Q: Fuel pump shot metal shards throughout fuel system

asked by on September 08, 2016

My car has around 43,000 miles. On the way back home after going to a store, which would was a 5-mile round trip, I heard what sounded like metal grinding from the engine compartment and there was reduced power. Turning off the radio, I could hear the sound better. When I got to the next red light, the car shut down and would not restart. I still had ¼ tank of diesel fuel, so I knew I was not out of gas. The engine cranked, but would not start. There was no warning before the metal grinding noise started. I had the car towed to the dealer, who kept it a few days in order to diagnose it as a faulty fuel pump which had malfunctioned and it had shot metal shard through my car’s entire fuel system. They replaced all components. The cost was exorbitant! But the shocking thing is that they did not replace the fuel tank, which could cause me problems in the future. Could you please tell me why they would not have replaced it and what might happen?

Hello. If the fuel tank was not replaced, it is likely due to the fact that the shop did not deem it necessary to the repair. It may be possible that the fuel tank was not exposed to any metal, or that it was cleaned. I would check with them to see if the fuel tank was removed and cleaned, as it would defeat the purpose of the repairs if they reinstalled a fuel tank that had metal shards in it. If you still do not feel comfortable with the vehicle, consider having it replaced.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do you use a mechanical key with a smart key system?
You push the Release button on the side of the mechanical key and remove the key from the electronic key. Re-insert it to put it back in place. The grooves on the key allow it to insert in only one...
Parking brake does not disengage.
Hello, I assuming that when you push the button on the parking brake lever the lever drops but the parking brake stays engaged. From what it sounds like there is a cable stuck, keep the parking brake applied. If you...
Key stuck in ignition of a 1988 Chevrolet Camaro
If this is an automatic you can try wiggling the shifter while trying to turn the keys, there is a rod that actuates a lock in the lock cylinder unless its in park. If that doesn't help the lock is...
fluids
Such a small amount of coolant may not completely damage the system, but you still do not want it in the power steering system. The power steering system uses a hydraulic fluid and engine coolant may cause the fluid to...
Ignition Lock cylinder issue
The attempted theft may have caused damaged to the housing behind the steering wheel. The spring loaded action comes from inside the housing and not the lock cylinder so I have a feeling you will either have to replace the...
Rough idling after new water pump and head gaskets. What now?
You have covered nearly all of the symptoms of what is normally a blown head gasket. Occasionally, when the computer reads a series of codes related to one issue when another is not immediately present and then the trouble codes...
Crank but no start.
Hello, thank you for writing in. These are all classic signs that the starter is failing. The starter will often progressively get worse as it wears out. The second sign that the starter is to blame is that it will...
Reman 600 cfm 4 bl eddlebrock carb on 390 preformer low rise intake on stock reman engine starts when throttle won't stay running
It sounds like your timing may be off slightly. Be sure the timing is at least very close to what it should be and then you can adjust the carburetor from there. I would also check to be sure the...
Can the fact that my long term fuel trim is -1.6 and short term is -2.3 be the cause of a P0422 on my 2000 Hyundai accent?
Hi Ashley. Thanks for contacting us today. The fuel trim numbers might be a symptom of the error code you are receiving, but not the source of the code. The P0422 OBD-II trouble code (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0422-obd-ii-trouble-code-main-catalyst-efficiency-below-threshold-by-brady-klopfer) suggests that the catalyst efficiency...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Chevrolet Avalanche
Few Few vehicles are as distinctive as the Chevrolet Avalanche. Part SUV, part truck, the Avalanche is actually surprisingly practical. On the inside, it feels more like a Chevy Tahoe, except when you look out your rearview mirror, you’ll notice...
2012 Kia Soul vs. 2012 Nissan Cube: Which One Should I Buy?
While technically these two vehicles fall into the “small wagon” classification, they look like nothing more than boxes on wheels. Some people are really into this design, while others are completely opposed to it. If you’re in the former camp,...
How to Buy a Good Quality Tow Hook
Tow Tow hooks come in a very wide range of styles, types and sizes depending on the application. They’re used for vehicle recovery, and can be attached to anything from a chain to a tow strap to the receiver on...