Q: Problem with intermittent momentary loss of firing/power X-Trail model

asked by on September 02, 2016

In Feb I sent to Nissan wshop for diagnosis, and was told slight lube leak via Rocker cover seals. I got it replaced. Right after service, I went to another wshop to fix the exhaust system. The rear muffler/silencer pipe have the hole repaired, and was also advised to remove the Catalytic Converter as it only cause back pressure, I got it removed. But after a week, the problem comes back. Two weeks ago, I went back to Nissan wshop, they checked and says no problem with ignition system, but could be the exhaust system. Does removing the Catalytic converter has any relation of this intermittent momentary loss of engine power? It happens during idling and also while on the move.

My car has 186700 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The catalytic converter does help to contribute to back pressure, however, it may not be related to your loss of power issue. If the same issue existed before removing the catalytic converter, then it is likely not the problem.

Intermittent loss of power could very well be a fuel delivery or ignition problem. Since the ignition problem was ruled out by Nissan, I would recommend checking the various fuel/air monitoring sensors such as the mass air flow sensor and throttle position sensor.

The mass air flow sensor regulates the air coming into the engine allowing it to mix with the fuel properly before being injected into the engine. When this is faulty, it will cause intermittent loss of power as you describe due to its inability to properly mix the air and fuel which causes the car to starve for fuel.

The throttle position sensor can also cause this same problem when it is faulty, as it monitors the position of your foot on the gas pedal and tells the car’s fuel injection system how much fuel to give the engine.

If you would like to have this scoped out by another technician, a certified professional from YourMechanic can come to your home or office to diagnose the power loss problem firsthand.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I view the instant fuel econ?
The instant fuel econ displays the gas mileage that your car is achieving at any exact moment. To view this feature, follow these steps: 1. Press the Up/Down buttons on the steering wheel until Trip 1 or 2 is displayed...
Engine light on, black smoke coming out exhaust on acceleration and fault codes
The glow plug faults are most likely going to cause a hard start condition, which will be most noticeable when the engine is cold. The colder the engine, the more difficult it would be to start usually. Often times, glow...
My car will not start
This could be a variety of things ranging from a fuel delivery problem to a no spark problem. The good thing is you know you are getting power to the starter if it cranks. Outside of this you will need...
Car shakes when I slow down.
Hello. The imbalance of rotating parts on a car, such as your wheel and tire assemblies, is a function of speed but also "positioning". When you were traveling at a steady state rate, say 65 MPH, the suspension was clearly...
Recall for Catalytic Converter on my 2003 Nissan Sentra
Hello. On most vehicles the catalytic converter can usually be covered for the first 10 years or 100,000 miles. Once you surpass either of these, the converter will not be covered whether it is under warranty or recall. If you...
Turn signal and hazards not working
Hello, thank you for writing in. It is possible that the vehicle could be having a switch or ground connection issue. The turn signals and the hazards are wired separately so that your hazards will work independently in emergency situations....
Replaced alternator
Hello, and thank you for writing in. With the new alternator installed, make sure the installation is holding. Double check all of the electrical connections are clean, dry, and tight. Make sure the battery is working and is capable of...
Carb not getting enough fuel I don't see it in the window n I put new fuel pump n lines on and another carb on it but same proble
Hi there. Unfortunately, I think Jay is correct here. Usually when you see air bubbles in the filter, it's due to a pick-up issue or debris in the fuel. If the gas tank is the original one from 1980, it...
New battery. Car won't start until minutes later when attempted again.
A voltage test will not reveal whether the battery is defective or not. A different test, referred to as a "load test" (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-is-dead-inspection), is required. During these no start incidents, check to see if the engine immobilizer system (security system)...

Related articles

How Long Does a Catalytic Converter Last?
The catalytic converter converts pollutants in the exhaust system into less toxic pollutants by using a redox reduction method. The catalytic converter...
How Long Does a Low Oil Level Sensor Last?
Having Having the right amount of oil in an engine is important to the smooth running of your engine. In order for the engine on a car to run as intended, it will have to have the right amount of...
P0337 OBD-II Trouble Code: Crankshaft Position Sensor A Circuit Low Input
P0337 means that the crankshaft is suffering because of low voltage. This could be due to sensor not being aligned properly or electrical problems.