Q: Shifter slides into neutral w/o using button on shifter and while driving

asked by on August 19, 2017

When driving if I accidentally hit the shifter w/my hand etc. not engaging the button on the shifter, not breaking, simply driving the transmission slips into neutral, is this normal? It'll go back into drive with no issue. I assume the button serves as a clutch similar to a manual transmission vehicle, with that assumption I'm inclined to believe there is an issue with this transmission. Note: The vehicle has a manual option that I have turned off.

My car has 11000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

This is normal way the shifter works. The button would need to be used to get from neutral to reverse. There is nothing wrong with your vehicle’s shifter.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

Especially when cold, I notice shifts in low gears on my transmission

Hello. If servicing the fluid and filter did not help, then it may be possible that the transmission is worn. If any of the clutch packs that the transmission uses to shift wear out, they may slip and cause harsher...

Jeep Grand Cherokee loses power when accelerating breaks up like the fuel is deprived.

Hello and thanks for writing in. I believe you are headed in the right direction. I would suggest checking the MAP sensor as well as fuel pressure to be sure that all fuel injectors are firing properly and not plugged....

Loud clunking when shifting reverse. Is it the pressure switch?

Hello. It sounds like you either have a mount that is failing or you may have an issue with the valve body in the transmission. I have also seen the driveshaft make this noise where it enters the transmission. It...

Reinstalling fuel pump back into tank

If you are not using an OEM, dealer supplied gasket, but rather an aftermarket supplied gasket, that could cause this problem. The gasket you have may simply be too thick. Even if the gaskets are of the same thickness, there...

Cracked radiator and cracked exhaust header which to fix first in need to repair fast and cheap for now,

The exhaust manifold should be replaced FIRST. If that crack happens to leak exhaust gases, that means CO can get into the passenger compartment. If that happens you won't have to worry about repairing the radiator. That manifold can be...

I pulled up to a gas station and filled up with gas. As I tried to start the vehicle just gave clicks. Jump starting did not work.

Hi There, If the vehicle previously overheated, it may be possible that it could have damaged a cylinder head gasket, which could cause it not to start as you describe. A blown head gasket may cause a number of different...

My car isn't changing gears properly. 2006 Chevrolet Impala

Hello. I would check the transmission fluid level and condition on the dipstick. If it is low and/or has a burnt smell (transmission fluid should be a reddish color), then you may have a failed transmission. Changing the fluid and...

Two cylinders misfiring

There are many possibilities for misfires. Spark plugs are common on your engine to cause misfires. Fuel injectors and ignition coils are likely as well. If there are only 2 cylinders misfiring, they could be related, or not. If they...

I purchased a Used Car from Carmax. I was told on Monday that they could not get the title and had to turn in the car to the aucti

Hello, thank you for writing in. This is a legal issue that is above the advice and services that we can give. You should check with your local courthouse and see if there are any legal advisers you can speak...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Skier
When When summer ends, skiers start thinking about hitting the hills, and that means having to contend with winter driving conditions. Not just any vehicle is going to get the job done. We have evaluated several used ski-worthy vehicles, and...
The Best Used Cars to Buy That Can Be Towed Behind an RV
Summer Summer is a great time for a road trip, but often travelers like bringing all the conveniences of home along, in the form of an RV. Then they tow their car behind it – sometimes this practice is called...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Jeep Wrangler
With With some subtle updates, improvements, and increases in size, the 2012 Jeep Wrangler maintains the model’s familiar and rugged look and feel. While the style of the Wrangler may not have changed much, though, its function has definitely been...