Q: If the thermostat is bad would it cause the heater core to not work properly?

asked by on January 07, 2017

I have read online that if the hoses leading to the radiator from the thermostat are cold then that means the thermostat is bad, but would that be the reason why my defrost doesn't work properly? When I start the vehicle I smell what could be antifreeze, just not sure if I should jump to replacing the heater core or hope the thermostat dose the trick.

Heater is not working Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Hello - you are correct. If the thermostat is stuck open, not allowing the engine to warm up properly, there won’t much, if any, heat in the passenger compartment. However, if you are smelling coolant in the passenger area, chances are the heater core is leaking as well - not a happy occasion. I would recommend a heater inspection by a mobile, professional mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, who will come to your location, confirm this diagnosis, and give you an accurate assessment of damage and cost estimate for repairs.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Overheating at the traffic light or while AC is on

You may have a restriction in your radiator or condenser that is preventing the cooling of the respective fluids that go through these parts. Restrictions will cause hot spots and therefore will not allow sufficient cooling of the refrigerant or...

Heads warped

Hi there. A stuck thermostat will definitely cause your engine to overheat. When your heads warp because of this, it is necessary to take it to an engine machining shop in order for them to attempt to straighten out the...

Thermostat malfunction code read

The Code that was set might have been P0126. The engine cooling thermostat maintains optimal engine temperature. Inasmuch as the PCM can measure actual temperature from other sensor inputs (such as the coolant temperature sensor), the functioning of the thermostat...

Problems with heating with check engine light on

On the 528's, there is an electronically controlled heater valve that can stick closed, blocking heated coolant from entering the heater core. Replacing this component will mean the coolant system would need to drained, filled, and bled. You may...

Thermostat

The cooling system would need to be completely checked out to see if the cooling fan circuit is working correct. If the fans are not coming on it would allow the engine to overheat. The thermostat would cause the engine...

Car Overheating; Unknown cause

The coolant could be low, the thermostat could be plugged up or sticking, the radiator could be plugged up restricting the coolant flow, the water pump could have failed, or the head gasket could have burned causing the engine to...

thermastat stuck removed now the car isnt regestering hot but can hear boiling from motor

First off, you need a working thermostat in the car for it to function properly. If you removed the thermostat to fix an overheating problem, you will need to install a new one and begin the process of diagnosing the...

Temperature gauges jumping and fan not running on a 2008 Avenger

Of course, the fans have to work correctly. They might not work for lots of reasons. First thing is to put in a new thermostat. Because, if you've got a stick in thermostat, the engine can get hot, but then...

Problems after thermostat, digital cluster & cooling pump replacements

It appears you may have a few different issues going on. It seems unlikely that more than one cluster would fail. The most likely cause is a shorted wiring or open circuit causing the clusters to fail. If the car...

Related articles

How to Buy a Good Quality Thermostat
While While many people are familiar with the major parts in their vehicle, there are all kinds of smaller parts that play a vital role as well. The thermostat is one of those parts that many don't think about, but...
How a Car's Cooling System Works
Have Have you ever considered the thousands of times explosions occur in your engine? If you're like most people, that thought never enters your mind. Every time a spark plug fires, the fuel and air mixture in that cylinder blows...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Thermostat
Common signs include the temperature gauge reading being very high or changing erratically, engine overheating, and coolant leaks.