride. With fuel efficiency that is comparable to many midsize SUVs,...
The Best Used Cars to Buy For Fuel Economy
Saving money on gas is an important factor to consider when buying a car. The Honda Civic, Toyota Prius, and Ford Fusion all have great fuel economy.