Q: How Do I Know if the Problem Is the Alternator or the Battery

asked by on December 01, 2015

How to know if the problem is the alternator or the car battery?

When your vehicle’s engine will not turn over or the Battery Light comes on in the dash, how do you know if it is caused by a defective battery or alternator? This article will help explain how each component works and how to know which one is the problem.

Most of today’s vehicles still use a 12 DC volt (Direct Current) battery that is made up of a plastic case with 6 individual lead acid cells separated by a plastic or other material plate. Each cell has lead plates with a negative and positive plate each separated so they will not touch with a permeable material. The plates are in an electrolyte solution to cause a chemical reaction between the negative and positive plates of each cell. Each cell is capable of producing about 2.1 DC volts. Since there are 6 cells in a battery connected in a series circuit the 6 cells are added together for a total of 12.6 DC volts when fully charged. Through the electrolysis process to produce voltage, the plates transfer some material from one plate to the opposite charged plate. As the charge is used, the battery voltage drops. The alternator is used to put a charge back into the battery. A battery will accept and release its voltage as long as the lead plates in the battery last or when they touch each other, causing short circuits. Once this happens, the voltage and power of a battery will drop till it can no longer produce or receive power.

The alternator in most vehicles is a belt-driven voltage generator. The alternator has a rotating rotor with an electromagnet built into it. The rotor rotates inside a field coil. As the rotor rotates inside the field coil it will cause a magnetic field that will produce an alternating current voltage (AC) of about 120 AC volts or more as the magnetic lines of force are broken. This is the same type of power your house uses. Your car cannot use this AC voltage since it can only use DC current voltage. The 120 AC volts is then rectified inside the alternator with a voltage rectifier to convert the AC into a DC voltage. The conversion process will make DC voltage that is regulated to be between 12.5 to 15 DC volts. The voltage levels may be different between manufacturers. The DC current is used to keep the battery at a stable constant voltage level of between 12.4 to 12.9 volts DC.

In order to test if an alternator is charging correctly, you first need to have a battery that is in good working order. To test a battery you will first need to look at the cold cranking amps or cranking amps rating on the battery. A battery size of the inside plate surfaces determine the cranking amps of a battery. You should then test the battery using a battery load tester or capacitance tester to see if the battery is able to handle a normal load and maintain a working voltage for the electronics and starting system in the vehicle. When load tested the battery voltage should not drop below 9.6 volts under load. Charge and retest it again if it falls below 9.6 volts. If it fails again then replace the battery.

Once a good battery is in place, then the alternator can be tested. An alternator is rated in amps. Different amperages for different vehicles depend on the electrical loads it needs to keep up with. To test the alternator a volt and amp meter is needed. Hook up the voltmeter to the battery and the amp meter around the large cable of the alternator. Run the engine at between 1500 rpm to 2000 rpm with all the lights and accessories like the AC compressor and blowers on max settings. You should have a voltage reading of between 12.9 and 13.5 volts and an amperage reading of over 85% of rated alternator maximum amps output. For example, a 100 amp alternator should put out between 12.9 and 13.5 volts and above 85 amps.

If you try and test an alternator with a bad battery then you will get incorrect voltage and amperages during the test and you may think the alternator is bad when the battery is the cause of the problem. Always retest the system after a battery is replaced since an alternator that is overcharging a battery can boil the electrolyte and shorten the life of the battery.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Loud noise when car starts

Unfortunately, the information you provided about your Dodge Durango is very limited, and I will be unable to make a proper diagnosis at this time. I would recommend enlisting the assistance of a certified mechanic and including as much information...

Car turns off out of nowhere

Hello, I would suggest testing your alternator. If jump starting will start your vehicle, use a multi meter to test your alternator while the vehicle is running. Good alternators test in the range of 13.8 to 14.2 volts. If it...

Engine kicking on startup when it's cold

The first thing you'd want to do is check the ignition timing. It is possible that it is too far advanced. If it is too far advanced, odds are, it's going to need a timing chain, which can be...

Warning lights come on after battery replacement

Hello. It sounds like the PCM (powertrain control module) and the BCM (body control module) have malfunctioned because of a shortage in the battery system. This could have happened when the battery failed, was removed, or installed. One explanation for...

Jump started car, buy new battery or recharge

Hey there. It would depend on why it went dead. If the battery went dead due to lights left on, then recharge and have it tested. If it went dead for no reason, then it will most likely need a...

Had battery cables and ends replaced. They said alternator and battery was good, but sometimes it will not start and needs to be jumped

Hi. There is something still draining the battery. There could be an interior light staying on and you don't realize it. Car chargers can also drain the battery when the car is off. There is also the possibility that the...

Battery group size

Hi, thanks for writing in. The main thing to keep in mind when it comes to battery group sizes is its physical size. The cold cranking amps (CCA) is what is important when it comes to the battery's ability to...

car suddenly won't start but radio and lights work, repair shop can't find problem

For the vehicle to start, many different systems must work. The most common causes of no-start conditions are the battery, starter, battery cable, ignition switch, or the fuel pump. Any of these can be intermittent issues, which will not always...

My car has been having issues staring I turn the key and no clicking or sound happens lights still work and I know not battery

There are several issues that could possibly cause this issue. A bad connection, a failed starter (or starter solenoid), a bad relay, or any number of other possibilities. It would be best to have a certified mechanic do some diagnostic...

Related articles

How the Alternator Works in Your Car
Your Your car alternator, at its most basic, is what works along with your battery and the rest of your charging system to keep your car running. When you start your car, you’re running on battery power. Then the battery...
How a Battery Works With a Car's Electrical System
Have Have you ever wondered how your car’s electrical system works? It all starts with your car battery. Your car's electrical system operates on a closed circuit, with the main power system being the automotive battery. It uses less than...
How Long Does a Starter Relay Last?
Most Most people are familiar with fuses – they allow your car’s electronics to work while protecting them from over-voltage situations. Relays are similar, but much larger and more powerful. There’s a relay for most of the major components on...