Q: Mechanic said OBD P0989 so need to replace silinoid for $1700. Should I try changing transmission fluid first? 2010 Cadillac SRX.

asked by on November 06, 2017

My SRX will not autoshift out of first gear when I first start driving it. If I stop, put it in park, then put it back in gear, it usually shifts correctly. It doesn't seem to happen when the SRX is warm. Mechanic said OBD P0989 meant I need to install new silinoid #5 for $1700, but can't guarantee that will fix it. Is that correct? Should I try to service the transmission fluid first?

My car has 83000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

You should ask the mechanic if he actually directly tested the solenoid and, if so, what the specific test results are. If he did not test the solenoid, look for a new mechanic. Trouble codes can never be relied upon as the sole basis upon which to conclude that a part is faulty. All suspect parts must be individually and directly tested regardless of what a trouble code might "suggest". In the case of this particular code, P0989, as is typical with most trouble codes, there are a multitude of possible causes of the shifting fault specifically listed within the code. All of the potential causes must be tracked down using the specific diagnostic decision tree that General Motors publishes in the Factory Service Manual for your specific year, make and model. Did the mechanic evaluate all of the other potential causes of the Code? If the mechanic cannot explain why he is proposing to replace the solenoid, and cannot explain exactly what has failed, or appears faulty in the solenoid, then you are probably wasting your time and money. Obviously, YourMechanic certified mechanics can diagnose and resolve this issue for you, most importantly giving you an intelligible and credible diagnosis. If you want to go that route, please request a transmission shift diagnostic - solenoids/P0989 and the responding certified mechanic will get this taken care of for you and explain in detail what is going on. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic because we want you to make the most of your repair dollars and help you to get the best possible results.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

Power steering, leak, and groaning noise.

Hi, thanks for writing in. This is a sign of a failing power steering pump which is what the groaning sound and stiff steering will come from. It also sounds like you have a major leak coming from somewhere. If...

Brake lights don't turn on when brake pedal is pressed.

Hello, thanks for writing in. Yes, the symptoms you describe are typical of a faulty brake light switch. The brake light switch, which is usually mounted at the base of the pedal, is the electronic switch responsible for powering the...

1999 Ford Taurus antifreeze leak between transmission and oil pan please help

Hi there. A coolant leak coming from the area near the transmission and oil pan it typically going to be coming from the heater core or heater bypass valve, which comes off the rear of the engine. However, there are...

2010 Cadillac SRX Service StabiliTrak message

Hello. If the vehicle is displaying a service message for the traction control system then it has detected an issue with the vehicle's traction control system. If the vehicle has also been put into a power reduced mode then it...

Can l cut the power steering belt on a 1999 Toyota sienna and drive it with no problem

If you take off power steering belt if it is only thing running on the belt then it will not affect any other system. You will not have any power assist when steering and it will be hard to steer....

How long does it take to change the gasket on the oil pan of a car?

You can get an exact quote by entering your year, make and model at YourMechanic's oil pan gasket replacement service page. To give you an approximation though, the required hours are probably in the range of 8 to 12 hours,...

I have 2004 Mercury Sable. It randomly stalls, after putting in gas, on hot days, will start after resting AC goes hot during buck

Hi Sandy. Thanks for all the information - it's very helpful to initially provide some technical advice. It appears as if you might have a few different things going on with your Mercury Sable. First, in regards to the engine...

Car runs rough - 1995 Cadillac Fleetwood

Hi! Sometimes a bad spark plug wire can result in what you are experiencing. If your vehicle is due for any scheduled maintenance (based on mileage), such as a tune up (new spark plugs, spark plug wires, distributor cap and...

Engine

Hello. Thank you for writing in. Do not assume right away that you have blown a head gasket. When the cooling system overheats and throws coolant all over the engine bay, every hot part of that engine will create steam....

Related articles

A Buyer's Guide to the 2012 Cadillac Escalade
When When you’ve said “Cadillac Escalade”, you’ve pretty much said it all. The Escalade has been synonymous with luxury since it first hit the scene in 1999. With the 2012 edition, Cadillac proved nothing has changed. If you want to...
How to Get Cadillac Dealership Certified
Cadillac car dealerships offer automotive technician jobs to mechanics who are certified through one of the many Cadillac training programs.
5 Comfortable Sports Cars Your Parents Won't Complain About Riding In
The most comfortable sports cars combine high performance with a smooth ride. Options include the Alpina B6, Audi S8 Plus, and Mercedes-AMG S65.