Q: My car won't engage 1st gear 2006 Audi A4

asked by on December 04, 2016

My car shakes and will not move when in first gear, it only moves when in 2nd gear. My mechanic replaced the mountings and confirmed the clutch and gearbox are fine, but told me the flywheel should be replaced.

My car has 1665274 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Gears slipping when accelerating Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hi there - I believe the problem is more likely with the 1st gear set in the transmission. If the clutch works in one gear, it will work in all gears. While a bad flywheel would cause the vibration and shaking you describe, it would also do so in all gears. There may, in fact be multiple problems at work here. Checking the flywheel, or 1st gear, will require removal of the transmission to access the flywheel, clutch, or to disassemble the transmission to check gear sets for proper operation. I would recommend a engine/clutch/transmission inspection by a mobile, professional mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, who will come to your location, diagnose this problem, give you an accurate assessment of damage and cost estimate for repairs.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What is the vehicle stability assist?
Your car has a stability assist system built into it (VSA). You might be more familiar with this as “electronic stability control,” but they both refer to the same thing. The VSA is a system designed to enhance stability and...
What does it mean if the Daytime Running Lights indicator comes on in the dash?
Daytime running lights (DRL) are an automatic system that turn on when the vehicle is turned on and in motion. The purpose of daytime running lights are to make the vehicle more visible during daylight hours and to alert other...
Turbo producing white smoke
If it is going out and you get white smoke and you've gone to the intercooler and you see there is oil in it, that means oil seals on the turbo are going out. I would advise fixing it very...
Car overheating and problem with staying running
A battery can't cause this. An overheating engine is due to a problem with the cooling system and the cooling system alone. If it is overheating and won't run, this is unfortunately a bad sign. Replacing the water pump (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-water-pump)...
If a mechanic put one of the fuel injectors in the wrong cylinder, could this damage the ECU?
Hello. The ECU could not have been damaged by moving injectors to different cylinders. The injectors are not programmed to be in a particular cylinder of the engine. Having only two injectors reconditioned is the most likely cause for running...
I put a new alternator in my car yesterday it started up fine about the third time starting the car to starter relay just clicks w
A starter like any other mechanical and electrical part is subject to failing sometimes for no apparent reason. However, sometimes this is misdiagnosed as well and often times mistaken for something much more simple like a fuse or starter relay....
What's the difference between the ECM and PCM?
The engine control module (ECM) controls all the engine functions to keep it running correctly monitoring all the sensors of the engine. The power train control module (PCM) will include multiple control modules in one case called a PCM. The...
i have 3 code on my car P0431, P0174, P0305
Noise in exhaust systems occurs due to leaks as well as internal failure of the baffles in the muffler or resonator. So, just because there are no leaks, doesn't mean the exhaust system will be noise free. An [engine/exhaust noise...
Miss fire
Engine misfires (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/engine-is-misfiring-inspection) can be caused by many different problems and are generally caused by either a spark or fuel issue or in some cases, a combination of both. Spark related problems generally will result from things like ignition coils,...

Related articles

Understanding Main Gears Vs. Planetary Gears
Aspiring Aspiring mechanics spend hours learning about how main gears and planetary gears work in a car transmission, so a full dissertation simply isn’t possible within this relatively brief article. If you’re curious about how they work, though, this brief...
How to Buy a Good Quality Driveshaft
The The driveshaft is the part of your car that takes the engine’s power and sends it to your wheels in order to propel the vehicle. There are two driveshafts in front-wheel drive cars, called half shafts. Rear-wheel drive vehicles...
How Long Does a Kickdown Cable Last?
In In order for a car to run smoothly, the engine and the transmission will have to work together. With all of the different components in the engine and transmission of a car, keeping up with them all can be...