Q: Knocking noise - 2005 Scion xA

asked by on September 12, 2016

that noise seems to come from the power stirring pump pulley, I look at a schematic of the pump and it seems that pulley is connected with a shaft going inside the pump, can that pulley and the axle be replaced without replacing the whole pump, it may be chipper? the pump itself works fine.

My car has 235000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Hello. Assemblies such as power steering pumps can often be rebuilt or repaired, but the economics of it are usually only attractive to car enthusiasts or hobbyists. That is, IF there is something wrong with the pump, it is much cheaper to buy a rebuilt one and often you will even get a lifetime warranty if you buy it from one of the national chain store parts vendors.

Really, though, the first thing to do is get a definitive diagnosis because there are quite a few moving parts in that vicinity that can cause noise and sometimes one source is mistaken for another. Also, given the amount of mileage you have on the engine, you might indeed have more than one part causing the noise you are hearing. If you need an expert to take a look, consider consulting a professional technician from YourMechanic to come to your home or office and diagnose the noise firsthand. They can advise on a repair and also replace the power steering pump or just the pulley for you if found faulty.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car tries to turnover but won't start
Hi there. If your car is not turning over, despite a new battery and a jump, then it is probably not a battery problem. It may be possible that there may be a problem with the vehicle's starter, or starting...
I'm told I need my timing belt for my 2011 Hyundai Accent replaced.
Under ordinary service conditions (i.e., as opposed to "severe" which would be lots of city driving and idling, trailer towing, etc.), Hyundai recommends that you replace the timing belt (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/timing-belt-replacement) on your vehicle once it reaches 90,000 miles. At that...
clutch pedal goes strait to floor and brake fluid is empty
You've probably had a failure in the clutch slave cylinder. The level in the brake fluid reservoir falls because the clutch also uses fluid from the same reservoir. There are compartments in there so that a leak in clutch system...
when coming to a stop, my truck has a binding/clunking noise in the rear end
Hello, thank you for writing in. While the components you have looked into are great inspections considering you tow often, lets start a little simpler and work our way down the list. Since this is happening while you are braking,...
WHERE IS 2006 KIA SEDONA BACKUP LIGHT SWITCH? BULBS GOOD.
The reverse lights are controlled by the neutral safety switch on the transmission as a computer input to the front control and rear control modules. These modules are accessed by using a scanner to scan for codes and data input...
2007 Mercedes C230. Cranks but won't start. Battery is only 1 year old. After a few attempts car starts. Alternator? Starter?
Hi Craig. Thanks for contacting us today. Generally speaking, when you attempt to start the vehicle and it finally ignites after a few times, it's caused either by a fuel / air mixture issue or a loose or worn out...
Hi Patrick i seemed to have bottomed out my m35 and need to replace oil pan and gasket. How much is the cost??
I would first recommend having the engine and under the vehicle inspected to see what all got damaged. If you damaged the oil pan then it may have also damaged the exhaust or subframe under engine that may affect the...
i have a hyundai 2010 elantra and my electric steering power light came on my wheel turns fine i was wondering if i need to change
If the EPS light is always on, it means the vehicle's computer is reporting a fault in the electronic power steering system. Using a scan tool, a mechanic can download the trouble codes from the computer that have caused the...
Will a bad air sensor damage your car if it is not fixed immediately, how long do you have to fix it?
If the check engine light is constant (NOT flashing) you might have days to weeks, depending on how much the air fuel ratio departs from the stoichiometric ideal. Too little fuel and the engine runs too hot. Too much fuel...

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Steering Rack/Gearbox
Common signs include a very tight steering wheel, leaking power steering fluid, grinding noises when steering, and a burning oil smell.
How to Replace a Power Steering Input Shaft Seal
A faulty power steering input shaft seal can cause hydraulic fluid to leak from the power steering input shaft and cause the system to overheat.
How to Replace a Water Pump Pulley
The serpentine belt or drive belt drives an engine’s water pump pulley, which rotates the water pump. A bad pulley leads to a failure of this system.