Q: Help to diagnose low MPG and high oil consumption.

asked by on June 03, 2017

My 1999 10th Anniversary MX-5 has about 256K on it. Now, it gets about 18 MPG on highway, but used to be close to 30 MPG. It consumes about 3 quarts of oil per 1000 miles and there are no obvious oil leaks. I did replace the valve cover gasket. There are neither black smoke nor soot deposits around the exhaust. No codes – everything is clear. Sometimes, I can hear misfires when the engine is cold and the low-end torque feels lower than what it used to be. Otherwise, the car drives fine. The following has been done so far: 1) Replaced spark plugs and wires. 2) Compression for all cylinders was within 205-210 range which a believe is good. 3) Replaced oxygen sensor 4) Replaced fuel pump 5) Replaced camshaft position sensor 6) Cleaned throttle body 7) Replaced MAF I am thinking of testing fuel pressure, injectors and vacuum, but something tells that the engine probably needs a serious overhaul. Yet, I find it hard to reconcile the need to overhaul with good compression numbers Any ideas w

My car has 256000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Catalytic Converter Replacement $291.63 - $3214.07 Get a Quote

A few different things may contribute to oil consumption and poor fuel economy. Typically, high oil consumption is related to worn piston rings or worn out valve guide seals. In your case, it is unlikely this is related to worn piston rings as indicated by the proper compression you have already tested for.

A clogged or failing catalytic converter can cause the vehicle to have poor fuel economy. As you know, the catalytic converter converts toxic exhaust gases into less harmful pollutants that are suitable to be expelled into the atmosphere. When this is clogged, this causes these gases to be backed up into the exhaust system not allowing the engine to breathe properly. When this happens, the engine is forced to work much harder to expel these gases. This often results in the engine bogging down, hesitating, shaking and causing very poor fuel economy. A clogged or dirty EGR valve may also cause poor fuel mileage. The EGR valve is a small component designed to allow the flow of exhaust gases into the intake manifold in controlled amounts. Whenever you start the engine, the valve comes alive and waits in a closed position, blocking the flow of exhaust gases. Once the engine reaches operating temperature and speed increases, the valve, either through vacuum or electronic control will gradually open, allowing burned exhaust gases to enter and combine with the air-fuel mixture inside the combustion chamber. When the EGR valve is clogged or dirty, as they are prone to, it may not function properly causing the engine to idle rough, stall at idle speeds, cause the car to get poor fuel mileage, or emit a strong smell of fuel due to excess hydrocarbons which also results in failing emissions tests. I would recommend checking the above to determine what may be causing your poor fuel mileage.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

I have a 1994 acura integra in great shape but when I come to a stop while in traffic my car idles weird and acts like it wants to die

What you are describing sounds like a dirty or failing idle air control valve. The idle air control valve monitors the air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected into the engine at low speeds and...

Hello, I have a 2006 mazdaspeed 6 with 100,000 miles and a "blown third piston" is it worth fixing?

It's too bad that it failed this early in the game, but I don't think there's any future in fixing it. Just remember that an engine is only one of many very expensive parts on a car and once you've...

How much to flush the ac system

Hi Short, Thank you for contacting YourMechanic! To set up the quote for the AC flush for your vehicle, we need some extra information in order to get you the most up-to-date prices on parts and labor. To verify...

Not able to open the trunk with the button on the trunk door

Most of the time, if the vehicle is equipped with a valet system, the button is hidden in the glove box. If this system is activated, the key fob nor the key will be able to open the trunk until...

P0446

Hi There, These codes all relate to a leak in the Evaporative Emissions system (EVAP system). Your car has a small purge valve with a purge solenoid in the Evaporative Emissions system that controls the venting of fumes from the...

How much would a spark plug change be for a 4.6l 99 expedition? And should I change coils too?

Billing question was sent to CS for the cost to replace the spark plugs and the ignition coils on a 1999 Ford Expedition with a V8-4.6L engine.

My valve cover gasket is visible from outside after replacement i haven't fastened to proper torque yet. Should metals touch?

Hi Paco. It depends on what type of gasket you've used. An OEM replacement gasket for the 4-cylinder Toyota Corolla engine will fit snug under the valve cover after installation and wait 24-hours for the silicone to cure. If you...

My trunk lid keeps rattling/shaking when I drive it on a bumby road and it's very loud.

Hi there. It sounds like you have either a latch problem or a trunk adjustment problem. There could be worn or bent components in the latch assembly causing the concern. I suggest having a qualified technician perform an inspection to...

Car radio dead

Hello, this could be a simple problem to fix. If the fuse is blown it will cause the radio to have no power. You could also just have a bad radio, and if this is the case, the radio unit...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2013 Mazda CX-5
Key Key Features The Mazda CX-5 has a 2.0 liter four cylinder engine that offers 155 hp at 6,000 rpm. The fuel economy is estimated at 26 mpg in the city and 35 mpg on the highway for the front-wheel...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Mazda 3
The The compact car class is definitely a competitive one, with established models like the Toyota Corolla and Honda Civic taking up a lot of the market every year. However, if you’re looking for a really attractive compact sedan or...
Understanding the Mazda Oil Life Monitor and Service Indicator Lights
Car symbols, or dashboard lights, are a car service reminder. The Mazda Oil Life Monitor system indicates when and what service your car needs.