Q: Is it better to just change trans fluid instead of flushing the whole system?

asked by on October 29, 2016

Well I need know which one is better

My car has 50600 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Transmission Fluid Service $140.08 - $502.73 Get a Quote

When it comes to vehicles over 5 years or 60,000 miles, my preference is to drain the transmission through the pan and replace the filter, especially if the transmission has never been serviced. The sales pitch is of course that the "flush" gets all the fluid out, but in my opinion, what is of greater concern, is all the material remaining in the bottom of the transmission pan and the filter remaining in place. Ideally, while it is more expensive, I recommend to flush, then remove the pan and replace the filter before adding the new fluid. If the transmission service has been done previously in the car’s lifetime, a flush should be sufficient.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

My clutch will not work.
Your clutch hydraulic system works very similarly to your brake system. If the clutch pedal is stuck in the down position and cannot be moved up at all then the clutch master cylinder has failed and has seized internally. If...
Car shakes and turns off
Hello. There are many factors that can cause a car to stall upon start up. You could be experiencing a fuel supply problem or a fault with a sensor in the engine management system. The first step with any drivability...
Car Starts And It Shifts Gears , But Won't Reverse , And In Drive It Barley Goes And When It Does It Jumps And Jolts. Transmisson?
Hello there, the transmission being unable to shift into reverse is a common issue for vehicles as they age and increase in mileage. There are a few common causes for this malfunction. The most likely would be low transmission fluid...
Front brakes drag
In order to locate the possible cause of your front brakes dragging, you will need to do some tests to isolate the cause. When you are testing the system brakes dragging the lift and support, check both front wheels to...
The temperature gauge is at half way and the heater is blowing cold air with the heater on
The only purpose of the engine cooling system thermostat is to maintain optimal engine cooling system temperature, which is typically around 200 degrees. However, inasmuch as it is the engine coolant that provides the cabin heat (through the heater core...
chrysler 2012 200,horn does not honk when you lock it with the remote
First check the vehicle settings. If you have a Menu button on the steering wheel, follow these instructions: Press and release the MENU button until “Personal Settings” displays. Press and release the DOWN button to display the following programmable features:Sound...
Beeping sound when pressing the gas pedal
Hi There, You will need to reconnect the parking brake module by turning the key on and pressing down the main brake. While the main brake is pressed, pull up on the parking brake switch. After the brake sets, you...
Electrical issues
Hi There, This will require some extensive electrical wiring testing to determine what specific wires have been affected by the fan motor and wiring burning. You will not likely need replace the entire engine wiring as not all of this...
Problem with RPM
What you are describing sounds like a dirty or failing idle air control valve. The idle air control valve (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/idle-control-valve-replacement) monitors the air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected into the engine at low speeds...

Related articles

2005 Jeep Wrangler vs. 2005 Chevrolet Blazer: Which One Should I Buy?
Sport SUVs are a class all of their own; these vehicles are meant for a fun drive through the woods and across the trail – but not necessarily to Grandma’s house! Think instead about going through the creek and through...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Farmer
If If you're a farmer, you know that what you need isn’t a used car – it’s a used pickup truck. How else are you going to haul around hay, implements, garden produce, fertilizer, and all the other things you...
How to Download a Chevy Owner’s Manual
When you buy a new car, you’re provided with original documents and books related to your vehicle. The materials you receive include: Your audio system operating information Your owner’s manual Your recommended maintenance schedule These manuals help you know how...